2 ms·
the climate window that has allowed for human life is very narrow, even by the standards of planetary history I remember when I was little, reading the Carl Sa
by AndrewKemendo 9y ago
the climate window that has allowed for human life is very narrow, even by the standards of planetary history
I remember when I was little, reading the Carl Sagan Cosmos book. It was based on the TV show, and had this really interesting section where it had pictures of what will happen on earth as the sun expands to a Red Giant [1].
That really stuck with me and ever since, it's clear to me that we humans live in a temporary golden period for the possibility of our form of life. Whether we burn ourselves out or wait for the environment to do it, the end result in a billion years is that there aren't humans in our form around anymore.
So whenever climate action comes up I ask: What is the end state that you are seeking? Is the goal to permanently solidify an undefined homeostasis? For what group? Are you trying to make northern Africa green again?
Again though, seems to be in vain cause it's all going to burn up in a few million years anyway. Climate action isn't TRULY long term thinking.
We have a tiny window that we can possibly engineer ourselves into a new form of intelligence. Lets work on that so that these biological issues, and our fate as a (transitional) species aren't issues anymore.
[1]http://static1.1.sqspcdn.com/static/f/398013/24076923/1387327371437/Sun.png?token=lBgC8gzFnsUMWh0mHw9WbSpxy4Y%3D http://static1.1.sqspcdn.com/static/f/398013/24076923/138732...
- mac01021 9y agoOk. Let's start by ensuring that our children and grandchildren have a livable environment in which to perform that work.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoAgreed. The one caveat I would make is in a case where something accelerated singularity tech, but was worse for warming/volatility, I would do the former.
- mfoy_ 9y agoWell, I'd argue it's all about buying time. Obviously nothing lasts forever, but that's no reason to throw the baby out with the bath-water. If we can buy our species another couple centuries on this planet, we can probably start looking at leaving. But if we continue on this accelerated doomsday course we won't have time to re-imagine the "form" of our species.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoAlso agree. I think we can practically do things that make sense economically, as well as environmentally that are no brainers like transitioning to renewable resources, solar, geo etc... The challenge is the lifestyle changes that transitioning economies expect in terms of total household energy expenditures. I think the biggest thing is helping developing and transitioning economies continue to raise their standard of living but through renewable resources, and not just piling more coal onto the fire.
- jerrylives 9y ago>We have a tiny window that we can possibly engineer ourselves into a new form of intelligence. Lets work on that so that these biological issues, and our fate as a (transitional) species aren't issues anymore. What about the entropic heat death of the universe? Seems to be in vain cause its all gonna settle to an equilibrium of nothingness. Transhuman action isn't TRULY long term thinking
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoYou joke but I struggle with that existential question all the time. I have a few silly theories about it, but it's a real philosophical problem.
- Houshalter 9y agoSometimes a big enough difference in quantity is a difference in quality. The difference between Earth surviving a 100 years or a billion is pretty significant. I can't even imagine how large a billion years is - it's just a mind bogglingly huge number. But my grand children will be around in a century - I might even be if medical technology improves or cryonics works. So it would be nice if the Earth is still in a nice state by then.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoYes well, the earth isn't going to be uniformly uninhabitable in anything like the near future.
- yongjik 9y ago> So whenever climate action comes up I ask: What is the end state that you are seeking? Is the goal to permanently solidify an undefined homeostasis? For what group? Are you trying to make northern Africa green again? That's all philosophical and nice, but it's just like asking everyone in the lower Mississippi basin "So what is the end game here? The river has changed its courses throughout geological history. Are we trying to lock it up in an artificial stasis?" And we could save billions of dollars spent on trying to artificially keep the river from flooding half of Arkansas. Somehow I don't think they would appreciate my wisdom. (In fact, it's actually worse; at least we don't have a "water industry" increasing the flow of the Mississippi every year and saying "But water is essential for life!")
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI grew up in Houston and for part of my life, we lived in a flood plane. From 2001-2008 our house flooded three times during Alison, Rita, and Ike. I moved out in 2002. I told my mom, maybe at a certain point you take the hint and move. So she did in 2010 right before the county expanded the Bayou system to that area. So yea, migration should be considered a standard part of life.