6 ms·
I'm in the TLD space (we run a fair number of gTLDs). If a gTLD operator screwed up like this then there could be consequences. A ccTLD, however, runs with ve
by CydeWeys 9y ago
I'm in the TLD space (we run a fair number of gTLDs). If a gTLD operator screwed up like this then there could be consequences. A ccTLD, however, runs with very few restrictions. I don't see much of consequence happening to it as a result of this.
I will, however, say that gTLDs are generally more secure and well-run than smaller ccTLDs, and are worth preferring for that reason. It's a weird historical quirk that .io randomly became popular in the developer community, but there are better options. And, as you point out, it's morally suspect, which is why we don't use it for new domain names.
- kuschku 9y agoThere are a few ccTLDs that differ from that, though. DENIC and CZNIC are two that are generally very well-run, DENIC even offering better security and safety than many gTLDs (while also being a cooperative, not a commercial NIC, so prices are very low, too)
- CydeWeys 9y agoThere's probably around a dozen ccTLDs that are really competently run and that are world-class. Beyond that I'd stick with competently run gTLDs. I actually just met a bunch of the denic guys at a conference they hosted a month ago in Frankfurt. They're on point with their Internet stuff.
- walrus01 9y agogiven the incredible importance to global internet infrastructure of things like the DE-CIX in frankfurt, I am not surprised that the Germans have their shit together when running critical back end systems.
- mcv 9y agoI think it's more than a dozen. I would expect all wealthy, tech-savvy democracies to have fairly competently run ccTLDs. It's just that there's about 200 countries in the world, and quite a lot of those are a complete mess.
- jtl999 9y ago.me and .ca "seem" competently run. More so for .me, ran by the owners of .org
- walrus01 9y agoif .ca was not competently run, I'm pretty sure the federal government would step in and put it into the hands of people with real DNS/network engineering credibility. Unlike the rarely used .us for the USA, it is used for the vast majority of canadian domestic corporations' web identities.
- sbarre 9y agoAnd also the Canadian government for that matter
- leipert 9y agoIt is really nice, that the .de domain is seen more as infrastructure than some business. But there are a few downsides to DENIC as well. 1. you need to have a person (juridicial or natural) with an address in Germany to register and list that person as ADMIN-C 2. if you run a website that provide contents which COULD generate revenue, you have to have an Impressum [1] which includes the address, names, etc. of the website owner. This is pretty annoying if you are sensitive about privacy and do not want your details out in the open. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impressum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impressum
- kuschku 9y agoWell, this is what every domain should have, though. A Ladungsfähige Anschrift of a person that is liable. This is a major criticism I have with many other domains, I don’t know where to send a C&D, or whom to sue if they violate my rights. And requiring only commercial entities to have these things also makes sense.
- walrus01 9y agomaking a single person personally liable for content that's hosted on a domain is problematic, to say the least. Go down that path and you eventually end up where the chinese government is now. Where you need a "license" from some ministry to operate an http daemon and you need to hire censors to police all user generated content that disagrees with an authoritarian regime's politics. https://www.google.com/search?q=china+lgbt+web&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&client=firefox-b https://www.google.com/search?q=china+lgbt+web&ie=utf-8&oe=u...
- leipert 9y agoAgree to disagree. Of the top of my head I can think of several useful things where a public (private) address would be problematic: 1. you want to do something like wiki leaks 2. you want to publish your thoughts anonymously, let's say you are from the LGTB spectrum and want to engage with people by building a forum or blog to communicate with them -> this could lead to potential problems with family, friends and work 3. you have political views and publish them. Now say someone disagrees with your views and is potentially aggressive. Do you want them to know where your family lives? 4. you do not wan't annoying calls by people who crawl the DENIC records (happens to me regularly) I agree with you that a person should be liable for the stuff they do, but should also be able to engage in open discussion while protecting their privacy. FWIW If someone does bad stuff on a .de domain there are several options: a) take down the domain via DENIC, or b) take down the domain via ISP or c) take down the domain via Hosting provider If you really did illegal stuff, I am with you and someone (DENIC, ISP or Host) probably should have the knowledge of the domain owner which could be subpoenaed to lawfully prosecute someone.
- walrus01 9y agoccTLDs don't appear to be held to very high standards. For example the .AF top level domain (which is controlled by the government's ministry of communications) doesn't even have a working website, www.nic.af
- CydeWeys 9y agoThey're not held to any standards, really. Some of the smaller ccTLDs are basically just run using hand-edited zone files and spreadsheets to track ownership and expiration thereof.
- coldpie 9y agoAs an average user, how do I know which is which? How can I tell whether .ABCXYZ is competently run and trustworthy? gTLDs & ccTLDs have to be some of the worst ideas in Internet history.
- CydeWeys 9y agoccTLDs are two letters long and gTLDs are everything else.
- walrus01 9y agoexcept all the new punycode IDN ccTLDs which now exist, for chinese, bulgarian, russian, etc.
- walrus01 9y ago> gTLDs have to be some of the worst ideas in Internet history. Not if you're an investor in Donuts, LLC, they're not...
- jmelloy 9y agoccTLDs (Country Codes) are always two letters. gTLDs aren't. The gTLDs have a pretty strict ICANN contract they have to follow; ccTLDs are looser.
- kijeda 9y ago_ASCII_ ccTLDs are always two letters. There are ccTLDs in other scripts that are of variable length (.ไทย, .ελ, .укр, .한국 etc.)
- guillon 9y agoccTLDs are loosers? Not according to their increasing registration figures.
- jodrellblank 9y agoLooser != loser
- bad_user 9y agoBesides the old .org, what better options are there for software projects?
- meddlepal 9y ago.sh and .run come to mind in some cases.
- CydeWeys 9y agoWe have .dev and .foo, which seem like they'd be good options, but neither are available for open registration. Sorry :(
- corobo 9y ago> .dev I really hope that one never becomes available..
- ebcase 9y agoPlay around at domainr.com, a brainstorming tool some friends and I made a few years ago. It supports all the new generic TLDs.
- walrus01 9y agowhat's wrong with the traditional .net ? software projects are pretty much all network related these days. or use the new gTLD .network which is pretty cheap to buy.
- Wicher 9y ago.build ?
- peterburkimsher 9y ago> "It's a weird historical quirk that .io randomly became popular in the developer community" The reason for me is totally clear: Github Pages gives me a free subdomain for http://pingtype.github.io http://pingtype.github.io but not .com. I registered http://peterburk.github.com http://peterburk.github.com before that policy changed.