10 ms·
This is a huge screwup on the part of the people who run the 'root' of .IO, and their entire operation should be severely scrutinized by ICANN. In my opinion a
by walrus01 9y ago
This is a huge screwup on the part of the people who run the 'root' of .IO, and their entire operation should be severely scrutinized by ICANN.
In my opinion almost all of the 'weird' TLDs which are country codes that are actually operated by a third party commercial service are 95% spam and junk registrations. .TV is a good example.
Technical screwups aside, the existence of .IO and the fact that it "belongs" to the UK government is morally questionable, since the entire country code only exists because the British and American militaries forcibly removed the original inhabitants of islands such as Diego Garcia so that they could use the area as naval and air force bases.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Indian_Ocean_Territory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Indian_Ocean_Territory
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diego_Garcia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diego_Garcia
If I had been able to successfully register these names and get live traffic going to a BIND9 instance, my first instinct would not be to alert the company through its first tier customer support levels, but to immediately post a summary of the problem to ARIN, RIPE, APNIC and ICANN mailing lists. This would get the issue in front of people who immediately understand how serious the problem is, and hopefully one of them would be able to contact the principals of .IO directly.
- peterwwillis 9y agoBad actors are on those mailing lists too. What you describe would be the equivalent of mailing fulldisclosure with "Hi all, there might be more unregistered nameservers at .IO (or another 101domains-serviced TLD) that could be used to attack live traffic if anyone wants to grab those, kthx"
- walrus01 9y agoI'm fine with that happening, because the people who run .IO need to be spanked. If their customers are subsequently unhappy that their domain names have been hijacked, they can take it up with whatever corporate entity runs .IO. Same problem as publicly disclosing serious flaws with an SSL/TLS root CA.
- peterwwillis 9y agoAh, I see you follow President Trump's incident response methodology.
- djsumdog 9y agoI own an .IO domain. Do I deserve to have fake LetsEncrypt certs issued against me and my domain hijacked because some engineer forgot to remove some critical NS records or forgot to register some aliases? Responsible disclosure cat is responsible!
- dogecoinbase 9y agoFrankly, yes, a little bit. You're choosing to run your website/infrastructure/etc with a dependency on a sketchy service with no oversight (the ccTLD system in general, but .io in particular). Unless you suffer for this choice, the market for provider competence will be broken.
- corobo 9y agoThat nobody had any idea was sketchy or un-oversighten until recently. It was not a choice to run their website/infrastructure/etc on sketchy services at all.
- dogecoinbase 9y agoNo. People who care about internet-scale infrastructural issues have known about these issues for a very long time. However, most people who utilize (and depend on) these services have not taken the time to understand how they work.
- corobo 9y agoBecause it's a simple transaction. I pay someone for a domain, I get said domain. Jimmy Throwawaysite shouldn't have to take the time to understand how DNS works above knowing how to set DNS records, the oversight should come from above. If ICANN wants to let anyone with a couple hundred thou run a TLD they should be making sure that entity can technically manage the TLD.
- venning 9y agoJust so no one is misled: "original inhabitants" does not mean "indigenous peoples" with respect to the BIOT. The islands were not populated prior to late-18th Century European colonization. The depopulation was of post-colonial people.
- panglott 9y agoWhy is that an important distinction? Is forcible expulsion and dispropriration more acceptable if the people were brought to the island as slaves and laborers in the mid-1700s?
- venning 9y ago> an important distinction That it is a distinction is important to me. Having difficult discussions is made more difficult if we obscure facts or conflate terms. > more acceptable I applied no normative judgement.
- nimchimpsky 9y ago> That it is a distinction is important to me. Why ?
- moo360 9y agoAre you being deliberately obtuse? It's a pretty important distinction that these were not some native tribesmen with millennia of ancestral history tied up in the lands.
- 3131s 9y ago100s of years though, so from the perspective of an individual on the island it's exactly the same -- their entire life was on that island. So, the distinction is pointless and reeks of apologetics IMO. "Sir Bruce Greatbatch, KCVO, CMG, MBE, governor of the Seychelles, ordered all the dogs on Diego Garcia to be killed. More than 1000 pets were gassed with exhaust fumes. "They put the dogs in a furnace where the people worked", Lisette Talatte, in her 60s, told me, "and when their dogs were taken away in front of them our children screamed and cried". Sir Bruce had been given responsibility for what the US called "cleansing" and "sanitising" the islands; and the killing of the pets was taken by the islanders as a warning."
- djsumdog 9y agoPeople make mistakes. This seems like some manual configuration/technical debt issues. Don't get me wrong, mistakes for these big, highly used TLDs is pretty massive. The scale of this is could have been devastating. Responsible disclosure to the company that runs the TLD seems like the right first step. This should probably posted on ICANN, ARIN, etc mailing lists even now, but I think the writer's original response is the right one.
- astrodust 9y agoThe people that make this sort of mistake should not be responsible for a TLD. This is one of the worst possible blunders imaginable. Considering they control the .io TLD these should have been registered and locked as reserved. That this wasn't the policy is but one of the many failings that lead to this outcome. If I were ICANN I'd slap them with a huge fine to send a message.
- sillysaurus3 9y ago*coordinated disclosure. "Responsible disclosure" is coercive.
- CydeWeys 9y agoI'm in the TLD space (we run a fair number of gTLDs). If a gTLD operator screwed up like this then there could be consequences. A ccTLD, however, runs with very few restrictions. I don't see much of consequence happening to it as a result of this. I will, however, say that gTLDs are generally more secure and well-run than smaller ccTLDs, and are worth preferring for that reason. It's a weird historical quirk that .io randomly became popular in the developer community, but there are better options. And, as you point out, it's morally suspect, which is why we don't use it for new domain names.
- kuschku 9y agoThere are a few ccTLDs that differ from that, though. DENIC and CZNIC are two that are generally very well-run, DENIC even offering better security and safety than many gTLDs (while also being a cooperative, not a commercial NIC, so prices are very low, too)
- CydeWeys 9y agoThere's probably around a dozen ccTLDs that are really competently run and that are world-class. Beyond that I'd stick with competently run gTLDs. I actually just met a bunch of the denic guys at a conference they hosted a month ago in Frankfurt. They're on point with their Internet stuff.
- walrus01 9y agogiven the incredible importance to global internet infrastructure of things like the DE-CIX in frankfurt, I am not surprised that the Germans have their shit together when running critical back end systems.
- mcv 9y agoI think it's more than a dozen. I would expect all wealthy, tech-savvy democracies to have fairly competently run ccTLDs. It's just that there's about 200 countries in the world, and quite a lot of those are a complete mess.
- 9y ago
- gist 9y ago> and their entire operation should be severely scrutinized by ICANN. ICANN does not have 'control' in any substantive way over the ccTld's. https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/cctlds-21-2012-02-25-en https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/cctlds-21-2012-02-25-e...
- inops 9y agoyeah...yeah...and the UK seized ".UK" from the Ukraine and this means... save your politics for politics, not for a technology discussion. We get it, you're moral.
- caryhartline 9y agoThat's not the same thing? If you're interested, the Ukraine TLD is .ua. To say they stole it from Ukraine in the same way they stole the .io TLD would mean that they would have to take over the entire country of Ukraine. Maybe the Russian government will have control of the .ua TLD someday.
- pmarreck 9y agoIn the mid 90's I got to spend a quiet and frankly wonderful 60 days on Diego Garcia while I was enlisted in the USAF. It is a wonderful island, you can bike around the whole thing in a couple hours, the rec facilities were great, beer was incredibly cheap, and the Internet (on such a remote island, in 1995!) was the best/fastest I had seen at that point. That all said, the forced expulsion thing (which I just caught up on) is news to me now. I guess bullies will always exist. It reminds me of forcibly relocating people in the US via eminent domain to build a highway. It's possible that an ethical argument can be made that if the security of the USA actually did depend on total control of that island, the cost in dollars and emotion of "strongly encouraging" people to move elsewhere might be justifiable (and I do believe they were compensated... the gassing of pets thing is shocking, though).
- Steeeve 9y agoThe idea that there should be a breakdown of domains by country is a bad one. There's this situation. There are many other situations where countries don't have the resources or drive to maintain what they have been allocated. And then there's the fact that there are enough domains conflicting with this structure that it makes no intuitive sense. The fact is that there is nothing that can be derived by an end user from most top level TLDs. EDU is one of the few, but then anybody can have a subdomain in an edu environment for any purpose. Maybe the time isn't now, but somebody should be thinking about how to replace the current domain management system and with what.
- dorianm 9y agoCloudflare For Top Level Domains? :)
- averagewall 9y agoJust about every country has had some war with people removed or killed by an occupier. America, for instance.
- icantdrive55 9y ago.io has been on my mind for months now. There is a guy who has a auction service for .io. He claimed his site is legit, and he's just a great Programmer, and Salesman. I forget the site, and he might be a straight shooter. I think I figured out his success. I think he scooped up thousands before he started the auction site, and people are basically just buying his domains. There's nothing wrong with that--I guess? My point is .io seems shady. I think they are overpriced. Yes--$99 bucks a year is $90 too much. I know the .io is popular among tech people. The rest of the world could care less.
- jahewson 9y ago> original inhabitants Is a pretty misleading phrase: they were 1000 or so slaves brought by the French to otherwise unoccupied islands. They should have been compensated like any other group of people whose government wants to build a military base, or a dam, or a highway on their land - but it's not like it was some kind of genocide. Much worse things have happened in pretty much every country on the globe.