9 ms·
Learning to run 100-mile marathons thanks to the science of self-control
- bbarn 9y agoa counter-point: http://nautil.us/issue/45/power/against-willpower http://nautil.us/issue/45/power/against-willpower
- mchanson 9y agoA much better article.
- gruturo 9y agoThird excellent nautil.us article in the span of 7 days for me - I'm starting to really like their style and subjects. Whitelisted on my ad blocker, and gave them my five bucks (well, 4.54 eurobucks). Other 2 articles I had found interesting (both found on YC): http://nautil.us/issue/50/emergence/how-the-oil-pipeline-began http://nautil.us/issue/50/emergence/how-the-oil-pipeline-beg... http://cosmos.nautil.us/short/161/how-much-should-expectation-drive-science http://cosmos.nautil.us/short/161/how-much-should-expectatio...
- bbarn 9y agoI actually subscribed to the print version last year. They're very high quality magazines, if a bit infrequent (every two months).
- Treegarden 9y agothanks, that was a really interesting article. Unfortunately it focused mainly on what "willpower" is dubious and not so much on what it is instead that helps one resist a craving. Only at the end the author wrote that the drinking lawyer had to much stress (underlying problem). But that isnt really a good general answer/explanation. I once read the book "the power of habit" and maybe that is the answer (its habits we need to control) but I am not sure.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 9y agoIn order to resist a craving you must have a craving, and that's why I don't like to think of it as will power. Edit: Maybe it's easier to talk about power to do things.
- sjg007 9y agoI think the cravings deplete themselves over time as you don't indulge them.
- pkghost 9y agoThe willpower hypothesis is one of the larger tire fires in the disaster that is reproducibility in psychology research. https://www.google.com/search?q=willpower+reproducibility https://www.google.com/search?q=willpower+reproducibility
- ttyl0125 9y agoFor a great summary, see: http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/cover_story/2016/03/ego_depletion_an_influential_theory_in_psychology_may_have_just_been_debunked.html http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/cover_story...
- sndean 9y agoI wonder how separate "willpower" is from the central governor theory [0]? Maybe they're completely unrelated and both tire fires. But I remember reading Tim Noakes' whole ~1000 page tome "Lore of Running" 15 years ago (in high school) which discussed the idea at length and thinking "If only I could have some control over my central governor, I could run under 4 minutes." Is that the same as hoping to "will your way" to a sub 4:00 mile? Not sure where the research stands now. [0] http://jeb.biologists.org/content/204/18/3225.short http://jeb.biologists.org/content/204/18/3225.short
- anbende 9y agoEasy, the tire fire is specifically in social psychology research. Other areas of psychology (e.g. cognitive, developmental, personality, etc) have their problems but in most cases no more so than other disciplines.
- 2309kdujj 9y agoTo be fair, the reproducibility crisis is widespread throughout many, many areas of science. There are many tire fires all over the place; people just started noticing it in a widespread way with social psych: http://www.nature.com/news/1-500-scientists-lift-the-lid-on-reproducibility-1.19970 http://www.nature.com/news/1-500-scientists-lift-the-lid-on-... Also, to be fair, the willpower hypothesis that was discredited is really about ego-depletion, the idea that willpower is (or reflects) a finite resource that is used by an array of neuropsychological processes. It's not that crazy of an idea, as there are many limits in human behavior and physiology.
- mankash666 9y agoResearch suggests a genetic preponderance towards physical fitness. With self control, you can make it to what your body can maximally achieve. But no amount of self control can guarantee the finish of an ultra-marathon if you're genetically not designed for it. PBS/Nova [1] took a shot at the question - "Can anyone run a marathon?", and found a certain lot more likely due to their genetics. [1] http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/body/marathon-challenge.html http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/body/marathon-challenge.html
- aezell 9y agoIt seems to me that the piece of data always missing in these kinds of challenges is time. I think anyone probably can run a marathon given enough time to change their lifestyle and build the appropriate strength and endurance. If that time is 10 years, then so be it for that person. The human body is designed to adapt to stressors and environmental conditions. The time it takes to adapt is where this genetic predisposition seems to come in to play.
- jackmott 9y agoMost people just walk these ultras, probably anyone healthy can do that with enough time to prepare. As well, probably anyone healthy can slowly jog a marathon with enough time to prepare. But not everyone can qualify for boston, or make the olympics.
- jontas 9y agoSource? I participate in these kinda of events.. I'd be interested to know where you are getting your information.
- jackmott 9y agolook up the average pace of the finish, do math. note: people have brought up aid station time, which, yes if you spent like 30 minutes at each this would being mid pack finishers up into the 'mostly running range' but its still amortized walking pace. This isn't meant to suggest that 100milers are easy or dumb, just that if you imagine someone actually running 100 miles straight and think that sounds nearly impossible, it is. Most people aren't doing that. If you think a 100 miler sounds interesting, you should try it, because you can probably do it. But please prepare really well because it is going to be really hard.
- water42 9y agoPeople die and people deal with it in different ways. I'm not sure what is unique about this. Lots of people learn to get in shape for marathons.
- codingdave 9y agoAnd if they all wrote about their experiences, I'm sure we'd read some of their articles, too.
- TheAlchemist 9y agoWillpower or not, I feel like running is really a great thing to do. Will Smith once said (or quoted, don't remember) that one should two things - run and read books. I definitely agree with that. I used to practice sports a lot, football and basketball and that had a positive effect on my teamwork ability. However, only when I started running I noticed how much this sport can influence one's life. There are no shortcuts, talent has almost zero influence, and it depends only on you how well you perform. I started about a year ago, more seriously about 3 months ago, and I already see how much I'm improving in other areas of life.
- Danihan 9y agoHow does talent have almost no influence? There are many genetic factors that would impact how strong a runner is. You mention football and basketball, which are essentially a series of short sprints. Sprints are _much_ healthier for people than 100-mile marathons that will essentially bathe your body in cortisol. http://www.marksdailyapple.com/the-evidence-continues-to-mount-against-chronic-cardio/ http://www.marksdailyapple.com/the-evidence-continues-to-mou...
- mmmpop 9y agoAs fairly average athlete myself, I think he's implying running is one of those sports that pure grit and determination can get you further ahead of the pack compared to many other sports. I'm just a skinny punk but I sure pass a lot of really buff guys when I run 5K races. Probably comes from a lifetime of running my mouth :)
- TheAlchemist 9y agoNot exactly. In football / basketball, so much depends on chance, your team, your opponents, the referee etc. You can work more / better and still end up with worse results. Or vice versa. In running, you mostly compete against yourself (unless you are a top athlete, but that's another story). You set your goals, you work to achieve them and it depends only on you. So yeah, grit , determination or however you call it, will make you progress, and you can measure it with an easy objective function (your time vs your past times, distance).
- HorizonXP 9y agoI'm a bit evangelical about low-carb, high-fat (LCHF) diets nowadays, especially keto. Personally, I'm not at the fitness level where I could conceivably run a marathon. Maybe a 5K or a half. But the article mentions him hitting walls as he hit certain mile markers, and having his wife help him reach the finish. This guy: https://youtu.be/96VZFklUM_Q https://youtu.be/96VZFklUM_Q runs ultra marathons, using fat for fuel. He leaves his fellow competitors in his dust because he doesn't have to carry glucose packets to keep his body fed. Instead, he finishes his race with an avocado and bison jerky.
- jackmott 9y ago>He leaves his fellow competitors in his dust because he doesn't have to carry glucose packets to keep his body fed. How do you know that is why he leaves others in the dust, vs him just being more talented, or training more, or training smarter, or just setting higher goals than the last generation of endurance runners? Also you should keep in mind that while there is at least a plausible story you can tell about > 5 hour endurance efforts benefiting from some kind of fat burning approach, from 5k to marathon, you absolutely want to be burning glucose if you want to go as fast as you can go. This is unambiguous.
- HorizonXP 9y agoI agree with the speed aspect, but I wish there were better studies that actually tested this. I realize that "explosive" power is diminished when you're burning fat vs. glucose, it would be interesting to know by what amount. Moreover, is it something that normal people need to know about or is it something that occurs at the extremes of performance? In regards to your first point, I mean, in the video, he stated that he used to try running with the glucose packets and he stated that he got sick trying to keep it all down, and it really slowed him down. It's anecdotal evidence of course, but I wasn't trying to present as anything other than that. :-) Edit: Holy run-on sentence. I'm going to leave it for posterity.
- jackmott 9y agoThe range of aerobic power that people put out is pretty huge, its possible that at the extreme low end, having no glycogen to burn wouldn't be a limiter, but certainly at the moderately trained average joe level, it is still a limiter. But early on, you don't need to worry much about it, just get out and move every day. If you keep it up for a year or two, and want to get faster, you can start adding things to be neurotic about =)
- Grustaf 9y ago”Bill Gates spent thousands of hours learning to program” Sure, and so did thousands of others. Bill Gates clearly didn’t become a modern Croesus because he was a better programmer, this is just trying to shoehorn Microsoft into the at once self-evident and ludicrous 10000 hour idea.
- paulpauper 9y agoa book that states what is otherwise obvious: a person with innate biological talent will get more 'mileage' from their 10000 hours won't sell as many copies as one that promotes the lie that 10000 hours will turn anyone into an expert at anything
- majelix 9y ago> ”Bill Gates spent thousands of hours learning to program” Here's the full quote: "Bill Gates spent thousands of hours learning how to program computers—but he only had that opportunity because he had the good fortune of having parents who supported his education." I think you're in violent agreement that 10,000 hours isn't sufficient.
- paulpauper 9y agoIt should be: how I learned to run 100 miles marathons due to having a high lactic acid threshold
- jmull 9y agoI'm sorry, but this is all gobbledygook. Nice ad for "sword" sportfood products, though. For one thing, running 100 mile races isn't a very good standard for willpower or self control. There is virtually zero use for this capability, so whether you spend 5-10 hours a week to do so or not isn't really a question of self control. It's a question of what activities/hobbies you want to pursue in your free time. Staying fit is a good-for-you type of thing, but you don't have to do anything close to that level of training to stay fit. My advice, whether you want to get/stay fit or achieve some athletic endurance goal is to make sure you find a way to enjoy the training. It takes consistent long-term training and you wont't have to worry about your willpower Or self control if you enjoy doing it. Along those lines: start slow - the hardest and most painful part is getting started. E.g., use a C25K program; find your own goals - whether that's completing 100 mile runs, or a 5K PR, or 1000 miles this year, or an 8:00 pace or a 365 day running streak or whatever.
- majelix 9y ago> There is virtually zero use for this capability [running 100 mile races] That's a major point of the article, given it's discussion of the spillover effect: "The bottom line: Practice self-control in one area of your life, and you can apply it in other parts, too."
- jmull 9y agoIt's nice that practicing willpower improves willpower, even across activities. But that doesn't suggest that's the best way to do it generally, or that running in particular is an effective or efficient way to do it. Look, I get it. I run and it takes time so there's pressure to justify it. But I don't see why the basic truth isn't enough: he enjoys it and it staves off his feelings of impending mortality. (In this case, I suspect he may also be trying to monetize it, but who knows.)
- rickpmg 9y agoI'm not so sure that's true... the example he gave about the non-dominant hand users being able to suppress their anger was questionable. Plus, a whole slew of writers say that willpower is an expendable resource.. resist the cookie in the morning, and you will be less likely to resist a candy bar in the afternoon..
- d--b 9y agoThis article angers me. 1. the guy is only an example. Willpower alone will not make you run 100 mile-race. You need the right body as well. 2. most people don't try and run 100 mile-races because they have better things to do 3. willpower and success: seriously this is really self congratulatory. running 100 miles does not make anyone a more succesful person. 4. no mention of endorphines and running addiction?
- majelix 9y agoThis article is less about specifically running 100 mile-races and more about doing something that requires self-control; and the claim is that doing so will make anyone a more successful person.
- kvhdude 9y agoi agree. i had will power to run a marathon just by myself - no event. I now have cervical herniated disc. No amount of my will power is useful. I just wish i had exercised common sense when my neck used to hurt after every long run.
- sushisource 9y agoNonsense. Unless you have some kind of disability anyone can run a 100 miler. That is completely true. You need to get in shape first, obviously, but unless you have a condition that prevents you from doing that, you can do it. I get the impression you haven't done much distance running, because the article is spot on when he says it's almost exclusively about determination. #2 just seems like you're being a dick. #3 is unprovable, and #4 is something I rarely hear any serious runner talk about, and it certainly isn't the reason I run at all.
- ErikAugust 9y agoI run ultras and mountain races. I ran one this Friday night into Saturday morning - a 12 hour overnight trail race where I managed 100K (62mi) in 11 hours and 23 minutes. Anyway, let's throw out willpower and even genetics for a second so I can bring up something: In today's age, virtually no one is even remotely close to their physiological limits. Literally, hundreds of people (elite marathoners, a few ultra marathoners, cross country skiiers) out of billions of people are bumping up against physiology. These people will do anything for the smallest performance gains (1%). Really, if you have not achieved a level where you are ~5-8% body fat and run consistently at 100 miles (or more) a week, you are not anywhere that close. Trust me. This is kind of even standard for competitive college distance runners - and even they are likely making mistakes that hold back their development (diet, drinking, running too many miles at too fast of a pace, etc.) Yet we can take someone who is 20% body fat, and runs 10 miles a week. You will find this person finishing an 100 mile ultramarathon. It's not that uncommon, if the time cutoffs are liberal. 18 minute miles is walking pace. The author even mentions he didn't think he was obese. He just didn't know the reality of things, I'd argue. He had to have this concept of willpower (concentration) to learn. And to change his diet and training habits. And even his understanding of what is possible. It's magical to chalk things up to grit - but there is so much process of knowing how the lows feel during a race, what to eat while training, how fast to do each run while training, how much to run while training, how to stay hydrated while racing, how to get nutrition while racing, etc. "Tough" or "in control of self" to me is too emotionally loaded. Edit: I almost feel bad writing this because it takes some of the magic that gets marketed about it. But this is a science-oriented crowd and should be exciting to know there is more of an opportunity for the objective than a lot of people believe.
- ErikAugust 9y agoLook at the consistently great 100 mile trail runners in the US - Ian Sharman, or Jeff Browning. Year after year. Look at how thorough they are. They are coaches because they know what to do and then they execute.
- kentt 9y ago> 18 minute miles is walking pace. Thank you for pointing this out. I'm so sick if people telling me they ran a marathon only to find out they walked. I'm totally fine with that being an accomplishment to finish, but it's entirely dissimilar to those who were racing.
- dogruck 9y agoI have finished six or seven 100 mile races. I've observed that the only apparent constant among all finishers is above average fitness, a reasonable approach to food and drink while racing, and a total commitment to finishing. Every race has some bare foot runners and some Hoka devotees. You see fat people and thin people. Old and young. Every finisher suffered tremendously, yet he or she refused to quit.
- pcunite 9y agoEvery finisher suffered tremendously, yet he or she refused to quit. I'm touching these words on my monitor. I can feel the pain. Ugh ...
- Gargoyle 9y agoI favorited this post because the top level comments are a perfect HN self-parody.
- jmcdiesel 9y agoThe fact that so many of the comments here are focused on running and its pros/cons and not on the actual point of the article (self control) ... its kinda strange for HN to completely miss the point by such a big margin...
- scintill76 9y ago> And so I set about fortifying my sense of self-control, based on the following factors: [Standards, Monitoring, and Strength] > Strength: ... I built my mental strength by running even when I didn’t want to—when I was sore, stressed, or sleepy. He built his will power by doing things he didn't have the will to do? One of the pillars of his self-control is that he has self-control? Maybe I'm missing something or jumping on the easy mockery, but this seems circular or common-sense.
- 09bjb 9y agoI don't see a problem with this. Habits are self-reinforcing, good or bad. If you can interrupt a bad habit once, or start a good habit once, you give yourself more momentum for the next go-round. You have X probability of successfully doing it the first time, and you may or may not do what you set out to. But whether you do affects the probability that you'll do it the next time. And I'd be wary of anyone that claims that they never, ever, have any say in the matter when it comes to doing something once, even if it's hard. I do agree with you in that by this same logic, you have a better chance of arriving at great self-control if you start with decent self-control.
- Bjartr 9y ago>I'd be wary of anyone that claims that they never, ever, have any say in the matter when it comes to doing something once, even if it's hard. When I hear "I don't have a say in the matter" I read frustration, not dismissal. I'd posit that when people say that, they don't mean it literally. Or, rather, it's the best they can articulate the internal struggle. I've found the language I know (English) to not provide me with the tools to describe the nuance of the sensation of lacking self-control or willpower. What I describe going forward is hard-won from long term introspection, and it still falls short of effectively communicating what I am really trying to say. I would wager that, for a not insignificant fraction of people, when they tell you they "don't have a say in the matter" they are trying to articulate the feeling/sensation of having the intellectual understanding of the situation i.e. (paraphrased for brevity) "I should do X because it has benefits Y and Z, instead of A which has downsides B and C" but where merely having that understanding is insufficient to compel (willpower, initiative, motivation, w/e) themselves to action, for however long they choose to linger on it in their mind.
- watwut 9y agoDoing sport as a hobby is pleasant. If you want test willpower, try sitting totally bored on playground every day because it is good for kids, try to come home sooner despite peer pressure and career hit because you matter for kids. Alternatively, try doing boring work you hate for hours because bills needs to be paid. It is less pleasant then doing sport you like.
- Dowwie 9y agochewable caffeine tablets? what could possibly go wrong with a combination of those and ultramarathons? (/s)
- samnwa 9y agoCan someone explain the point of all this? Is this to challenge your own ability to stick to a plan? Is it to impress others? The motivation alludes me entirely.
- didibus 9y agoI didn't see any science in this article. I was disappointed.
- didibus 9y agoI think what's good about fitness goals, is that they're all very achievable. If you are motivated, you're chances of success are almost 100%. There's not a lot of factors out of your control apart from the limits of your own body. In that sense, they're good for moral and confidence. If you struggled at other things, taking a goal whose success is in your hand, and for which failure has no consequence is a good way to test if you're the problem or not.