4 ms·
Well, the text is gussied up and there is plenty of dramatic license, but there were hundreds, if not thousands of startups that fit that description. Have a lo
by titzer 9y ago
Well, the text is gussied up and there is plenty of dramatic license, but there were hundreds, if not thousands of startups that fit that description. Have a look at the meteoric rise and fall of pets.com: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pets.com https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pets.com
For every high-profile one, there were dozens smaller ones that rose and fell on the same wave.
That's not to say that all .com companies crashed and died in that mess, but there were plenty.
- tptacek 9y agoThe bar your argument needs to clear isn't whether there were lots of Internet companies fitting Taibbi's falling watermelon description, but rather whether there are any that Goldman underwrote. Pets.com was underwritten by Merrill (also, against the notion that Merrill was packaging any bongwater-fueled idea presented to them is the fact that Pets.com was majority-owned by Amazon.) The target of the article is Goldman, not '90s Internet companies.
- microtherion 9y agoGoldman underwrote a lot of companies, if anybody wants to dig through the whole list: http://www.nasdaq.com/markets/ipos/offering-history.aspx?expert=goldman%2c+sachs+%26+co&page=24 http://www.nasdaq.com/markets/ipos/offering-history.aspx?exp... The first name I saw that IMHO would qualify as a watermelon was Etoys Inc.
- tptacek 9y agoI don't think that's a good example. For one thing, eToys had been in business for several years before IPO. For another, toys are a surprisingly difficult logistics problem for retailers (a friend told me stories about the bear of a time Amazon had with them). But most damning to the narrative Taibbi wants to sell, Goldman got in trouble with eToys --- for underpricing it. The founder of eToys went on to start Gamefly, and then took over as President of Gap Direct. This isn't to say that eToys is a solid company by the standards we set for modern tech companies. But it's not a watermelon thrown out of a window, either.
- microtherion 9y agoThe reason eToys stuck in my mind was their ham fisted legal battle against eToy: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/analysis-and-features/etoys-vs-etoy-743280.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/analysis-and-feat... Can we agree that WebVan was a watermelon company?
- tptacek 9y agoOf course not! Webvan was an enormous undertaking. No amount of bongwater gets you the service Webvan built --- a service, for what it's worth, that has also created several unicorns, an IPO, and the largest Amazon acquisition in its history. I was a Webvan customer in San Francisco, and it was better than anything I had for 10+ years afterwards. Be careful about what you're trying to argue. If Taibbi was just arguing that Goldman participated in the startup market, and that most startups fail, he'd be saying something true but banal. But that's not what Taibbi's saying. He's saying something that's not banal, but also probably not true.
- camelite 9y ago> But most damning to the narrative Taibbi wants to sell, Goldman got in trouble with eToys --- for underpricing it. I think you're underestimating Taibi's argument if you think the IPO-ing firm being pissed off at a later date argues against Goldman pulling off a scam, or that under-pricing and over-pricing can't be part of the same scam. There are 4 actors here: a) Goldman b) Goldman's preferred clients c) The company d) The investing public The argument goes that Goldman underprices the IPO initially. Their preferred investors get cheap stock. The stock goes public. The preferred investors have agreed to buy post-IPO stock. This causes the stock to rise. This rise doesn't appear to the investing public to be artificial, but a stock with momentum. This causes the price to shoot up. At some point the insiders take their gain and sell their stock. They then reward Goldman by channeling a significant portion of their profits back to them by using their underwriting services. As a post-script, the thing that first struck me was, if they screw their clients, how do they get new ones. Well if you read on to the next section, Taibbi explains part of that puzzle too: "Here the investment bank would offer the executives of the newly public company shares at extra-low prices, in exchange for future underwriting business." Losers: a) The company: they have less money to invest in their company's success, and fewer "long-haul" stock-holders than they would like. b) The investing public who buy high, sell low. Winners: a) Goldman's clients - buy low, sell high b) Goldman - they build long-term relationships with investors and skim some of the profit back directly Here's the eToys guy: After the deposition, he recalled, the S.E.C. lawyers began to show him some Goldman Sachs documents. He saw that one big firm after another had been allocated shares — and had immediately flipped them, even though Goldman had promised that its clients would support the stock. “That’s when I thought, ‘We really got screwed,’” Lenk told me. Although the experience still angered him, he now has 14 years’ worth of perspective. “Look at what has happened since then,” he said. “If you think eToys got screwed, what do you think happened to the country?” “What Wall Street did to us in 1999 pales in comparison to what they did to the country in 2008,” he said. http://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/10/opinion/sunday/nocera-rigging-the-ipo-game.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/10/opinion/sunday/nocera-rigg...