5 ms·
Devices are going to last all sorts of times - from a few months to years. Depending on what you pay for it. To legislate that no cheaper versions of things sh
by JoeAltmaier 9y ago
Devices are going to last all sorts of times - from a few months to years. Depending on what you pay for it.
To legislate that no cheaper versions of things should be available, even making them illegal, seems blind to the issues of those of limited means. It seems like a society pawn saying "I always buy Gucci; I mean why do they even make other brands? Har har!"
Demanding a warranty for instance would be a softer approach. But to make cheap, low-lifetime options actually illegal shows some fundamental misconception about how a free market works.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI'm not so sure. You know the saying, "I'm too poor to buy cheap". Cheap crap often ends up being bought again and again, because it breaks so often. I'm not convinced that raising the minimum quality floor would increase prices or make cheap products disappear. I give two reasons for that: one, manufacturing costs are usually only a fraction of the sticker price, and two, supply and demand - people of limited means are a market too, they have some money and want to buy stuff. My biggest worry here is that companies could respond by changing their business model from selling stuff to "hardware as a service" - i.e. since crappy products are disallowed, we'll make only premium products, but we'll only rent them out.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoAll true. But what's wrong with renting? Who needs to own a toaster? Why? I've long imagined a lifestyle-as-a-service business. Imagine pledging some (large?) fraction of your income for inclusion in an association that provides housing, transportation, appliances, food choices, vacation rentals etc as a service. A sort of concierge life. Just join and move in!
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI feel this would work only for people who live the exactly average lives. You know, "people made out of ticky tacky, who all look just the same"[0]. The moment you want to make something outside of the catalogue, or outside of the standard schedule, you'll be hitting the limits of service model. That said, I find myself wishing for some of my life to be turned into a service. I'd gladly give away a large fraction of my income in order not to have to bother with most house appliances, food, shopping and clothing. But I suspect different people would prefer a different set of services. The risk is that, as everything becomes a service, there will be no products at all, and you either take a service or live (die?) without it. [0] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LM8JhvfoqdA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LM8JhvfoqdA
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoAll in the design. Don't like your service? Join another. Not a big deal to move - no belongings, just show up at another complex tomorrow night! And options have to be a big part of it. Sign up for the pub-crawl package, or the comicon package, or join the swinger subgroup or whatever. Upgrade your appliance package, get a good kitchen or no kitchen at all. Need garage space - choose from the brochure from basic oil change to grease rack. Cute vid by the way. But I always was suspicious of that song - calling a house 'ticky tacky' is bourgeois talk (oh look they can't even afford the best) which is at odds with the message.
- kbart 9y ago"To legislate that no cheaper versions of things should be available, even making them illegal, seems blind to the issues of those of limited means." That's why we can't have nice things (i.e. Paris agreement).
- Brakenshire 9y ago> It seems like a society pawn saying "I always buy Gucci; I mean why do they even make other brands? Har har!" Not at all, Gucci is almost entirely without objective value relative to its increased cost, a fridge that lasts 10 years rather than 5 years, all else being the same, is objectively better than the alternative. Also, it's highly likely that any direct legislation would work through a minimum warranty, like the laws which already exist.
- kuschku 9y ago> Demanding a warranty for instance would be a softer approach. That already exists, and it leads to many companies just throwing products away and replacing them several times over the warranty period. This increases prices, and is worse for the environment. Yet, companies try to use DRM and copyright laws to prevent people from repairing products.