5 ms·
Someone is losing their job unexpectedly. Nearly everyone spends too much of their income and saves too little for retirement/emergencies, so losing your job un
by pc86 9y ago
Someone is losing their job unexpectedly. Nearly everyone spends too much of their income and saves too little for retirement/emergencies, so losing your job unexpectedly can have devastating financial consequences. Even bouncing back and finding another job could set your retirement back years if it doesn't happen quickly enough, and ruin your credit if you don't have appropriate savings.
I don't think there's a way to make it "more human." The opposite extreme of your scenario is bringing everyone (either on site, or everyone getting laid off) into a room and break the news in one shot. I've had coworkers who have been laid off in the "put everyone in a room" way. 60 people told at the same time their position had been eliminated, leave their badge at the door on the way out. That's not any less cold. I'd argue individually telling folks is better. It lets people have an emotional reaction if they need to, and not have to worry about the other dozens of people around them.
If you need to lay off many people at once, there is no good way to do it.
- jacobr1 9y agoThe way to make it more humane is a generous severance.
- pc86 9y agoSeverance just accelerates the firing process. If you've got to provide 3 months severance, you're laying people off at least 3 months sooner than you otherwise would. I'm sure there have been companies contemplating layoffs that have been able to just barely make numbers to avoid it. Not arguing against severance just saying that "well throw some money at them" doesn't necessarily make it any better.
- syshum 9y agoIt does not make it better for the companies, but it does make it MUCH better for the employee, as they now have 3 months to find a job before having to dip into any savings, retirement, or make painful phone calls to creditors looking for payment forgiveness and other things Companies generally do not tell you 3 mos in advance you are being laid off, so if there is no severance then you are blind sided and are instantly with out income I would much rather my layoff come 3mos sooner and have 3 months to look for a job before having no income, then been "allowed" to continue to work 3 months longer with no severance
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoAccelerating it is exactly what makes it more humane. You now have 3 months to find another job instead of immediately losing income.
- soneil 9y agoOurs is 8 weeks pay per year worked. I’ve got a friend going through this at the moment, with 20 years under his belt. You may not be that surprised to hear that he’s not bitter at all, and has every intention of working ‘till his last day.
- keithpeter 9y ago"Nearly everyone spends too much of their income and saves too little for retirement/emergencies, so losing your job unexpectedly can have devastating financial consequences." UK: in larger organisations (I mean big enough to have more than say 20 employees being made redundant) there is a consultation process that lasts a month or can last up to three months depending on the number of people being made redundant. There is a process that has to be kept to and there is a statutory minimum amount of redundancy pay [1] as well as payment in lieu of notice. Redundancy payments are tax free up to a limit The result is in my experience less secrecy (consultation period) and some sort of financial safety net, at least a few months worth. [1] https://www.gov.uk/redundant-your-rights/redundancy-pay https://www.gov.uk/redundant-your-rights/redundancy-pay
- grogenaut 9y agoHow shitty do the employees get during the consultation period?
- gaius 9y agoOften there is no requirement that they come in during this period, it's one form of "gardening leave".
- bboreham 9y agoConsultation happens before the decision is made* about who is leaving and who will still have a job. * officially made
- keithpeter 9y agoInterpersonal relationships can become 'interesting' during this period, but deliberate vandalism would be self-selection for redundancy and possible criminal action. Management become very 'correct' - to the extent of external 'consultants' sitting in on meetings and taking notes - and you can bet on morale being significantly impacted during and for up to a year after a long consultation. As pointed out below, the consultation period is before those being made redundant are (officially) selected. In large organisations - for extra fun - you have things called 'redundancy pools' based around areas of work or grades that all share a risk of redundancy but only (e.g.) 5 out of 25 will actually be made redundant. I should also point out that larger orgs often offer voluntary redundancy at enhanced terms within given 'pools' - unions where they exist will often bargain for enhanced terms. Not a pleasant time but does give people weeks/months to find something else and take what financial precautions they can - and perhaps decide that 'VR' (voluntary redundancy) is possibly attractive. Yes, you do lose good people sometimes.
- EGreg 9y agoI would definitely prefer the mass-firing way. Because people feel strength in numbers and don't beat themselves up that only THEY are being let go. If all those other people are being fired - including Bob over there who (50% chance) worked harder than me - then it's not my fault.