3 ms·
A system designed like that is flawed and insecure, and someone else with more resources--probably someone much more evil, sadly--is going to have figured out a
by saurik 9y ago
A system designed like that is flawed and insecure, and someone else with more resources--probably someone much more evil, sadly--is going to have figured out a way to get to that key... we should want to air that to the light of day and get that fixed.
I mean, at some level your comment turns into "we should try to hide the security flaws we have as much as possible, even from the people who are actively trying to help the world be more secure"... if you aren't serious about finding bugs, why bother with security?
- Someone 9y agoI don't understand that logic. Apple built a safe. If I want to check that it is secure, it would be helpful if they built one from glass, so that I can see how the mechanism works, and thus verify the design. My argument is that that may expose a secret stored in that safe that then can be used to break into 'real' safes. Your argument seems (to me) to be there should be no secrets on that phone that make attackers any the wiser (might well be possible, given the existence of asymmetric encryption). If so, why did Apple go to the effort to add the secure enclave?
- willstrafach 9y agoSaurik is correct about security through obscurity not really being helpful, but for what it is worth, this: > Countermeasure would be to have separate keys, ideally for each such phone, but having them for only this class of phones might be sufficient, too, if they also restrict access to this class of phones. I think that's technically easy, but may be expensive, process wise. ...is already something Apple does with the special development devices. Different keys and certificates used, probably to allow easier access for engineers while tightly monitoring and auditing production infrastructure.
- saurik 9y agoThe goal of the secure enclave is to protect your information (the signature of your fingerprint, the encryption key of your flash memory, etc.) from people who want to steal your device and access that information without your passcode by decapping the chip and reading its content. It is not there to protect some kind of global security key from Apple (we live in a world with public/private key cryptography... there's almost no reason why some key would exist on the device that is somehow critical to its security, and if it did exist it would mean a complete security failure).