2 ms·
I think the other poster sufficiently deconstructed your argument one way, but I want to point out that you haven't made any case that slavery is a red herring.
by naasking 9y ago
I think the other poster sufficiently deconstructed your argument one way, but I want to point out that you haven't made any case that slavery is a red herring. Like, at all.
If this debate were taking place just prior to the civil war, there would be significant debate over whether slaves had human rights, and many making the economic case for slavery.
RMS is trying to tell you the same thing right now: that DRM is a tool that takes away some basic human rights, and instead of taking a moment to think about it, you simply dismiss it out of hand merely because you can see an economic case for it.
So take a few moments to consider the worst possible outcomes of adopting DRM, and whether history will regard the economic case for DRM as harshly as it regards the economic case for slavery.
- andrewflnr 9y agoYou're responding to a bunch of things I didn't say and don't believe. I'm not a fan of DRM, just defending the position that RMS isn't the best source on it. Also, you yourself haven't made an argument that DRM is anywhere near as bad a problem as slavery was. It's nowhere close, and to imply otherwise is to cheapen the suffering of slaves in America. Is that enough of an argument that it's a red herring?
- naasking 9y ago> Also, you yourself haven't made an argument that DRM is anywhere near as bad a problem as slavery was. This judgment was made with perfect hindsight in one case, and no hindsight in the other, so the conclusion is immediately suspect. Like I said, consider the worst possible nightmare for DRM, and then judge whether the comparison is actually fair. Finally, whether RMS is the best source on it is itself a red herring. If he makes a reasonable case for a nightmare outcome, his perspective is absolutely worth considering when weighing the pros and cons of DRM, regardless of how absolutist you think he is.
- andrewflnr 9y agoYou have the same lack of time machine as I do in regards to DRM. For the rest, I think I've made the points I care about well enough.