4 ms·
> Conceptually it's the: eventually you have to launch, problem. Why do you have to launch? If we can't solve our serious problems on Earth, what do we expect
by geofft 9y ago
> Conceptually it's the: eventually you have to launch, problem.
Why do you have to launch?
If we can't solve our serious problems on Earth, what do we expect to gain by going into space?
- pjc50 9y agoAnd don't we just risk taking them with us? (Theme of counless scifi, e.g. Clarke's Songs of Distant Earth)
- justinpombrio 9y ago> If we can't solve our serious problems on Earth, what do we expect to gain by going into space? A colony on Mars! I'm sorry, I really don't get the question.
- ivanbakel 9y agoGP was asking why GGP said we had to launch. This isn't a software project with a management deadline - space travel is an active human decision. What requires that we start launching at all?
- justinpombrio 9y agoA colony on Mars! Don't you want a colony on Mars? I still don't get the question.
- geofft 9y agoI don't want a colony on Mars. What would I do with it? Why do you want one?
- stale2002 9y agoUhh, there are lots of valuable resources in space. If we can mine 1 asteroid, we can get more valuable metals from that than have ever been mined on earth.
- friedman23 9y agoDo you honestly believe we will achieve post scarcity society without leaving Earth?
- vacri 9y agoHow is having a small dependent colony of tunnel-dwellers on Mars going to give us a post-scarcity society?
- dwaltrip 9y agoThe same way Columbus gave us our massive modern international shipping infrastructure. It's a small step in a large process. You don't just jump from A to B. In this case, getting nearer to post-scarcity will undoubtedly involve capturing a much larger portion of the Sun's energy output (only one billionth reaches Earth), which will require significantly more developed space industries. Or if fusion becomes viable, we will need to harvest some of the more efficient inputs, such as He3 from the moon. The technologies we develop to accomplish these endeavors will provide enormous benefits to all humans, including those still living on Earth.
- friedman23 9y agoMars has nothing to do with it. We simply do not have enough resources on this planet to provide everyone with everything they desire without destroying the planet in the process..
- tptacek 9y agoMalthusians have been making and being embarrassed by that argument for hundreds of years. Meanwhile, the standard of living for all people on the planet increases, and the link between that increase and resource consumption is not linear. Given the history of the argument, it seems forgivable to assume that the people who make it in the context of space travel are simply besotted by the romance of space travel.
- geofft 9y agoAnd do we have the resources on two planets to provide everyone with everything they desire? Or ten, or a hundred? If you know what the bound is on the resources needed to satisfy people's desires, and that's a finite number of planets greater than one, sure. But if you don't have a bound, it's going to be far more effective to adjust people's desires. (And if you do have a bound, and it's slightly greater than one, it may still be more efficient to adjust people's desires to get it to less than one than to expend the engineering work needed to build a multi-planet civilization.)
- olegkikin 9y agoWhy didn't you sell your computer to donate to the starving children? Why did you even buy it in the first place?
- geofft 9y agoOne, because donating money to starving children is not a sustainable solution, and I believe that I can generate more long-term benefit for humanity from using my computer than from selling it. Two, I literally bought this computer from a charity auction. (Are you actually genuinely unclear on why "sell everything you have" is not an ethical imperative, or are you trolling?)
- Balbazac 9y agoPeter Singer would like to have a word with you. Disclosure: I strongly disagree with his (Singer's) thoughts on this matter.
- johncolanduoni 9y agoThere's a lot of reasons to go to space other than trying to fix problems or run away from them. If the latter is your thing you're much better off with a forest than space.
- prawn 9y agoHaving a second basket for our eggs?