10 ms·
You're making false comparison here. DRM is extremely invasive - it's akin to being forced to wear handcuffs inside a store to prevent theft, or perhaps being s
by izacus 9y ago
You're making false comparison here. DRM is extremely invasive - it's akin to being forced to wear handcuffs inside a store to prevent theft, or perhaps being strip searched every time you walk past a store. Both of those actions can also be sold as "business protection against theft", but our legal framework currently says that we're ready to tolerate some amount of shoplifting and we're not going to allow stores to strip people naked at the exit to check for stolen goods. The profit fallout of shoplifting is just too small to allow for such egregious attacks on legitimate customers.
Same story with DRM - yes, piracy IS illegal. But DRM as a response is hugely disproportionate to damage done, causes huge issues to LEGITIMATE buyers. What DRM proponents defend is attacking paying customers with restrictions, lockdowns and costs to hunt a rather small profit loss (the relative smallness of lost sales due to piracy have been repeatedly demonstrated in these last years).
- maxerickson 9y agoAt least for the US, I think you are overestimating the restrictions on private establishments. Stores don't do invasive things because it doesn't make business sense, not because the legal system particularly enjoins them. Like if I opened a candy shop that required agreeing to an NDA for entry, what law do you think would make me let people in without signing the NDA? It might not be enforced, but there isn't anything that would stop me from requiring the signature for entry (other than it being silly).
- hellbanner 9y agoShowing that contract up front I would guess your customers would leave. Many movie pirates aren't aware of the laws (eg. kids)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- izacus 9y agoIt was just an analogy to make it easier to demonstrate the disproportionate effect DRM has on paying customers. I don't particularly care about entering into a debate about what kind of abuse of people US laws allows.
- maxerickson 9y agoFair enough. The disproportionate effect DRM has on paying customers doesn't seem to be obscure or difficult to think about though.
- type0 9y agoBut DRM isn't NDA so what is your point here?
- maxerickson 9y agoI don't like analogies.
- dasil003 9y agoThe risk to a shoplifter is unfathomably larger than the risk to a pirate, and the leakage is infinitely less. Analogies generally don't serve this debate well. Saying DRM is like physically invasive security to your person is just as ridiculous as Studios' claims that piracy is the same as theft. Both attempt to communicate real issues, but are ridiculously inaccurate.