4 ms·
> you're comparing different times > Compare to the hypothetical It's invalid to compare the present with the past, but valid to compare the present with a pr
by throwanem 9y ago
> you're comparing different times
> Compare to the hypothetical
It's invalid to compare the present with the past, but valid to compare the present with a present that never was?
- cma 9y agoThe past isn't a possible present (it is still fine to compare if there are enough analogs).
- thinkfurther 9y agoIf I just said "it would be better to behave more honestly", what would the response be? More often than not, something along the lines of "I know why it would seem that way, of course honesty should be used whenever possible, but diplomacy being so complicated and humans so mean, what actually would happen when you're too honest (or don't have double standards, etc.) is blah blah blah". If you disagree, make an argument against it without any such invalid comparisons [It doesn't matter if you say the word "compare", if you don't want to see the woods for all the trees you'll always find excuses anyway and I for one don't need to hear them] because otherwise, there isn't even anything there I need to argue against, and anything beyond pointing that out is just a bonus for someone who doesn't get or doesn't like the point to get hung up on, if you will. On HN it's usually silence or responses like that, bleh, look for the least generous reading, squirt out a one liner. Oh well, you do you.
- throwanem 9y agoSo you'd be happier with an empire honest about its behavior than one which seeks to dissemble about it? I mean I'm having kind of a hard time figuring out what you're getting at here, is what I'm trying to say. Can you explain it in a way that involves less vague inveighing against ill-characterized malfeasance, and a more coherent statement of what you're actually about?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]