3 ms·
The outcome looks suspiciously like the real-world wealth distributions that we presume to be the result of efficient free markets. Is capitalism mostly noise?
by pavlov 9y ago
The outcome looks suspiciously like the real-world wealth distributions that we presume to be the result of efficient free markets.
Is capitalism mostly noise?
- Retric 9y agoNo, this is fairly linear distribution. Capitalism produces exponential wealth curves. Further, if you do running average over very long time frames the averages will converge. Aka weathly will become poor then wealthy again.
- lou1306 9y agoExcept that, in the real-world, wealthy people will spend more money than the poor. I wonder what we outcume would be if each agent spends a random amount of money that depends on their current wealth (say, anything between $1 and 5% of the total).
- js8 9y agoAlso wealthy people have much bigger gains from investment (what money they already have), which will ultimately cause the distribution to be much more exponential than the one from the simulation. I suspect giving away a proportion would have no significant effect on the result, because poor and wealthy have still the same likelihood of receiving money.
- neilwilson 9y agoAnother illusion. A millionaire always spends less than a million people with a dollar.
- lou1306 9y agoTrue, but typically he will spend more than _one_ single person with a dollar. I created a gist (https://gist.github.com/lou1306/1041ed6cd4eed433cfabf45f666bf298 https://gist.github.com/lou1306/1041ed6cd4eed433cfabf45f666b...) to try and prove my point a little better: when people are only allowed to pay $1 to one another, the resulting distribution is quite unfair (as shown in the original post). However, when payments can be as big as, say, 2-10% of the player's wealth, there is a noticeable decrease in the Gini coefficient.