3 ms·
It's hard to take people like Naggum very seriously when the languages they so self-righteously dismiss (C, C++, perl, Java) are used every day to build softwar
by cageface 16y ago
It's hard to take people like Naggum very seriously when the languages they so self-righteously dismiss (C, C++, perl, Java) are used every day to build software at all scales of complexity and Lisp remains an essentially irrelevant niche.
He also completely misunderstands free software. It's not about giving things away for free. It's about sharing the grunt work so we can focus on doing new things.
Naggum is an extreme example of the somewhat common example of the grumpy old man that refuses to understand or accept change. You can find much better gurus if you want a guru.
- zachbeane 16y agoThis is the sort of thing someone might write if their entire exposure to Erik Naggum's writing was that single blog post. Your summary is inaccurate.
- cageface 16y agoI read Naggum's posts regularly on comp.lang.lisp for years. They always generated much more heat than light. He was entertaining but terribly misguided. I don't miss him. I do kind of miss Xah Lee though.
- dman 16y agoMath remains an essentially irrelevant niche according to your definition of relevance - no of exponents. Lisp remains a great vehicle for exploring ideas and writing algorithmic code. Also in response to your other post, comparing Naggum to Xah is doing Erik a disservice in my opinion.
- cageface 16y agoI like Lisp but ridiculous statements like this: Using such inferior languages is like asking a chef who could have done wonders with any kind of raw materials, to use a dirty kitchen, a broken refrigerator with food that is about to die a second time, broken tools, and brownish tap water that tasted of swamp land. just fly in the face of all the available evidence. When I was new to Lisp I took bullshit like this at face value. This is a poisonous line of thinking I'd encourage all new programmers to avoid. Naggum was worse than Xah. As another poster in this thread pointed out, his shockingly intolerant vindictiveness and cruelty were disgusting. If you're looking for "wisdom" then keep walking. Lisp has had the misfortune of attracting bright but nutty people like Naggum all along. It's held the language back quite a bit.
- vsync 16y agoDon't forget - besides the exploration of algorithms dman mentioned - that languages such as Perl, Java, Ruby, Python, etc benefit from the experience and precedent of the Lisps. I'm always chagrined when I see the kids in some popular language community pretending like some 40-year-old technique is new and brought to the table by their favorite toy. But at least usually the heritage is respected and mistakes avoided by looking to the examples provided by the Lisps.
- chromatic 16y agoSuch languages often gladly borrow ideas introduced by Lisps and make them available to larger groups of people. While the world would be a very different place if more people used Lisp than other languages, half a century of history suggest that that will not happen soon.