5 ms·
Great insight! You can see this not only at the macro level (Google winning all of search by being marginally better than competitors), but at the micro level (
by ryandrake 9y ago
Great insight! You can see this not only at the macro level (Google winning all of search by being marginally better than competitors), but at the micro level (top employee out of a team of 10 gets the bonus/promotion while everyone else gets nothing), and probably everywhere in between.
What I wonder is: Is this really an intrinsic quality of capitalism? What causes this "winner take most" reward system emerging in some areas of the economy but not others? In many industries, multiple competitors can exist with stability and split market share, and in others, having multiple competitors leads to a blood bath where only one can survive, winning it all.
- the_cat_kittles 9y agoyes i wonder about that too. i never thought of myself as someone interested in economics, but i guess thats where you'd look for answers to why some markets are weighted towards winner take all and some aren't. my guess off the top is that it has to do with how easy it is to switch between two competing products, and how economies of scale work in the industry. if there is a big economy of scale, and its easy to switch between competitors, i think that makes for the biggest winner take all scenario.
- kevinnk 9y agoI think the more fundamental connection is that when goods are perfect subsitutes for each other, under perfect information you always choose the "cheaper" good (where "cheap" is defined by whatever metric you're using). Somewhat ironically, this fact actually has connections to the concept of dual variables in constrained optimization problems, the theory of which was largely developed in the Soviet Union for use in central planning.
- the_cat_kittles 9y agovery interesting! that seems to make sense. do you know of any good writing on examples?
- tenkabuto 9y agoI suspect that in industries with strong network effects, the winner-takes-most system is most prevalent, as say, one additional unit could mean stealing three units away from competitors in the long-term.
- WalterBright 9y ago> Is this really an intrinsic quality of capitalism? Hardly. The history of capitalism shows that absent government intervention to prop up companies, they rise and fall. When I started out, everyone was a-feared that IBM would inevitably take over the world. Then Microsoft dethroned them, and Microsoft was going to take over the world. Then Apple dethroned Microsoft. And on it goes. There was Sears that dominated retail. Then Walmart shoved them aside. Now Amazon stepped all over Walmart. See "The Innovator's Dilemma" by Christensen for a book full of examples.
- bitwize 9y agoIsn't Christensen one of those thought leaders who are paid by megacorps to spread Gramscian false consciousness and make the masses think capitalism really isn't so bad?
- scottLobster 9y agoSounds like you already have your conclusion in mind, so why ask the question?
- xapata 9y agoIs this irony?
- valuearb 9y agoYes, facts don't matter, only the political pedigree of the person relating them.
- WalterBright 9y agoI prefer to read books where the author tries to prove me wrong. Books that agree with me are boring :-)
- Rusky 9y agoAll of those companies exist in a world with the threat of anti-trust regulation, and some were directly affected by it. There are plenty of counterexamples from before that regulation, and there are still some today (e.g. ISPs).