6 ms·
> But since the boy could be either the younger or the older child, the analysis is more subtle. Devlin started by listing the children’s sexes in the order of
by bad_user 16y ago
> But since the boy could be either the younger or the older child, the analysis is more subtle. Devlin started by listing the children’s sexes in the order of their birth
Personally, when I read that I could spot the error. For lazy people (tl;dr types) ... order doesn't matter as you're not given any info about that order.
So given 2 children, there are only 3 possibilities ...
boy, boy
girl, girl
boy, girl
So if you're told one of them is a boy ...
boy, girl
boy, boy
And that's it ... a 50% probability that both children are boys.
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoYou can't mean that. There are four possibilities: Older child boy, younger child boy Older child boy, younger child girl Older child girl, younger child boy Older child girl, younger child girl Of those only one is precluded by saying (at least) one child is a boy.
- bad_user 16y agoNo there aren't ... notions of order like older/younger don't enter the equation (as the problem was stated). Oh well, I guess this is what the article is talking about :)
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoLet's toss two coins until at least one shows a head. By your reasoning the odds of them both being heads is 1/2. It's not. Try it. Suppose I roll two dice until at least one of them shows a 6. What's the odds of both being 6's? I've said nothing about the red die versus the blue die, but the underlying truth requires that the situations are kept separate. It's only - as far as we know - in quantum mechanics where you deliberately lose the distinction. I've done these as real world experiments as I explore them with kids, and I have a lot of direct experience. If you disagree then I'd be delighted to gamble with you.
- bad_user 16y ago> Let's toss two coins until at least one shows a head. By your reasoning the odds of them both being heads is 1/2. It's not. Try it. You haven't read the article then ... the problem as stated in the article is that you know one coin is going to be a head, so what's the probability of the other one also being a head? Of course ... the events aren't connected ... the second coin toss doesn't depend in any way on the first coin. That's why I think there's something wrong about the article ... saying that the probability is 33% fails both intuition and elementary probabilistic.
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoHere's the problem as Gary originally stated it, and as the article quotes it: > I have two children, one of whom is a son born > on a Tuesday. What is the probability that I > have two boys? You say: the problem as stated in the article is that you know one coin is going to be a head, No. The point of the article is that you don't know how or why you are given this information. Suppose I toss two coins until I get one that's a head, then I tell you that I have two coins, and one is a head. I've complied with the problem as described. The probability that they are both heads is 1/3. I was there when this problem was posed. I was in the room when the questions were asked, and Gary clarified. I had lunch with Gary afterwards, and he said it was deliberate that it was ambiguous. It seems to me that you're missing the point. Perhaps you should explain clearly exactly how you think the situation arises where the information given is as described.
- bad_user 16y ago> The probability that they are both heads is 1/3. The probability they are both heads is 1/2. You're trying to formulate this as .... P(head AND head | one is a head) = P(head AND head) / P(one is a head) = 1/4 * 4/3 = 4/12 = 1/3 But this is wrong ... you know that you have a head ... which makes ... P(one is a head) = 1 && P(head_a AND head_b) = P(head_a) = P(head_b) 1/3 would be the probability only on the first try (instead of stopping when you've got a head).
- NeilCJames 16y agoOlder/younger doesn't exactly enter into it, but some ordering is necessary to properly describe the set of probabilities. This can be arbitrary, but birth order makes the most intuitive sense. The set of probabilities of sex distribution in two-child families is [(B, B), (B, G), (G, B), (G, G)], for any arbitrary ordering, this cannot be reduced to [(B,B), (B,G), (G,G)] as you have done without adding a variable to double the probability of (B,G). Assuming a coin-flip probability for boy/girl distribution, you get the 1/3 answer if we select for two-child families where at least one child is a boy: [(B,B), (B,G), (G,B)]. If we don't pre-select for having at least one boy, (i.e. if we select the family because we just met the father socially), the probability rises to 1/2, because we have two cases to consider, each with a 1/2 probability: [(B,B), (B,G)], and [(B,B), (G,B)].
- bad_user 16y agoYes, but this is wrong ... the sex of the second child is in no way connected to the sex of the first child. He didn't ask ... what's the sex of the second child? No ... he asked ... p(boys = 2 | boy >= 1) == p(child = boy) Choosing a distribution that involves both children in this case is wrong, hence my answer that ordering doesn't matter. 33% is just wrong.
- NeilCJames 16y agoWhat I wrote is not wrong unless, when you wrote: "So given 2 children, there are only 3 possibilities ... boy, boy girl, girl boy, girl" you are asserting that in the absence of any information about the sex of either child, 2 boys is a 1/3 probability, instead of (1/2)*(1/2)= 1/4.
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoActually, I'm going to stop now: http://xkcd.com/386/ http://xkcd.com/386/ It's pretty clear I won't convince you. Let me leave you with these questions: If I toss two coins until at least one shows a Head, what's the probability that both are Heads? If I roll two dice until at least one shows a 6, what's the probability that both are 6's? If I spin two roulette wheels until at least one shows a Red-23, what's the probability that both are red? Are you sure?
- bad_user 16y agoIt's been fun :-) > If I toss two coins until at least one shows a Head, what's the probability that both are Heads? I answered in my last reply ... P(head_a AND head_b | head_b) = 1/3 The problem is that head_a and head_b are independent events, and that P(head_a) = 1 (you made sure of that). P(head_a AND head_b | head_a) = P(head_a AND head_b) / P(head_a) = P(head_a AND head_b) = P(head_a) = 1/2 QED :)
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoI have no idea what problem you think you're solving, but it's not the one I posed. I never said a specific coin was heads, I just said at least one of them was heads. Given that I make money on these sorts of questions (doing it for real in a semi-military context where it's important to be right, and you get tested against reality) I feel pretty confident that I know what I'm talking about. You're clearly talking about something completely different, and I really don't understand what you're saying. And that's the last I'll say.
- bad_user 16y agoLook, don't take this the wrong way ... probabilities are easy to get wrong ... I'm only having this conversation with you because my math skills are rusty. > I never said a specific coin was heads OK, so let's make it mathematically correct (let's say we're painting them) ... making an effort here :) P( blue_head AND red_head | blue_head OR red_head) P(blue_head OR red_head) = 1 you said that you're retrying until this happens normally this would be 3/4 Making the problem ... P( blue AND red | blue OR red) = P( blue OR red | blue AND red ) * P( blue AND red ) / P(blue OR red) (applied bayes) = 1 * P(blue) * P(red) / 1 But ... P(blue OR red) = P(blue) + P(red) - P(blue) * P(red) = 1 => P(blue) * P(red) = 1 - P(blue) - P(red) = 1 - 1/4 - 1/4 = 1/2 Show me the error. [EDITED] ... modified the stuff as I've totally fucked up the previous version :) ... as I said, I'm rusty