8 ms·
URLs are UI
- robin_reala 9y agoLast time I was localising a service I ended up localising the the URLs as well - if URLs should be readable they should be readable in the localised language too right? Luckily there’s the RouteTranslator gem which made it trivial: https://github.com/enriclluelles/route_translator/ https://github.com/enriclluelles/route_translator/
- sharpercoder 9y agoThe first realization about URI's being UI I had when I was looking to the first billboard with a URI on it - it must have been around 2000 or so.
- userbinator 9y agoYes, I absolutely agree that good URLs are extremely useful, although personally I don't really like the long-string-of-text pattern, especially if it isn't actually significant. A short identifier is useful when sharing them offline: "HN article 14723409" or "YouTube video AQcSFsQyct8" or "forum thread 5705591" For a blog, news, or other chronological content, I'd like to see a timestamp of some form. If it's rigidly hierarchical content, then a hierarchy (of which I should be able to remove 'subdirectories' to see the parent content) makes sense. Otherwise flat IDs are OK too. Too bad browser developers seem to love hiding or mutilating them...
- chrismcb 9y agoA string of text is much easier to remember then a bunch of digits. Exorcism if there are more than 4 digits in a row
- saurik 9y agoThe string of text, if you are seriously trying to remember it (which I seriously doubt... do you really try to type in those sentence-long title slugs from memory?!) is subject to domain-specific forms of corruption, in the same way direct quotes from people or TV characters tend to be: you subtly change the grammar or replace a noun with a synonym with which you are more familiar. Regardless: I am quite serious... do you seriously try to remember and type, from memory, URLs with title slugs?
- wingerlang 9y agoDoubt he does that, however I collect some links in a text file and the ones with text in them are the ones I can identify instantly. The ones with just IDs are totally random as to what they are and usually requires a comment accompanying them in the file.
- seagreen 9y agoAbsolutely true, and also a problem. The fact of the matter is unskilled people are always going to be designing websites. This is OK! However, it does mean that we should require them to do as little as possible so they have the best chance of getting it right. Asking them to design a second UI right from the start on top of the first HTML/JS one -- and then telling them never to change it(!) -- is a little much. Instead of URLs, websites should have UUIDs to identify each resource. They should also have metadata describing what that resource is. The metadata (eg "articles/urls-are-uis") should be able to change without breaking links to the resource. Browsers should be intelligent enough so that when you hover over a link you see the metadata, not the UUID. (This has one downside which if if you link to thing X and the UUID is later changed to point to thing Y, it may look like you linked to something you didn't mean to. This can be trivially fixed by including a "what the metadata was when I made the link" field in links along with the UUID) EDIT: I'm actually not set on UUIDs specifically, they're a little long. Any random, non-meaningful identifier is fine. Really I'm just saying that points 2 & 3 of the article are so good we should have made them the default (and perhaps only) option from the start.
- hhh000 9y agoYeah and also urls ending with .aspx are ugly and stupid
- morecoffee 9y agoWhich of the following URLS are clearer? 1a. https://foo.com/ 1b. https://www.foo.com/ 2a. https://foo.com/search/products/couches/color/red 2b. https://foo.com/search?products=couches&color=red 3a. /posts?recent 3b. /posts?recent= 3c. /posts?recent=true 4a. /post/1234/products-couches-furniture-red-cheap-recent-ikea-tags 4b. /post/1234/ I can think of good reasons for picking each of these, and even good reasons for picking their alternatives. URL design is tricky to get right because realistically you can't change it later.
- klenwell 9y agoI'd be happy with any of these. What I'm meeting with my team next week to discuss is establishing some conventions to avoid stuff like this: 4c. /post/_level/modular/1234--Products--Couches%20red+cheap%20ikeaTags%28OLD%29.aspx
- zepolen 9y agoOf course you can change it later, that's what 301s are for.
- sametmax 9y agoIf you make money with it, 301s are going to hurt the wallet for some months.
- zepolen 9y agoYou obviously have no idea what you're talking about.
- sametmax 9y agoI had several websites where changing the URL schemas resulted in Google rank dropping, resulting in advertising revenue loss. I don't see I can be more honest than that. And frankly, you are not just unfair, you are being rude.
- csours 9y agoSee also the pit of despair known as SharePoint. example.com/sites/MySite/MyList.aspx can be functionally the same as example.com/sites/MySite/MyList.aspx?GUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUID=GUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUID&GUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUID=GUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUID&GUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUID=GUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUID&GUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUID=GUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUIDGUID Why, SharePoint, why? Or even worse, Angular SPAs example.com/page#nice_page_you_have_there/shame_if_you_tried_to_share_it As a tester, I always check: 1. What happens if I go to "example.com", "http://example.com" http://example.com", "https://example.com" https://example.com" 2. Sharing URLs - at least you should get a landing page, but I've seen 404s from shared URLs
- keganunderwood 9y agoWhile I've become less than enamored by Microsoft lately, these are difficult decisions to make because every assumption carries a penalty. All abstractions are leaky. That being said, maybe they can do better. I used SharePoint 2007 and was told 2010 and beyond were much better? I've been playing with drupal for a few weeks and there's the concept of an alias in drupal where everything is /node/{node-id} internally but the user sees the alias every time. About angular 2+, you can have routes I believe. Like {base-url}/user/keganunderwood can show you the profile page for me. Even if you go to it directly.
- Can_Not 9y agoThis is a pet peeve of mine. I'm writing some vuejs SPAs and I am using nuxtjs for server side rendering (probably a clone of react's nextjs) and when appropriate, using the URL for reproducible "what you are currently looking at" state as much as reasonably possible. It's too disappointing these days how apps don't let you middle click open a link to a new tab, destroy your original URL when rewriting navigation history to redirect you to login, etc.
- carsongross 9y agoAt some point here the collective web development world is going to realize what it lost when it tossed REST/HATEOS out in its rush to appear modern.
- gjvc 9y agoWhen did this happen, and what frameworks did the throwing out?
- pcmaffey 9y agoURLs are also inherently useful state managers, with powerful time traveling histories, when used well. cough cough
- captbaritone 9y agoI made a little project taking this idea to an extreme. The idea was, that you should be able to generate "meme" image macros simply by typing a URL. That way you could create memes on the fly anywhere that you can enter a URL (Slack/Twitter/Facebook/etc.) without having to leave the app. Just type a URL of the form: http://urlme.me/<search_prhase_for_meme_image>/<top_text>/<bottom_text>.<ext> http://urlme.me/ http://urlme.me/
- loco5niner 9y agoWow, I love this. My girlfriend and I LOVE sending memes to each other. This will give me major points :-)
- j2kun 9y agoThis project alone is more convincing that the entire linked article. Needless to say, I love it!
- klenwell 9y agohttp://urlme.me/epiphany/URLs/Are_UI.jpg http://urlme.me/epiphany/URLs/Are_UI.jpg
- clishem 9y agohttp://urlme.me/wow/URLs/Are_UI.jpg http://urlme.me/wow/URLs/Are_UI.jpg
- romwell 9y agoBrilliant! http://urlme.me/simply/one_can't_simply/fix_the_web http://urlme.me/simply/one_can't_simply/fix_the_web ..but your example might lead the way. Also, I hope this stays up for a long time to come.
- captbaritone 9y agoIf you are at all worried about it going away, you can add: ?host=imgur To the URL and it will 301 to the image hosted on Imgur. That is assuming you have more faith in the longevity of Imgur than you do in the longevity of my side project :D
- 0xdada 9y agoI know this is nitpicky but the author's website doesn't follow their own advice: https://www.hanselman.com/blog/URLsAreUI.aspx https://www.hanselman.com/blog/URLsAreUI.aspx https://www.hanselman.com/blog/URLsAreUI https://www.hanselman.com/blog/URLsAreUI --> 404
- LeoPanthera 9y agoThe article does mention that.
- shanselman 9y agoYep. 17 year old blog. Technical debt. It's on Github and it's on my list. I also specifically say it in the post. ;)
- internet2000 9y agoI agree with the article, and I really don't understand how Google Search can be so bad with URLs. Seems they get more and more paramenters every time I look, to the point my browser (Safari) hides the URL just for them.
- Doctor_Fegg 9y agoGoogle Search is perhaps the definitive example of a site with no interest in human-readable URLs. Google wants you to navigate the web using Google, not by cutting and pasting URLs.
- oblio 9y agoPlus it would be a bit ironic if the Google Search page itself cared for SEO :)
- sp332 9y agoI switched to DuckDuckGo, but for a while I had a browser extension that would fix Google URLs for me. Recently I added another one for Twitter links.
- sgustard 9y agoThis URL I've memorized and revisit regularly is a bite-sized marvel of semantic clarity: https://www.wellsfargo.com/mortgage/rates https://www.wellsfargo.com/mortgage/rates
- OJFord 9y agoIt passes the 'parent exists' test too. https://www.wellsfargo.com/mortgage https://www.wellsfargo.com/mortgage
- elcapitan 9y agoFirst thing with new Safari: Change default setting for URL bar to actually show URL. Because UI.
- Tehnix 9y agoI can’t remember if it was actually shown or just argued for, but the simplification of the URL in the address bar actually helps identify phishing sites, as there is a lot less text to process through, and that one character that might have been changes becomes more visible than before :)
- elcapitan 9y agoFor the "easier to read" part I would prefer Chrome's black vs grey url string. But for phishing .. with all the tricks possible with Unicode lookalikes, I wonder if people are still doing easily visible character exchanges? qoogle instead of google?
- agumonkey 9y agoURLs are programming language.
- irl_ 9y agoURLs are addresses. For web, we messed up and URLs became part of the UI. It shouldn't be necessary to use URLs in most cases though. e.g. imagine using IMAP URLs to read your email.
- wodenokoto 9y agoMan, I'd love to be able to link to individual emails from my calendar. Having entries like the following in my calendar app would be amazing: "Company event on <date>, for details see linked email"
- irl_ 9y agoIf we remembered there was more to the "web" than HTTP, this would be a thing. I remember Tim had a diagram that showed "links" between all different systems, all addressable by URI/URL.
- a3n 9y ago> I love Stack Overflow's URLs. Here's an example: https://stackoverflow.com/users/6380/scott-hanselman https://stackoverflow.com/users/6380/scott-hanselman > The only thing that matters there is the 6380. Try it https://stackoverflow.com/users/6380 https://stackoverflow.com/users/6380 or https://stackoverflow.com/users/6380/fancy-pants https://stackoverflow.com/users/6380/fancy-pants also works. SO will even support this! http://stackoverflow.com/u/6380 http://stackoverflow.com/u/6380. This works too: https://stackoverflow.com/users/6380/a3n https://stackoverflow.com/users/6380/a3n That doesn't seem right, and on a different site could even be dangerous.
- romwell 9y agoDangerous? How so? This scheme is used on other sites, too.
- a3n 9y ago"Other people do it," by itself, is not a great justification. It's yet another way to mislead. Just because other misleading schemes exist doesn't mean this isn't also misleading and potentially bad. As for "How so" ... I didn't think it through. I'll go with "potentially not good," but equally not thought through. Since the subject of the article is URLs as UI, when you send someone a URL to "look at this", what they see is the URL, and in my example the human readable part is "the site" and "a3n", but what they get is nothing to do with a3n. I can only intuitively start with "that's misleading," and imagine (but not point out) the possibility of "something bad". Maybe something merely annoying like rick-rolling.
- simias 9y agoThat's a "slug", it's extremely common and IMO a good thing. Sure, you can create a weird looking or even misleading URLs that way but I don't think it's a big problem because 1/ as soon as the page load the URL gets rewritten to the real title and 2/ it's often very easy to obfuscate links regardless of that. Many platforms allow you to hide your links behind an href with some markup for instance, so you can make bogus links very easily. Think of something like: <a href="http://evil.org/">http://google.com</a> This is very common in spam emails. You can't even trust the browser's link preview tooltip because it can be overridden in JS. So in general it's a bad idea to blindly trust an URL "from the outside", slug or not. I really, really wish youtube would do the same thing for instance, it's completely impossible to know what a youtube link is pointing towards. You could argue that they want short URLs but since they already have a "youtu.be" shortening service to make them even shorter it feels a bit redundant.
- tvgggghh 9y agoGuys, I along with the rest of iOS users on the planet won't get to see any of your fancy clean URLs in Safari.
- OJFord 9y ago> I proposed this. Proposed what? Great article and I completely agree with it, I'm frustrated perhaps daily by bad URLs, (I don't know if I've ever written a more lame description of myself!) but I was very confused by the ending. I was expecting the author to propose a (informal, but) concrete system for URL UI. I know it's short of implicit throughout, but a summary would be good.
- kmfrk 9y agoI hate that people use shorturls on Twitter, especially news sites with paywalls. I check the full URL of articles in my Twitter client before I click them, especially when people share the links without any description. Since Twitter gives all links the same allotment of characters, it's really frustrating that people insist on sticking to shorturls. Goes to show how tracking and advertising keeps ruining the Web.
- DanBC 9y ago> Since Twitter gives all links the same allotment of characters Does it? The documentation I've read doesn't suggest this, unless you're including Twitter's own wrapping of links with its own shortURL t.co
- guscost 9y agoThis is all solid advice, but there's something that still bothers me about URLs: From one side I hear that hypertext should be the engine of application state. This implies that the URL router should control just about everything, and that you should be able to click a link in an email and jump directly to any state of your application. From the other side I hear that web apps can be just as capable as desktop apps, and it's only a matter of time before we'll be using PhotoshopJS in a browser. What isn't said is that Photoshop has no concept of an "address bar", and it probably will never have one. As with so many things, the best practices for a blog or message board might be completely different from the best practices for a creative application. Could you design a URL format to represent the state of a Photoshop editing session? Would you even want to? Something's gotta give.
- jdavis703 9y agoIf you're using non-destructive editing a URL might indeed be helpful for sharing the progress and evolution of a file with others. Something like photoshop.app/jdavis703/file/oceanview.psd/layer/colorcorrect might be really useful.
- guscost 9y agoThat's a really interesting idea.
- combatentropy 9y agoInsisting that a URL change with state is taking it too far. It's not how I understood what Tim Berners-Lee and others were saying at the beginning. I would be interested, however, in articles that espouse this. If the URL represented state, then it should change as you're filling out an HTML form, at each keystroke. But instead there is one URL for the blank form and one after you click Submit. A better rule is one URL per "document" or "record." So in your Photoshop example, there would be a different URL per file that you edit (www.photoshop.com/image001.psd) but not per edit. Well, if the app saved versions, then you could append ?v=203. But in general I think it's enough to align URLs to "documents" (like a news story) or "records" (like a particular profile in a contact database).
- supernumerary 9y agoMade me think of how, (and perhaps it's anti-pattern) I find myself using react router to manage state between components...
- jccooper 9y ago> I love Stack Overflow's URLs. Here's an example: https://stackoverflow.com/users/6380/scott-hanselman https://stackoverflow.com/users/6380/scott-hanselman While it is nice UI, it's probably SEO first. This ensures keywords in the URL while making it safe to mangle.
- joshmanders 9y agoUrls are a very important part of things for me. I spend just as much time figuring out how I want to structure my urls as I do my database.
- ng12 9y agoI was thinking this recently as I tried Reddit's mobile app. I found that navigating subreddits through URL was so natural that I was kind of lost in the app -- and frankly Chrome did a better job of suggesting the content I wanted than the app did.