8 ms·
NewsLabs (YC W10) folds months after launch, regrets big promises to journalists
- brandnewlow 16y agoThat's it? They lasted 2 months? Did they get bored?
- dannyr 16y agoI'm curious to know how long they worked on the product before YC.
- brandnewlow 16y agoIn their Reddit AMA I think they said they originally were going to sell a white label Disqus commenting system to newspapers as their product, only to find out that building it would be easy, but selling it would be extremely hard. So they decided to go with the True/Slant/Examiner/Associated Content/Demand Media model of getting a whole bunch of people publishing in one place to pool their collective Google juice. My sense, from comments made here and there is that they hadn't really been working on the site itself all that long when it launched. Some of the features they said were on the way seemed pretty core to me (letting writers sell their work directly, for example).
- ErrantX 16y agoI think this is right; in the early stages (post YC funding) when they were doing a QA mailing list wwith some journalists they were just building the product. (in fairness it appeared very fast and iterated really well from what I saw/heard)
- rokhayakebe 16y agoIt seems like the guys had the product prior to joining YC. it could more than a year in the making.
- Groxx 16y agoDon't think I've heard of that one. Any great loss?
- riffer 16y agoWas a YC W10 company
- joshbert 16y agoThat's a shame. Looks like they didn't take it very seriously though.
- brandnewlow 16y agoSomeone should stick that up in the headline. If we're going to do it for the good news about YC companies, we should do it for the not so good news, too. I'm assuming there was something else happening behind the scenes to cause both founders to jump ship so quickly. They made a very strong (positive!) impression on me with their rhetoric and claims here as well as over in a Reddit AMA they did (http://www.reddit.com/r/iama/comments/bwrew http://www.reddit.com/r/iama/comments/bwrew). I'm surprised to hear they fizzled so quickly after all the big talk.
- dpritchett 16y agoAt least we're allowed to comment on this YC company story. I still can't get comfortable with the no-comments-allowed YC stories here on HN.
- davidw 16y agoThose are just job advertisements, and I still think it's a mistake, as the comments would be a great place to ask for questions/clarification that might benefit others and keep the same questions from being repeated in private email.
- Pent 16y agoSeems like they wanted to build a brand overnight and then give up when it didn't happen. I've never even heard of them, personally. Is there more to the story than what was in the post?
- gojomo 16y agoThere must be some backstory -- out of money, irreconcilable founder differences, etc. -- which will only come out if the principals want it to. Without that, speculating on their "boredom" or "impatience" or "seriousness" is unfair.
- chime 16y agoLet me recap: * One of the two cofounders was on his honeymoon for the month of May, right after launch. * The other cofounder had difficulty managing everything on his own. * Cofounder comes back from the honeymoon and decides to leave for good. * Remaining cofounder doesn't want to run it on his own. In my past life, I've been both of these guys and frankly, it is hard to blame either. If the passion somehow died for honeymooning-cofounder, you can't expect him to give his very best on this startup. On the other hand, if your cofounder leaves, you have very little incentive to do everything on your own. Part of working with a cofounder is each person doing what the other most probably dislikes (usually biz vs. tech). What's the fun if you have to get better pricing AND write efficient code? Most people like one or the other. I think the take-away from this and my own life examples is to start small, not try to get too much publicity early on, work on finishing the product before making promises, and most importantly, be honest to yourself and your cofounder.
- michael_dorfman 16y agoWow. Maybe it's because I've never been either of those guys, but I have trouble rustling up as much compassion as you seem to. One of the two co-founders schedules a launch right before his honeymoon? Who does that? And, after just a couple months, the passion dies? What kind of commitment does that show? I agree with your take-away, though. Don't try to get hype, until you actually have something solid to hype.
- chime 16y ago> One of the two co-founders schedules a launch right before his honeymoon? Who does that? Life. Nobody knows what happens next. I have no idea how/what/why this transpired but it wouldn't be far-fetched to imagine that the wedding/honeymoon was planned well-in-advance. And the success of the startup was a last-second thing. Sure, the honeymoon could have been postponed but then again, maybe he wasn't certain about the startup, the other cofounder, or his life in general. Truth is, nobody knows other than the guys themselves. That's why I gave them the benefit of the doubt. Because I've been there. And because if you are in a position where you have to choose between commitments you've already made and dreams you wish to pursue, you have to say "no" to someone. Maybe the passion did not die. Maybe there were other reasons that the founders do not want to share. Maybe it was personality issues, financial issues, or even health. Who knows? The reason I am giving them the benefit of the doubt is that they came out clean and apologized. That is action and it was direct, honest, and to the point.
- barkingcat 16y agoI think one problem they had early on is that technology is not the answer to an editorial and writing problem. Many people on the newslabs lists questioned their experience in journalistic and publishing oriented endeavours - the founders' answers to quality and editorial concerns weren't very convincing - and always came back to technology. Ideas like building mass-comment moderation systems, crowdsourced editing, etc - don't work if the people moderating don't have literary taste. But it was a good try - and I hope that other people tackling this problem space would think about some of the questions raised by the newslabs contributors.
- pbiggar 16y agoI'm Paul Biggar, one of the founders. There's a lot of speculation and reading between the lines going on here. There is really no information to go off, and jumping to conclusions based on that email is a little unfair. (By contrast, the journalists to whom that email was addressed had tons of context.) I'm in the middle of writing a "what went wrong" piece, which I'll link to here, but I'll ask you guys to hold off judgement until then.
- chime 16y agoI apologize if my comments sounded like I was jumping to conclusions. With respect to the passion dying, I was just giving an example of something that happened in my past experience. By no means was I hinting that is what happened to you. I just wanted to make that point that people can't blame the founders, especially when they don't know the full story.
- rokhayakebe 16y agoI upvoted you and I agree people should not make comments with just half of the story. But come on this is the internet. It's near real time now, and people will not wait for someone to tell their side before they can come to a conclusion. You guys should have taken a day to handle the outcome before sending the email. That being said, I think you guys had something going. Good luck on your next projects.
- MediaSquirrel 16y agodude, seriously? honeymoon right after launch = guaranteed fail OR I want a "lifestyle business." How did you guys pass the PG sniff test??? #YCadmissionFAIL I don't mean to be a total dick, but when you're doing a startup and OTHER PEOPLE ARE DEPENDING ON YOU, going on a vacation of any sort right after you launch is just plain irresponsible. People like you give the rest of us who are busting our ass and putting everything on the line to make our companies work a bad name.
- axod 16y agoSome things are more important than money, companies, startups etc. Don't be so quick to pass judgement if you don't know the full story.
- jasonlbaptiste 16y agoI still think the offering of: we handle technology+monetization for journalists/online publishers is a very valuable proposition.
- brandnewlow 16y agoI totally agree. One of the big problems with that though is its nearly impossible to bootstrap an audience on the web. That's why Kevin Rose pimping Digg on Tech TV was such a coup. He had product/market fit AND could drop an audience on it. With most publishing startups, you have to survive the whole first year until Google un-sandboxes your domain and you get legit Google traffic. Until then you have to find other ways to build numbers, Reddit-baiting, cutting deals with other publications etc....notice none of these are technical problems? So you can't really sell publishers on traffic, you've got to offer them something else. Then at that point, how are you better than Wordpress.com?
- jasonlbaptiste 16y agoIs it impossible to boostrap an audience on the web? I feel like that's where most successful online publications have come from. Techcrunch came out of arrington's boredom and Pete Cashmore started mashable in scottland at 19. I think it's all about baby steps. If your goal is to get 1 million visitors fast that won't work. It's the first 50k or so. Technology is the less important than traffic/content/readerbase, but it's certainly something you do not want to deal with. Wordpress.com is certainly great, but I wouldn't be running that if I were trying to do something professional (I would use Wordpress though).
- brandnewlow 16y agoThat's not exactly bootstrapping though. Those are both examples of organic growth that happened over YEARS. That's very do-able if you are making content people actually want to read.
- jasonlbaptiste 16y ago
- bjplink 16y agoHere are some previous posts about NewsLabs that might be interesting reading in light of this announcement, in case anyone is unfamiliar with what they were about... http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1159683 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1159683 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1259603 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1259603
- credo 16y agopg has said (http://www.paulgraham.com/notnot.html http://www.paulgraham.com/notnot.html) that "Not having a cofounder is a real problem" and that finding a co-founder should be the "first priority" for any single founder and that this is "more important than anything else". This is a fairly common meme in the startup world. Newslab looks like a great example of how that meme gets it wrong. Many other things are far more important than finding a co-founder In this case, it looks like one co-founder goes on a honeymoon and decides to drop out. Then the other co-founder decides that he doesn't have the passion to run it on his own. So the whole company collapses. I'm assuming that a more passionate person who didn't believe in the co-founder meme would have shown more perseverance.
- axod 16y agoI think getting to be profitable is more important than finding a co-founder. It does indeed sound like neither really believed in the idea passionately.
- pg 16y agoActually this case isn't a counterexample. Paul wasn't someone Nathan recruited; more the opposite.
- chegra 16y agoWhat I have found in terms of co-founders is that people will join when you have traction. At least in my circle, people aren't risk takers and wouldn't stop their own personal project to work on someone else project. With so many people having problems finding co-founders, I would suggest they implement something and get some traction. After, find a co-founder who now you can offer less equity since they weren't there to share the initial risk then approach investors.
- thaumaturgy 16y agoYES! Oh man, I want to thank you for saying that. I would love to find a co-founder. I've bootstrapped a successful business, it's going quite well, and I've been doing it for 2.5 years now. I've simply refused to give up at every step of the way -- even though I've often wanted to. And if I have my way, this business is going to get quite big. But, I'm not running the sort of thing that YC would be interested in, and my sporadic efforts locally to drum up support have accomplished little.
- talbina 16y agoDoes YC see a problem with founders being the technical developers? When I saw their bio when this was announced a few months back, I did scratch my head a little. One was a PhD in computer science, the other was a researcher at ARM. None had a media background. I just wish people stop thinking that journalism is a technology problem.It doesn't matter how good your platform is. This hacker culture of thinking everything can be solved with guru developer skills needs to stop. Here are some qoutes from that letter: "If I could rewind and start again then I believe the pitch for NewsLabs should have been simpler and much more realistic: we will build you a technology platform and strive to work hard for you as programmers... but we cannot magically generate you an online brand or guarantee traffic." "It seemed like we had the right parts (your writing and our technology)..." This is why Mark MacLeod, in a recent post on his blog startupcfo.ca, said that one of the traits for a successful founder is domain knowledge: "Lets look at domain knowledge first. This is not about having studied or otherwise artificially gotten to “know” the industry. This is about coming from that industry, having lived it, knowing the players and knowing the pain firsthand. There is no substitute for this. You can’t fake it. You either come from the space or you don’t."
- brandnewlow 16y agoWorld Cup-related allusion: Which is why I'm not surprised at all that Argentina's team is playing its heart out for Maradona. The man may be a lunatic and borderline incompetent as an organizer, but he has the domain knowledge and knows the pain points of winning a World Cup as an Argentinian side better than anyone.
- hboon 16y agoThis advice that a successful founder has domain knowledge runs contrary to what's said of PayPal though. From a recent thread in HN: http://primitus.com/blog/why-did-so-many-successful-entrepreneurs-and-startups-come-out-of-paypal-answered-by-insiders/ http://primitus.com/blog/why-did-so-many-successful-entrepre... PayPal had a strong bias toward hiring (and promoting / encouraging, as Keith mentions) smart, driven problem solvers, rather than subject matter experts I doubt there's a hard and fast rule.
- ErrantX 16y ago
- ErrantX 16y agoPaul was kind enough to include me in a prelaunch mailing list of journalists where he discussed his vision. At the time I have to confess I was not convinced Newstilt was the right product at the right time. It was an interesting vision (in a nutshell: to have journalists establish their own brands and syndicate content more directly to publishers/websites) but I did forsee traction trouble: - Firstly because I felt journalists would have difficulty "getting" the new concept EDIT: by this I mean there was far too little content coming into Newstilt, I'm guessing because the writers didn't see instant returns and therefore gave up. As the email says Techcrunch took dedication and unfortunately for Newstilt they needed dedicated writers aiming for the same vision, hard to find. - But mostly because publishers and websites would be resistive and negative about this concept (or simply uninterested). I actually think it is a good model. A few years ago myself and others tried to form a similar style collective for UK tech magazines. It was a very hard to sell and ultimately failed because it was so radically difference. I suspect one of the major problems was that it is such a different approach to media that it put many people off. I've come to the conclusion that, for this sort of thing to work, it has to be built by journalists with both the contacts and the ability to placate both of the above problems. (also, taking a honey moon in the first few months of a startup is never going to end well!). Good luck Paul and Nathan - I really was rooting for you and it sucks that such a cool model never got off the ground.
- dman 16y agoIf its a good idea, then it will find its champion and its moment in the sun ... eventually.
- ErrantX 16y agoYes, it will. Something like it is on my back burner still (after 3 years - which in my mind makes it a great idea). One way it could work is for a site (or a collaboration of sites) like Tech Crunch to create a network for aspiring tech writers - and go from there.
- brandnewlow 16y agoTheAwl has a solid little write-up about this: http://www.theawl.com/2010/06/another-journalism-changing-startup-bites-the-dust http://www.theawl.com/2010/06/another-journalism-changing-st... "It is very difficult to get readers regularly returning to any site; it takes a blend of pumping out the content and getting linked by high-profile sites both in and out of its immediate topic — and a not-insignificant amount of luck — in order to do so. Internet behaviors can be very entrenched things!"
- ig1 16y agoI wrote an analyis of the newslabs model back in March prior to their launch: http://blog.awesomezombie.com/2010/03/journalism-advertising-business-model.html http://blog.awesomezombie.com/2010/03/journalism-advertising... From my analysis I couldn't see the financials working out (obviously that wasn't the cause of their failure in this case; but I presume the financials not working didn't help the situation).
- _pius 16y agoI'm usually very reticent about making snide remarks about a startup as it deadpools, but in this case I'll make an exception. As someone who's working in this space (and was not fortunate enough to have been granted the imprimatur, mentorship, and network of YCombinator), it pisses me off that this company garnered so much hype and is now giving up so quickly. It'll now be that much harder to get print journalists to put their faith in new business models for their work. From the start, I thought the promises NewsTilt was making were great but it wasn't at all clear how those promises were going to be fulfilled. On the strength of YC's reputation, I assumed that there was some "secret sauce" that differentiated them and made their promises credible. According to this e-mail, I was wrong. And now, mere months after being given what I'd consider to be the chance of a lifetime, they're just giving up. Not evolving, not making changes, just giving up. What a joke. Have some passion about what you're doing or just don't bother.
- talbina 16y ago"As someone who's working in this space" Do you mind saying where?
- _pius 16y agoMy own pre-launch startup.
- brandnewlow 16y agoDrop me an e-mail when you launch and good luck!
- _pius 16y agothanks!
- petercooper 16y agoAnd now, mere months after being given what I'd consider to be the chance of a lifetime, they're just giving up. Not evolving, not making changes, just giving up. What a joke. Companies (or people!) who make bold promises, get the press excited, and then fail to deliver make it harder for us all to get our stories across. I usually play down what I'm doing and underpromise, but it seems reaching way beyond your limits and impressing journalists is the way to go for coverage (Sam Sethi's exploits that TechCrunch covered so deftly come to mind here, too.)
- petercooper 16y agoPerhaps it's just confirmation bias because I'm interested in this space, but aren't most news startups that rush to market cursed with obscurity or death? Newsvine is the only interesting and semi-successful one that comes to mind over the past few years, and the executive team there is crazy experienced and of great provenance. All the other good news "startups" I know of have had to grow quite slowly over a long period of time or are heavily leaning on exposure in fields like politics or tech.
- bosch 16y agoI think this serves to remind everyone that you need to have the will to persevere for your start up to thrive during the first few years when things aren't going your way. If you're only in it for an instant hit, you're not building a business properly.