4 ms·
Why do you care about what doesn't work? If the things that work are in the set "Medicine", that's the only set we need to be concerned with. Sure, it's worthw
by StavrosK 9y ago
Why do you care about what doesn't work? If the things that work are in the set "Medicine", that's the only set we need to be concerned with.
Sure, it's worthwhile to try and figure out which medicine doesn't work, but we know for sure that anything non-medicine does, by definition, not work.
- tvanantwerp 9y agoExcept the range of possibilities isn't ['works', 'doesn't work']. Rather, it's ['works', 'no effect', 'harmful', 'works and is harmful at the same time']. A banal example: proton pump inhibitor drugs used to treat acid reflux will, over very long timeframes, cause nutrient malabsorption resulting in more brittle bones. They also have what's called a rebound effect, where dropping them cold turkey leads to a huge jump in stomach acid production and worsening of symptoms. So while effective to reduce stomach acidity, they also have long-term negative effects and a sort of withdrawal that makes the original problem worse. It's a weird and complicated situation, and certainly not the most intense example.
- StavrosK 9y agoOkay, sure, but again, the things that have "no effect" are not worth even mentioning at all. That is what the debate is about, not whether medicine that works is also harmful.
- watwut 9y agoThey are worth mentioning, because they are often expensive and take a lot of time. They are often uncomfortable or painful. It is not neutral.
- glenra 9y ago> we know for sure that anything non-medicine does, by definition, not work. We don't actually know that. That something is proven to work to the satisfaction of the FDA and the doctor's lobbies is too high a bar to say that anything failing to meet it does not work. Many treatments that "work" either can't adequately be double-blind tested or have a status such that the current US regulatory climate makes it too hard to get them approved as treatments. For instance, treatments that are "medicine" in other countries (China, Japan, Russia...) but not yet accepted here. Treatments that can't be patented so it doesn't make economic sense to get them approved here. Treatments that probably work but are legally or ethically problematic for other reasons (eg, ketamine for depression, alcohol for social anxiety, or cigarettes for weight loss).