4 ms·
No matter what they had done the luster would have worn off. The badge system just makes the whoring and the impossibility of ever attaining certain badges mor
by dasil003 16y ago
No matter what they had done the luster would have worn off. The badge system just makes the whoring and the impossibility of ever attaining certain badges more obvious.
Every online community must go through a maturation process where excitement wanes and moderation waxes. At some point the curation of content becomes of primary importance.
Arguably they could have built a longer lasting community with Wikipedia style participation, but it certainly wouldn't have grown as fast, and maybe never would have gotten traction at all, so it's hard to make a retroactive critique.
In any case though, Stack Overflow still has a fundamentally a great user experience. It's not a growth business, but there will always be new tech, and I don't see the community drying up.
- michael_dorfman 16y agoNo matter what they had done the luster would have worn off. I'm not sure this is necessarily the case, because, as you write: At some point the curation of content becomes of primary importance. Which is why they need to find a way to build an incentive system that properly rewards "Wikipedia-style participation". That's a tough nut to crack, but I certainly hope that they've got some folks working on it, now that they've got the VC money in place.