4 ms·
And it isn't even remotely clear how this would work. Like all "let's just semantic web all the things!" projects it all makes sense at a super-ultra-high level
by jerf 9y ago
And it isn't even remotely clear how this would work. Like all "let's just semantic web all the things!" projects it all makes sense at a super-ultra-high level, but when you try to manifest this in the real world there's an immense explosion of tricky details, by the literal thousands.
Making social networks speak together is probably a good order of magnitude harder than unifying the IM networks, and even after a decade+ of effort and tons and tons of work, the multiprotocol IM clients are still generally quirky, involve losing useful features from any given specific network, and face constant issues where the semantics of the networks differ. (Especially around conferencing.)
Shared social graphs is a nice idea, but it would take enormous effort backed by legal force to happen, at a minimum.
- EGreg 9y agoNot necessarily. Linux arose despite Windows' monopoly. Wikipedia arose despite Britannica et al.
- ucaetano 9y agoLinux didn't arise where Windows had a monopoly. Wikipedia didn't arise where Britannica had a monopoly. The industry changed, and the segment where Windows had a monopoly became less relevant, the same with Britannica. Windows still retains 90%+ market share on desktops.
- ge0rg 9y agoI think that solving the technical problem is in the same order of complexity as the IM problem actually. It is solvable if you have some strong backers and not just the nerdy volunteers doing it in their leasure time, the ones who are telling you to use XMPP since 2004. Actually the XMPP protocol already has a distributed social graph, and there are micro blogging extensions (eg. Movim), so we can get a functional distributed social network basically overnight. The problem is that (a) you can't monetize an open, distributed network, so the incumbents will do everything they can to prevent federation, and (b) the only driving force that remains are the nerdy volunteers, who have a limited impact, even if they are able to tackle the UX challenges.
- dane-pgp 9y agoThe 80/20 solution would be to "just" free the authentication aspect from Facebook's control. If Facebook were forced to support something like OpenID Connect, then anyone with one of those IDs, from any provider, should at least be allowed to log in to Facebook and view posts from their friends who have accounts there. Facebook would be forbidden from storing any information about you, except for the fact that your friends on Facebook had manually specified your ID as someone who could view their posts. If your ID provider also ran a social network, and allowed people to log in with their Facebook accounts to view your posts, then that would cover a lot of use cases. The next step would be to allow/require Facebook to fetch RSS-style feeds of events from your social network, so that Facebook users would be alerted to your new posts, without having to manually browse to all the different sites that their friends are on. This would require more engineering work, but could perhaps be implemented as a browser plugin. At some point, if Facebook are making it unreasonably hard for competitors' users to interoperate with users on Facebook, there would be grounds for an anti-trust case against Facebook, which I'm sure the EU would be happy to consider.
- anigbrowl 9y agoYou don't need them all to work together. You just need one federated one that is functionally better. It seems to me that a big problem is avoiding feature creep. I don't want or need a full browser experience for everything because it will break any customization I have set up.