I'm infinitely more comfortable with functional composition over object composition, but Mobx is still far more intuitive to me. It's because functional composi

I'm infinitely more comfortable with functional composition over object composition, but Mobx is still far more intuitive to me. It's because functional composition over a constantly changing global state tree is a huge fucking mess. There's a reasonably objective explanation as to why it is a mess, and more specifically, why Redux suffers from so much boilerplate and painful refactorings. In UI programming you are managing state, full stop. Almost any UI can be described as a state machine. Not just GUIs, but any UI: digital, analog, mechanical, whatever. And since you are basically managing state machines, any refactoring of the functionality of your UI is fundamentally a refactoring of your state. Rendering is a functional refactoring (state doesn't change), but if you are building a UI and not just a simple landing page, you are far more likely to refactor functionality over rendering...meaning your data is more likely to change than your functions. In other words, UI programming via functional composition over a frequently changing global state tree falls on the wrong side of the Expression Problem [0]. Every time you change your data, you have to modify every functional pipeline, from beginning to end, that touches that changed section of your state tree. That is where all the boilerplate comes from, and that is why Redux is consistently criticized as a system that becomes more and more unwieldy as your UI complexity grows. It is a bad abstraction for the problem at hand. Mobx is a far better pattern IMO, and I feel entirely comfortable saying that is an objective position to take as long as your functionality is more likely to change than your rendering. It isn't that Mobx is a superior idea, it's just the fact that it embraced object composition for a use case that is perfect for it. [0] http://wiki.c2.com/?ExpressionProblem http://wiki.c2.com/?ExpressionProblem