5 ms·
> we need to learn 'the basics' and survive without tools to some degree This is the wrong approach. There's no way you wouldn't understand math much better w
by adamnemecek 9y ago
> we need to learn 'the basics' and survive without tools to some degree
This is the wrong approach. There's no way you wouldn't understand math much better with these tools.
I'm hoping that in the future, math will be less about equations and symbols and more about graphing and being able to move around in the spaces described by the equations.
I would draw an analogy with a compiler. After using it for some time, your brain will take on the shape of the compiler and you'll write correct (lol is it ever tho) code without even having to compile it.
- reikonomusha 9y agoI would claim that most folks who have a reasonable understanding of fundamental computer architecture and assembly are those who actively learned it. Folks who have just used a compiler for everything, in my experience, rarely actually develop the understanding innately. Compilers still have this "magic" element associated with them.
- adamnemecek 9y agoIt's not either or, it's a dance. You make a hypothesis in your head, verify it with a compiler. If result matches your hypothesis, move on. If not, investigate. For me personally, I thought I kinda knew assembly until I started using https://godbolt.org https://godbolt.org when I realized that I really didn't know assembly. This site helped a lot of other people as well. Note that all it does is make the process of discovery faster. But it's a tool in the same category as a calculator.
- btilly 9y agoBoth are true. Clearly we are more productive with the tools. However it is very, very easy for people to see the tools as magic. At some point we need to actually understand what it is that we are doing. For which those equations and symbols are essential. Yes, the computer can draw a pretty picture. Pretty pictures are helpful in conveying information. But they are a horrible way to understand inherently complex topics. For example pictures are essential for conveying basic concepts in in multi-variable calculus. But you won't make much sense of the topic until you actually understand the three basic mathematical representations of a surface embedded in a higher dimensional space (function, level surface, and parametrized coordinates), how each connects to the tangent to the surface at a point (whether that tangent is a line, plane, or something higher dimensional). And you need to understand this in an n-dimensional way because that comes up, a lot. So no, we won't lose equations and symbols. Ever. They are essential, and there is no possibility of real understanding without them.
- adamnemecek 9y ago> So no, we won't lose equations and symbols. Ever. They are essential, and there is no possibility of real understanding without them. I didn't say get rid of them. But I think that if you see a complex equation, you should be able to roughly imagine it in your head. Working only with symbols won't get you there.
- btilly 9y agoBut I think that if you see a complex equation, you should be able to roughly imagine it in your head. Working only with symbols won't get you there. You're wrong. To take a real example, visualize G_{\mu \nu }+\Lambda g_{\mu \nu }={8\pi G \over c^{4}}T_{\mu \nu }. I dare you. That's Einstein's field equations for General Relativity. I don't visualize a system of 2nd order partial differential equations involving many dimensions at each point in a 4-dimensional coordinate system. Do you? Furthermore people differ on how visual they are. If you're someone who has to visualize things to understand them, you're hardly alone. Lots of people are like that. But then again there are people like me whose thinking is almost entirely non-visual. If I'm dealing with something abstract, not only do I not think visually, but a purely visual explanation doesn't really help me much.
- adamnemecek 9y agoI mean this particular equation not really no but that might be because I haven't done much general relativity. But I can kinda visualize other somewhat complicated equations. Sure but then you are giving an advantage to the more visual people no? Can't I just flip your argument? Yes, symbols are useful but you should have an understand of what they are actually doing.
- btilly 9y agoSure but then you are giving an advantage to the more visual people no? Can't I just flip your argument? Sure, you can flip the argument. You'll be wrong, but you just did it. People naturally lean towards understanding using different methods. Each mode of thinking has strengths and weaknesses, and so do people. Some things are better understood visually. Other things not. Some things have the best way of understanding varying by person. So yes, on some things you'll have an advantage over me because you're visual. On some things I'll have an advantage over you because I probably understand complex abstract relations more naturally than you do. And your insistence that everyone is best off trying to think like you do is completely misguided. Anyways I've explained my position enough. If you don't wish to get it, you won't. I'll let other people take over the task.
- Chris2048 9y agoMany vocations use computers, but should they all require learning about software, electronics etc? If you don't need to "understand" the math, why risk opportunity cost learning it? > I would draw an analogy with a compiler staying "high level" is a good thing for some programmers. If every web dev had to dig into the low-level working of the browser, a lot less would get done.