7 ms·
As much as I'd like to reduce my reliance on "cloud" services, Gmail is one of those that I just can't quit, since they've pretty much solved the spam problem f
by ryandrake 9y ago
As much as I'd like to reduce my reliance on "cloud" services, Gmail is one of those that I just can't quit, since they've pretty much solved the spam problem for me. I'd rather a few false positives get filtered than the deluge that comes with inadequate (self-hosted) E-mail.
Sorry if this guy's "audience building" business is affected, but as an end user not worried about "my open rate", I appreciate Google's aggressive filtering and urge them not to let up.
- mikl 9y agoThat’s fine for you, but believe it or not, there are actually people who sign up for newsletters voluntarily because they want to stay informed about something. Google shouldn’t try to override the user’s preference about receiving newsletters.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- CydeWeys 9y agoMark a few of the messages as important and you won't miss future ones. Given how pervasive getting signed up for email lists is even when I don't really want to be on them, the opt-in model makes more sense for me than the opt-out model.
- rtx 9y agoTrue, but the solution should be double optin not something managed by Google.
- CydeWeys 9y agoMailing lists that aren't double opt-in are way more likely to be managed by Google on behalf of the user than those that are. The spammy mailing lists are way more likely to get spam-filtered by users who were "opted-in" to them by the mailer. Google's solution is necessary because bad actors in email abound.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pmontra 9y agoMore or less any business that sells domains also offers POP3 or IMAP mailboxes with spam filters and some web mail interface (which I'm not using). That's what I've been using for my two primary domains (vanity personal and business one) since 2004 and 2006. Those filters work pretty well. I can't compare with Google's one but they're enough. I prefer to get some extra spam than losing a business email and maybe a new customer. Maybe there is a way to keep using Gmail, read from an external POP3/IMAP mailbox and disable Google's antispam on messages fetched from there.
- CodeWriter23 9y agoLet us know how you feel when Google starts filtering out transactional emails for your company and your chargeback rate goes up as a result.
- acidburnNSA 9y agoA reasonable sentiment, for sure. I'm curious though, have you tried self-hosting email recently? Spam-assassin with razor2, pyzor, and Bayesian learning is really working pretty well for me. I train every 6-12 months based on my most recent 10k spams. I get a few false negatives but I can tune my spam threshold so that swings to a few false positives with one quick vim session. Dovecot + Thunderbird even gives you client editing of server-side filtering based on all sorts of criteria, and self-hosted webmail (e.g. MailBox) is pretty good these days as well for when you're on the go.
- ryandrake 9y agoIt's been on my list of things to do "some time later," as I understand the tools have gotten much better. I suppose my belief that self-hosted E-mail necessarily means inadequate spam filtering may be a relic of a time long past.
- mcguire 9y agoSpam-assassin soaked up too much memory for my cheap, tiny virtual server. I recently set up rspamd, which seems to work as well and, while it is still the largest process on my machine, hasn't forced a reboot yet.
- pmlnr 9y agoDspam used to be great, but now it's mostly unmaintained :(
- roblabla 9y agoUrg. The thing is, I run my own personal email server. It's not used for spam ever. It's only personal email to family members, friends, and the odd reach out to support. The volume of email is so small it's ridiculous. I might send up to 10 mail (1 receiver each) per month. I set it up with SPF and DKIM properly, triple checked. And yet, for whatever reason, sometimes my email end in spam. Generally when I send attachment (like pictures). But sometimes it's just completely arbitrary. How about this : for you it might be a "few false positive", because so much of the wanted mail traffic originates from google in the first place. But for the few of us that use mail as was intended, this becomes a huge problem. Having a mailing list doesn't necessarely mean the content is unwanted. I'm subscribed to HN replies for instance. I want those email. If it started going to spam, I might consider "hey it's a few false positive". But for the HN replies guys, it would be maddening to be unable to fix the problem because Google can't be arsed to have a support channel. From my POV, Google is way past "aggressive filtering" territory and way into "monopolistic behavior".
- mikl 9y agoYeah, I’ve seen the same, to the point that I’ve actually considered getting a Gmail account for my business, because customers not receiving important e-mail is bad for business.
- mysterydip 9y agoAnd I think that's half their goal. Why fix something if it gets you more customers (direct or roundabout)?
- mikl 9y agoYeah, it certainly looks rather sinister.
- acidburnNSA 9y agoOk so as much as I promote self-hosting email, you're right. I've also had trouble with mail originating on my server to gmail and only gmail accounts. I did recently discover that I had some configuration issues via mail-tester.com though (my rDNS didn't match the HELO of my server) so now that I'm getting a 10/10 on that, things seem a bit better. I definitely felt that gmail was being too aggressive on this too. I sent a bunch of detailed replies to middle/high schoolers working on science projects when they reached out through my public-education webpage and when they went to gmail I never got a reply but if they went to some other server, the conversations usually continued nicely. That was pretty frustrating.
- jacobr 9y agoI switched to FastMail from GMail earlier this year, did not notice any increase in spam to an address I've used publicly for at least 15 years.
- mstade 9y agoI've been on Fastmail going on a year now, and spam was my biggest worry coming from gmail. But honestly I don't think I've received any spam in my inbox at all since doing the switch, and only occasionally had to check the spam folder for a missing email I was expecting. It's been surprisingly solid I think. I'm very glad to be off gmail.
- tjoff 9y ago"I'd rather a few false positives get filtered than the deluge that comes with inadequate (self-hosted) E-mail." The main reason you need a spam-filter is because your address ends with @gmail.com. Man I've lost important mails due to gmail, I'd never use it for anything remotely serious. Works fine for interactions within google-services though. But apart from that there is no decent client and their notification support is not reliable either, nor can you rely on their spam-filter. Why even bother with email if you are going to use gmail?
- josteink 9y ago> As much as I'd like to reduce my reliance on "cloud" services, Gmail is one of those that I just can't quit, since they've pretty much solved the spam problem for me. It's overrated. And like mentioned in this article: it makes regular email delivery unreliable. For me FastMail has largely replaced gmail. I'm much more happy with them than I ever was with gmail. And they have an actual support channel. Edit: the "gmail is the only real option" meme is getting pretty tired. They were clearly the best option 10 years ago, but times have changed. No need to repeat old truisms.
- Semaphor 9y agoBack before I switched to fastmail I'd sometimes stop receiving newsletters. Because Google randomly decided the newsletter I've been receiving for ages and never marked as spam is suddenly spam. Fastmail on the other hand only classifies spam as spam (with way less than one spam mail per month getting through) which for me is far superior to Google's "I have to check the spam folder regularly because anything can end up there"
- mintplant 9y agoI would love if I could set the spam filter to include "audience building"/"growth hacking" emails. I have TENS OF THOUSANDS of emails in my inbox because every startup wants to "boost their engagement". Startups have given me Pavlovian email anxiety.
- motoboi 9y agoAnd what about email newsletters you subscribed to? Those you _want_ to receive? Because is about those ones the article is about.
- corobo 9y ago> Gmail is one of those that I just can't quit Literally just started to switch back today from Fastmail > since they've pretty much solved the spam problem for me #1 reason. I tried Fastmail for a month or two but I've only just hit the 200 spam messages to train my "personal" spam filter, all of them "greetings of the day" website/SEO related. Realised I've been fighting to get to this personal filter level and then when it enabled.. I received another spam message. I'm out. Love the idea of not relying on Google for everything but I guess for now spam filtering is just one of those things Google does good.
- eridius 9y agoYou just barely trained your spam filter and are surprised that you got another spam? Why are you giving up so early? The spam filter only gets better over time, and you're quitting without giving it a chance. Also note that you can tweak your spam preferences. For example, I have mine set to mark things at spam at a score of 4.0 instead of the default score of 5.0.
- thatswrong0 9y agoGmail user here: I like the fact that Gmail's spam filter just works. The false positive rate is incredibly low for me.. things rarely end up in my spam folder that don't belong there. And I didnt have to configure anything. Why should I want to struggle for so long to get the same level of functionality?
- eridius 9y agoBack before I switched to FastMail, I did actually have to keep an eye on my Gmail spam folder, because stuff I wanted would end up there every now and then. And the very subject of this article is emails that people want to receive getting filed into spam by Gmail (but not by other mail hosts).
- corobo 9y agoIt was the #1 reason. Other issues were I had about 480 emails in my inbox. I'm not sure where the difference is but I've always managed an "Inbox Zero" with Googles' Inbox There are other things I missed from Inbox too such as reminders "hit t - set reminder", snoozing emails till another time and I have a few people that contact me via Hangouts so I ended up loading Inbox occasionally anyway to see those messages. No fault on Fastmail really, if I'd never discovered Inbox I'd still be using it. In regards to spam I just can't be dealing with training a spam filter, I was reminded it was one of the reasons I switched from self hosted to Gmail in the first place. Edit: For what it's worth the SEO and website spam emails weren't getting a spam rating at all, most were <2.0 Edit 2: Also while looking at the spambox for that last message I now realise a lot of my server backup status messages were going into the spam box with a 7.1 spam rating. Edit 3: I'm going to stop editing after this one. Edit 2 was on me, the backup messages were sending direct rather than via mailgun.