5 ms·
That is a frankly astonishing misapprehension of the case. A military organization, such as that described in this article, seeks to minimize civilian casualti
by throwanem 9y ago
That is a frankly astonishing misapprehension of the case.
A military organization, such as that described in this article, seeks to minimize civilian casualties to the utmost possible extent. One of the realities of warfare is that civilian casualties can't always be entirely avoided, and a war still be prosecuted with meaningful hope of success. But the failure to avoid civilian casualties, however necessary, is regarded as a failure nonetheless, and weighs heavily on those involved - perhaps you overlooked the mention of an increased need for anti-suicide counseling after strikes in which civilian casualties occur. One does not often find "the complete devaluation of innocent human lives" coincident with contemplation of suicide as a potentially proportionate response to having taken them.
A terrorist organization, such as its current adversary, has no such scruples, and indeed will often seek to inflict as much atrocity on innocents as it can manage. The incentives, and the balance of advantage and disadvantage, for irregular fighters, are such that the involvement of civilians - not just as targets, but also as human shields and as a sort of moving camouflage in which to conceal oneself - is an utter necessity, because there's only one way for a stand-up fight between a regular military and a guerrilla band to end. The typical fashion in which such bands misuse innocents by default would weigh heavily on their members as well, which is why one finds such a heavy investment in ideology among these groups, whether it be religious as in the current case or secular as in the case of last century's "Communist revolutionaries". You have to have some story to tell yourself that makes your flagrant abuse of civilians seem righteous - in other words, to devalue innocent human lives enough that you can live with the things you do to them.
To casually equate such wanton violation of every civilized standard of conduct, with the extreme if admittedly at times imperfect care that military forces exercise to avoid behaving even remotely similarly, strikes me as something that must be motivated either by arrant ignorance of the facts underlying the case, or by some sort of ideologically motivated disinterest in them. Neither seems to me terribly useful in developing an accurate apprehension of reality.
- hasenj 9y ago> A military organization, such as that described in this article, seeks to minimize civilian casualties to the utmost possible extent. This has only become the case officially after WWII. And frankly I think the only reason this even matters is the media. Civilian lives meant absolutely nothing and were considered fair target during war. Millions died in WWII from intentional fire bombing campaigns on urban areas by the allied forces. Same in the Korean war. Same during the Vietnam war. Civilians were purposely targeted to "demoralize the enemy" and force them to surrender. The official difference between war and terrorism is that war must be officially declared by a government and have specific objectives and once the objective is reached then the killing should stop.
- vain 9y ago> The official difference between war and terrorism is that war must be officially declared by a government and have specific objectives and once the objective is reached then the killing should stop. What's your source for this definition?
- hordeallergy 9y agoAlso, haven't isil declared war, and with specific objectives?
- throwanem 9y agoWhich government has recognized ISIL's claim to sovereignty in those territories it still holds, or indeed in any territory at all?
- vacri 9y agoThe US and Russia both have claims to sovereignty there!?
- throwanem 9y agoISIL's claim is the one under discussion, though. That's the one whose recognition would signify in the question of whether their actions are legitimate warfare, by the standard cited earlier in this thread. US and Russian claims are a different question altogether.
- vacri 9y agoISIL's actions in the war zone are acts of war and have fairly standard military objectives. ISIL's actions against uninvolved countries by directly attacking their citizens is terrorism. It's not an either/or situation.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ComputerGuru 9y agoBut the failure to avoid civilian casualties, however necessary, is regarded as a failure nonetheless, and weighs heavily on those involved - perhaps you overlooked the mention of an increased need for anti-suicide counseling after strikes in which civilian casualties occur. One does not often find "the complete devaluation of innocent human lives" coincident with contemplation of suicide as a potentially proportionate response to having taken them. I don't know. You need to distinguish between the "soldiers" such as those in the article and the ones you describe as needing counseling and suffering from the effects, and the people up top calling the shots and deciding policy. While a soldier may decide on a per-case basis what is acceptable collateral damage, that decision doesn't exist in a void, it's rooted in the policies and guidelines of the organization set by people that, one could argue, are not placing the same premium on human life.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- madez 9y agoI wonder why you differentiate so much between the life of a civilian and a non-civilian. You imply that as soon as you decide to fight — be it righteous or not — you forfeit your life and it is okay to kill you. Isn't it equally bad if a civilian dies as to when someone who fights dies? The attitude behind these ideas stink of arrogant bigotry. It reeks of the shit you get from the abrahamistic relevation-based religions.
- Filligree 9y agoNever mind the religion. This attitude--differentiating based on civilian-ness--is useful. Spreading it allows wars to do less damage, because if fewer civilians die then repairing the economy is easier afterwards. This leads to a host of good consequences, most importantly that it reduces the chance of renewed war later on. Soldiers' lives aren't as important, in that sense. Sorry, but they're not. And soldiers are going to die no matter what; the cultural innovation here isn't treating soldiers' lives as worth little, it's treating civilians as highly valuable. Some of which has later spread to the soldiers as well...
- madez 9y ago> This attitude--differentiating based on civilian-ness--is useful. I disagree. War must be deadly and costly for both sides. Human intercation is heavily based on deterrents. One can see that in interactions in small and big groups. Taking away the deadliness and cost of war will make it happen more often. Besides the obvious example, there is peace in europe for so long only because the war before has been so costly and deadly. A power in the world that can wage military conflicts without significant loss in their rows is a disaster for the world.
- throwanem 9y agoWhat of a power that treats its enemy's scruples over civilian casualties as a vulnerability to be exploited?
- deleted 9y ago
- RodericDay 9y ago> In 1985, when I was the Deputy Director of the Reagan White House Task Force on Terrorism, [my working group was asked] to come up with a definition of terrorism that could be used throughout the government. We produced about six, and each and every case, they were rejected, because careful reading would indicate that our own country had been involved in some of those activities. […] After the task force concluded its work, Congress [passed] U.S. Code Title 18, Section 2331 ... the US definition of terrorism. […] one of the terms, "international terrorism," means "activities that," I quote, "appear to be intended to affect the conduct of a government by mass destruction, assassination or kidnapping." […] Yes, well, certainly, you can think of a number of countries that have been involved in such activities. Ours is one of them. […] And so, the terrorist, of course, is in the eye of the beholder.[62] - Edward Peck, former U.S. Chief of Mission in Iraq (under Jimmy Carter) and former ambassador to Mauritania For what it's worth, I'm not american (canadian), but your post reads like pure unadulterated american propaganda to me. Stuff like putting "communist revolutionaries" in quotes, repeating the unsourced myth that american patriot soldiers suffer with suicidal ideation because they feel remorse, etc. It's like we're from two different worlds.
- throwanem 9y agoIt's worth keeping in mind that the profession of a diplomat in large part involves, indeed above all requires, the ability to see the matter from the other fellow's point of view. We've had perennial problems with our own diplomats being so skilled at it that they forget which country commands their allegiance. Here, Mr. Peck's partial citation is carefully circumscribed in a fashion that seems impossible to read as other than tendentious. The first term set out in 18 USC 2331's definition of the term "international terrorism" [1] is thus: > As used in this chapter-- > the term “international terrorism” means activities that-- > involve violent acts or acts dangerous to human life that are a violation of the criminal laws of the United States or of any State, or that would be a criminal violation if committed within the jurisdiction of the United States or of any State; While I'm happy to concede that the US government has taken a somewhat cavalier line with regard to its own policies on the declaration of war, our legal and judicial systems have yet at this time to find that such conduct is unlawful. Until that changes, there seems no clear argument to be made that that conduct qualifies as "international terrorism" under the definition our law provides. To claim that the problem of suicide among US soldiers and veterans is mere "unsourced myth" is to say the least remarkable. You may care to examine a recent report [2] on the matter, produced by our Department of Veterans' Affairs - an organization whose misfeasance is legendary among veterans themselves and among other Americans knowledgeable on the matter, so if anything, even the vastly disproportionate rates there described are still likely to be low. Or you may not care to examine it, preferring instead to continue in the comfortable fancy that I'm just making this all up to serve my turn. I don't really care either way which you choose, but the facts are here before you, if you have any interest in them. As for the rest - I do suppose I can understand how it might seem that way, for all that the difference is purely one of perception and analysis. I don't see any compelling reason at this time to privilege your perception and analysis over mine - and it does seem as though yours is somewhat less universally shared than you may imagine; at any rate, some of the world's most effective snipers are countrymen of yours. Perhaps they come from a world less like yours than like mine. [1] http://codes.findlaw.com/us/title-18-crimes-and-criminal-procedure/18-usc-sect-2331.html http://codes.findlaw.com/us/title-18-crimes-and-criminal-pro... [2] https://www.mentalhealth.va.gov/docs/2016suicidedatareport.pdf https://www.mentalhealth.va.gov/docs/2016suicidedatareport.p...
- vacri 9y ago> because there's only one way for a stand-up fight between a regular military and a guerrilla band to end. In a political victory for the guerrillas? This kind of absolutism was killed by the Vietnam War. And the Vietnamese success against the French the previous decade kicked off the whole end-of-colonialism thing. > A military organization, such as that described in this article, seeks to minimize civilian casualties to the utmost possible extent. This is a PR line, not truth. There are plenty of militaries that don't particularly care about civilians, especially civilians that don't look like them. > A terrorist organization, such as its current adversary, has no such scruples, and indeed will often seek to inflict as much atrocity on innocents as it can manage. The Which is again a myth. The IRA would frequently phone ahead to say where and when its bombs would go off. Yes, the IRA killed people, but it didn't seek to inflict as much atrocity on innocents as it could manage. Europe has been awash with terrorists, and they don't all go after innocents - some of them very specifically go after authority figures involved in what they perceive as their oppressors. > if admittedly at times imperfect care Words fail me. Doubly so given that the reason we have ISIS as a military presence is because of the 'admittedly imperfect care' of the invasion conducted by the exact same military we're talking about here.
- throwanem 9y ago"Stand-up fight" means open combat. Guerrilla forces avoid that precisely because it's unwinnable for them, and instead employ tactics that play to their own strengths rather than those of their adversaries. In the case of the Vietnam War, those strengths were twofold: on the one hand, the NVA and Viet Cong knew the country in a way that we didn't and could leverage the civilian population in ways we couldn't; on the other hand, they knew it wasn't really a fight our nation had ever wanted, and by making it as ugly and interminable as possible, they could convince the US that continuing the war wasn't worth the atrocities and the casualties it would cost us to achieve anything we could call a win. The IRA is a special case. Early on in their conflict, they employed typical guerrilla schrecklichkeit tactics - it was only later, when their leadership realized that killing English civilians was hardening opposition against them rather than advancing their goals, that they switched to targeting the English economy rather than its people. They found much more success that way, too - but they couldn't have done it at all absent the coincidence of geography that put them close enough to English economic centers for the tactic to be viable. I shouldn't like to be mistaken for saying that all the moral opprobrium in conflicts like those we discuss should accrue to one side or the other. As I said in another comment here, warfare means having to choose, not between right and wrong, but what looks to be least among the wrongs which are all that that form of human interaction makes available. Even when proceeding from the best of intentions, people can't be relied upon to always make the choice which is clearly correct in retrospect - and, of course, people don't always proceed from the best of intentions. I'm not interested in defending the actions that brought us to the present state of affairs, because I regard them in the main as indefensible. But regardless of how we got here, we are here, and I fail to grasp how slandering our own military forces with the name "terrorist" in any way advances the purpose of finding a path forward that involves the minimum extent of atrocity, on all sides, that we can possibly manage to produce.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]