3 ms·
Sometimes I see Tesla and it seems like 10% engineering and 90% BS and Elon Musk reality distortion aura a la Steve Jobs.
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
Sometimes I see Tesla and it seems like 10% engineering and 90% BS and Elon Musk reality distortion aura a la Steve Jobs.
- brianwawok 9y agoThat is Apple. Tesla is landing rockets on little boats. Apple is adding little color icons where F1-F12 used to be.
- SEJeff 9y agoSpaceX is landing rockets (14 story first stages of Falcon 9 rockets to be specific), on massive Automated Drone Ships roughly the size of football fields, but sure, little boats works too :)
- bluejekyll 9y agoI think you're grossly undervaluing the impact Apple has had in computing over the years. The iPhone is an engineering accomplishment, which has served to remake the way that people interact with each other. The comparison of Apple and Tesla/SpaceX in terms of what they produce is practically apples and oranges. I don't get why people are so quick to dismiss the accomplishments of Apple; there've been numerous technologies that they backed, which are now critical to computing today. LLVM for example (yes, technically came out of a phd), this has been huge for the computing industry as a whole... I know it's not a rocket, but the software that runs and uses the satellites is just as important as launching the satellites (and no, I have no idea if any satellites use LLVM for any compilation).
- rxhernandez 9y agoFor me at least, you're grossly overvaluing how much of an engineering accomplishment the iPhone was. I had windows mobile phones for at least a couple years before the iPhone came out and those phones had basic functionality that the iPhone was plain missing for years like mms and copy/paste.
- tinus_hn 9y agoYeah if only Bill Gates had had the same charisma as Steve Jobs, we would all be walking around with these fantastic fixed keyboard resistive touch models with user interfaces that require pens, instead of these boring multitouch slate smartphones.
- anko 9y agoThere is this common misunderstanding that technical people have when it comes to design. I think it's because a list of features makes it seem easy to "compare" two things fairly. It works especially well in the enterprise - if you're in that space you just add an MVP for every feature your competitors have, so when your clients are comparing products yours always seems like a better deal. The thing about design is, it's about tradeoffs. Good design is stripping things down to their most essential - working out what matters most. It's having courage to say no before something is ready. I would argue that copy/paste was added to iphone prematurely - it only became good when force (3d) touch was introduced. This stuff has been argued to death because people dislike apple's decisions. Like them or not, the iPhone changed the industry and set the bar for the competition. If a windows phone was so compelling, everyone would have had one! If MMS was so important then why don't we all have nokias? The proof is in the market! that stuff doesn't matter as much as having an easy to use interface, which was partly multi touch, but also a heck of a lot of engineering.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoIsn't part of Musk's genius his ability as a bullshit artist? He is a brilliant engineer and visionary, but take away his showmanship and he's just another balding engineer. Doesn't mean his showmanship isn't impressive. Just like Jobs.
- darawk 9y agoThat's not really fair to Musk. The man has created a string of extraordinary companies. He has done objectively impressive things on a scale and with a frequency that is objectively highly unusual. He is a showman, and to some extent a bullshit artist. But to say he's "just another balding engineer", or even to say he's "just like Jobs" is to unfairly discredit him, imo.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wvenable 9y ago> showmanship Have you seen Elon Musk give a keynote? The man is no Steve Jobs. He should actually spend a little more time working on his showmanship.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoYeah but what is this other than brilliant self-marketing? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mh45igK4Esw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mh45igK4Esw He's a really really good marketer. No disrespect in recognizing that.
- prawn 9y agoOutside of your assessment of engineering, vision and showmanship, you're ignoring the fact that he's leading some seriously ambitious and successful projects. "he's just another balding engineer" You say that like you're trying to knock him down a peg, like he reads HN comments and cares. Is that really necessary for any argument?
- bane 9y agoOnly Musk's reality distortion field seems to be actually distorting reality.