4 ms·
The second chart is all you need to look at. It can't be healthy for a society if only the top few percent see any income gains and for the rest incomes stagnat
by maxxxxx 9y ago
The second chart is all you need to look at. It can't be healthy for a society if only the top few percent see any income gains and for the rest incomes stagnate.
- mac01021 9y agoIt may be all you need to look at if your goal is merely to scoff at the state of affairs and reaffirm your egalitarian self-identity. If you want to thoroughly understand the problem so that you can reason intelligently about what a solution might look like, you'll probably want more data.
- nickthemagicman 9y agoHow can that be interpreted in a positive light to have all of the economic gains of a country going to a small few?
- thehardsphere 9y agoBecause "income" does not equal "all of the economic gains of a country." Lots of other things happened in the period in that graph which kept median incomes lower despite economic improvements taking place. Like: 1. The offering of health insurance as a tax-free employment benefit. 2. An increase in divorce rates (households all over cut in half but the median household income didn't drop; there must have been an economic gain distributed to not-rich people for this to happen). Also, this graph doesn’t say anything about what happened to the size of each of these groups. Pretty sure the biggest trend in America has been the middle class splitting in half between people making more money (and thus becoming part of the "small few") and people making less (which worsens income inequality even though more people are now "rich"). So yeah, there's a lot missing from these graphs.
- nickthemagicman 9y agoThe goal of the graph is to generalize large scale income distributions/gains on a large sample size of hundreds of millions of people. Not to go into every single micro sub group of income earners and divorced neurologists with company sponsored health insurance who have more income than an tech worker homeowner with 6 cats. The graph is perfectly valid for what it represents. The share on a large sample size of hundreds of millions of people of historical income gains and results can be interpreted thusly.
- rbcgerard 9y agoI do t think these charts take into account benefits (I.e. Health insurance) which means that for many people income has not grown, but total compensation has grown, those workers just didn't get to choose where to spend it...
- maxxxxx 9y agoIn my view health care should be added to inflation. Then the chart would look even worse
- thehardsphere 9y agoInflation is a monetary phenomenon that affects all prices in the economy. If there's only a price increase in one sector it's by definition not inflation.
- crdoconnor 9y agoNot true. When the oil crisis hit in the 70s for example, inflation spiked. OPEC wasn't a monetary phenomenon.
- thehardsphere 9y agoOPEC did not cause the inflation, nor did the increasing price of oil. During the same period, the US fully abandoned the gold standard and the Federal Reserve pursued a policy of loose money. Here's a brief history: http://www.investopedia.com/articles/economics/09/1970s-great-inflation.asp http://www.investopedia.com/articles/economics/09/1970s-grea...
- pmiller2 9y agoIn that case, think of that chart as representing "buying power," rather than "income."
- cheald 9y ago