4 ms·
One could argue it wasn't "augmented reality" at all. I doubt cell phones have the power to take their camera feed in, do actual computer vision to analyze the
by jerf 9y ago
One could argue it wasn't "augmented reality" at all. I doubt cell phones have the power to take their camera feed in, do actual computer vision to analyze the (arbitrary) world [1], and then overlay anything with any interesting intelligence at all. (Even if you can scrape together the specs to say that high end phones might be able to do nontrivial work, I wouldn't be surprised you hit problems like internal hardware bandwidths and such. Even before we discuss battery, which Pokemon Go certainly chewed down pretty well even without complex analysis.) Pokemon Go was just a character laid over the camera with no intelligence.
[1]: I have to qualify this because the 3DS can do some things with certain prepared cards, and cell phones nowadays outclass the 3DS quite handily. But doing any sort of analysis without such hints, which certainly have not taken off, is way harder. https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=3ds+augmented+reality+cards https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=3ds+augmented+r...
- karkisuni 9y agoI guess you haven't seen ARKit yet?
- CodeCube 9y agoheh, no kidding :) https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=ARKit&page=&utm_source=opensearch https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=ARKit&page=&utm... Even though, to his point, he's technically correct, it was just a "dumb" overlay. However, part of the excitement of the game was that you could see it in the world (both physically by having to walk around to catch it, and visually via the AR). I'm surprised you didn't see people posting pictures of pokemon in funny locations/situations back when it was really popular
- e0 9y agoThey did! For example, https://www.reddit.com/r/PokemonGoSnap/top/?sort=top&t=all https://www.reddit.com/r/PokemonGoSnap/top/?sort=top&t=all
- jerryr 9y agoThere was an app called Minecraft Reality back in 2012 that would seem to prove otherwise: https://mojang.com/2012/11/announcing-minecraft-reality-for-ios/ https://mojang.com/2012/11/announcing-minecraft-reality-for-... It placed a Minecraft creation into your environment in realtime. Though it seemed mostly like a tech demo without much of a point, it was pretty impressive when I played with it.
- Animats 9y agoI doubt cell phones have the power to take their camera feed in, do actual computer vision to analyze the (arbitrary) world [1], and then overlay anything with any interesting intelligence at all. Word Lens.
- jerf 9y agoA decent counterexample, but that's still not analysing the environment for geometry, it is doing OCR and very simple replacement. And I found it to work less well in practice than the demos showed. Though working at all is impressive.
- jpindar 9y ago> I doubt cell phones have the power to take their camera feed in, do actual computer vision to analyze the (arbitrary) world Toyota 86 AR Though you do have to put down a marker to indicate where you want the center of the racetrack to be, so there's not much analysis going on.
- j3097736 9y agoI had couple of games installed on a symbian phone (200Mhz ARM) using "AR" almost a decade ago (a table tennis one and a virus catcher thingy), they were a bit laggy but that was because without onboard sensors they had to track movement using only the camera and at the same time push video plus overlay to the display. So, not really impressed by pokemon go.