4 ms·
I'm at a loss here. Why is this authoritarian decree being cheerleaded on this site? It wasn't always like this. At one time there were a LOT more of tradition
by mindcrime 9y ago
I'm at a loss here. Why is this authoritarian decree being cheerleaded on this site?
It wasn't always like this. At one time there were a LOT more of traditional hacker-mindset types here, the ones who held to ideals like:
Mistrust authority.
Always yield to the Hands-On Imperative.
Promote decentralization.
But things have shifted over the past few years and authoritarian / big government ideas have gained a lot of currency here. I attribute it to something like the "Eternal September" phenomenon. As more and more new users flood in, the percentage of old-skool "hackers" who hold to those ideals falls.
- Caveman_Coder 9y agoYeah, its only by casual observation, but I've noticed the same trend. I remember when our community was about the tech and anti-authoritarian rabble-rousing in general. Nowadays its like our community is more interested the percentages and genders of the community and ROI/productivity/disruption/etc of the latest and greatest chat app that will be gone in a few years...
- oh_sigh 9y agoSure, because those things are trendy in this space. It's a real shame - I wish we as a subsection of society decided we had more interesting things to talk about than gender and racial equality, but that is the dominant topic for the day.
- oblio 9y agoOooooor, HackerNews has become more international and as a result has moved further left since as far as political axes go, the US is to the right of almost any other country on this planet, especially among the developed ones ;)
- mindcrime 9y agoMistrust of authority and aversion to bureaucracy isn't really a "left" OR a "right" thing though. That's why libertarians, for example, are often referred to as "left of left and right of right". I'd go as far as to say that "left" and "right" don't even really mean anything anymore. Those terms now are just pejoratives that refer to a perceived group that "doesn't agree with me". I mean, who in this day and age has a strong stake in the preservation of the French monarchy?
- euyyn 9y ago> I'd go as far as to say that "left" and "right" don't even really mean anything anymore. Those terms now are just pejoratives that refer to a perceived group that "doesn't agree with me". I can see that being the case in the US, and in other countries with de jure or de facto bipartidism. But left and right still retain their economic meaning.
- Analemma_ 9y agoAgain, see my reply to ekianjo. The idea that "old-school hackers" were all libertarians and that the "hacker ethos" always consisted of the three things you mentioned above is mostly a myth that certain people are determinedly trying to turn into fact by rewriting history. For instance, see ESR's rewrite of the Jargon File, which was condemned and disavowed by the actual old-school hackers precisely because it injected so much libertarian thinking where previously there was none.
- mindcrime 9y agoThat "old-school hackers" were all libertarians and that the "hacker ethos" always consisted of the three things you mentioned above is ... Nobody is saying that all "old-skool hackers" were libertarians, or that the "hacker ethic" is composed of nothing but those three things. But as long as I've been involved in what you could call "the hacker community" - a period of time that dates back more than 20 years now - I've observed that many self-described "hackers" did, indeed, adopt somewhat (albeit not exclusively) libertarian attitudes, and did adhere to principles like the ones mentioned above. Whether the mind-set of self-described "hackers" has changed over the years, or whether this site is simply made up of a lower percentage of "hackers" now is a question I can't really answer. Or maybe it's a combination of both. But in either case, it seems clear to me that there has been a shift in the overall tone of the community here, towards more acceptance of authoritarian approaches. And frankly I find that disturbing, but what can ya do?
- Analemma_ 9y ago> But as long as I've been involved in what you could call "the hacker community" - a period of time that dates back more than 20 years now - I've observed that many self-described "hackers" did, indeed, adopt somewhat (albeit not exclusively) libertarian attitudes, and did adhere to principles like the ones mentioned above. 20 years isn't nearly long enough to cover the phenomenon I'm describing. Part of my thesis is that, starting in the 80's, a vocal minority began attempting to redefine the "hacker ethos" to conform with their specific libertarian views, and that in the 90s, venture capitalists and SV "thought leaders" eagerly co-opted and encouraged this redefinition so that their drones would oppose any regulations that might get in the way of profit. So the fact that you've seen lots of libertarians in hacker spaces from the 90's onward doesn't disprove my point. > And frankly I find that disturbing, but what can ya do? You could start by realizing that calling your opponent's views "disturbing" does not automatically give you any moral weight. For example, I find it disturbing that people - equate "banning plastic bags" with tyranny - refuse to accept that coordination problems and externalities are a real thing and that not only is government the most efficient way to fix these issues, but, empirically, the only one that reliably works at all - are fine with widespread environmental destruction, for the sake of avoiding things they think are tyranny but really aren't but I just have to accept that you don't care about any of that.