3 ms·
Because the climate doesn't care what form of government you have. Because the free market has consistently, and utterly failed to price in the cost of polluti
by vkou 9y ago
Because the climate doesn't care what form of government you have. Because the free market has consistently, and utterly failed to price in the cost of pollution. Because people will not do the right thing that will inconvenience them.
If I start dumping my soda cans in the trash bin, the City of Seattle will fine me. Instead of complaining about authoritarians, I put them in the recycling bin. No, you won't be personally rewarded for every correct decision you make. Society doesn't owe anyone a gold star for not doing the wrong thing.
- nostromo 9y agoActually, that law in Seattle that allowed trash collectors to rummage through your trash was ruled unconstitutional under the state constitution as a violation of privacy. http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/judge-seattle-trash-check-ordinance-unconstitutional/ http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/judge-seat... That aside, I think a smarter solution is taxing the actual thing you don't want (carbon in the air via a carbon tax) rather than second order things (gasoline cars). It's much more effective. For example, if your Tesla is being powered by coal, you're doing almost nothing for the environment by switching to electric. So we need to set up the incentives thoughtfully, rather than being reactionary.
- vkou 9y ago> Actually, that law in Seattle that allowed trash collectors to rummage through your trash was ruled unconstitutional under the state constitution as a violation of privacy. This is a peculiarity of Washington state. In much of the US, and the world, once your garbage is on the curb, there is zero expectation of privacy. (And yes, I agree that we want to punish the real externality, which can be done by taxing, or banning coal, petroleum...) However, forcing a switch to electric, without banning fossil fuels would still be a net gain - an electric vehicle powered by fossil fuels produces fewer GHGs per mile driven then a gasoline one.
- greglindahl 9y agoNearly all economists agree that a carbon tax would be less distorting, but politics. You know.
- oh_sigh 9y agoYou don't need the free market to factor in the externalities of ICE pollution. If we are into government decrees, why doesn't the government just decree that you can drive whatever you want, but if you drive an ICE you will pay for your externalities? I'd imagine if gas was priced at it's true cost(including externalities), the switch to electric would be much easier.