3 ms·
What is the advantage of this over a traditional password manager? You need to sync a file so you can obtain the state needed to generate a password, just like
by mikeash 9y ago
What is the advantage of this over a traditional password manager? You need to sync a file so you can obtain the state needed to generate a password, just like a password manager. Your CSV file can be stored in a publicly accessible location without losing security, but the same is true of a password manager's database. Both are useless without the master password, and both unlock everything if the master password is compromised.
It seems to me that generating a password from a master password and some settings in a file is equivalent, both in terms of convenience and security, to decrypting a password from a master password and an encrypted password store.
- kybernetikos 9y agoI agree, there's not much in it. If you're not using proper salts there is a small advantage which is that it's usually possible to work out the settings for a site even if your sync file is lost since they will tell you the allowed characters and remembering a version number for the sites where you've changed it is not too hard especially since I show the corresponding emoji every time you log in. I also prefer it to involving a third party service which is the other way password managers often work.