4 ms·
Net use doesn't seem to be very informative. France could be exporting at crucial times to cover base load while importing when Germany's wind farms have nowher
by adrianN 9y ago
Net use doesn't seem to be very informative. France could be exporting at crucial times to cover base load while importing when Germany's wind farms have nowhere to dump their electricity because it's too windy.
- euyyn 9y agoIt also could be a matter of which factories near the borders are closer to which power plants, to save on transmission costs.
- jacquesm 9y ago> Germany's wind farms have nowhere to dump their electricity because it's too windy. That's not how it works though. Electricity isn't 'dumped' other than by lowering the price of the producers. It's not as if there is a giant resistor somewhere that gets connected in parallel to get rid of unwanted electrons. And if there are no consumers that want the power at any price what happens instead is that windmills will simply be furled. Depending on in which country this happens if the contract between the consumers and the producers stipulates it the windfarms that are requested to shut down will still get paid as if they're operational. This situation has occured in Scotland, Germany and China in the last year or so. If France can buy power from Germany at rates that are lower than what it costs them to produce the power themselves then that's actually great news for renewables. It is often said that windpower can not be used to provide base load power but that's not the whole story, you actually can provide base load power but you'll have to install a huge surplus in windpower to be able to do so with some regularity and you may end up transporting energy across distances too large to be economic. The bigger problem with this is that even if windpower generated can fluctuate quite rapidly the only plants capable of matching those fluctuations fast enough are hydro and gas turbines. Neither coal nor nuclear has the capability to follow that quickly.