2 ms·
> It's not reasonable that some people should have to work, so that others may voluntarily sit idle. But it is, under the right circumstances. If you have a m
by majewsky 9y ago
> It's not reasonable that some people should have to work, so that others may voluntarily sit idle.
But it is, under the right circumstances.
If you have a mostly automated society, where only 1% of today's human work is required to design, build and service the robots that do the actual work. Now you could have each person working half an hour per week, but that would mean that you would have to pay to educate every person out there in robot design, construction or maintenance. In this scenario, it's wildly more efficient to just educate 1% of the potential workforce and have them work 40 hours per week (or maybe 2% at 20 hours). You get the same work done, but spend way less on education (and also on auxiliary costs like payroll and shift planning).
Note that I'm explicitly only arguing with economic concerns, not social ones. If you define "reasonable" in social rather than economic terms, my argument need not apply.
> I think that without a need to work, a large fraction of people will choose not to.
Why is it then, that most people who are rich enough to sustain themselves indefinitely without having to work, still choose to work?
> The fraction of the economy spent on UBI would continue to increase due to inflation of those costs.
That's a problem, but UBI doesn't change it AFAICS. You can just reword this as "The fraction of the economy spent on food and living space would continue to increase due to inflation of these costs", and it would hold true regardless of whether there's UBI or not.
- michaelt 9y agoIf 99% of people are unemployed, it's not like there will be social sanctions, shame or other negative repercussions for being part of the 99%. Ideas like "the protestant work ethic" and "the nobility of work" will all be consigned to the past, right? What would motivate the 1% to work 40 hours a week when they could spend their time on things they enjoy instead?
- majewsky 9y agoAn expensive hobby?