5 ms·
There are laws allowing person to shoot intruder in their house. And I can't serve nulls from my own web server? That would be ridiculous.
by vbezhenar 9y ago
There are laws allowing person to shoot intruder in their house. And I can't serve nulls from my own web server? That would be ridiculous.
- blunte 9y agoDo you have an NRA?
- test1235 9y agoFrom what I've read, in some parts of America it seems okay to shoot at intruders running away from your house, which I find unreasonable. A farmer here in UK stirred up a whole load of shit when he shot two burglars [1] trying to escape from his property. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tony_Martin_(farmer) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tony_Martin_(farmer)
- rmc 9y agoThe UK (or English?) law about self defence is "back to the wall", i.e. you can invoke leathal force to defend your own life when your back is against the wall, when you have no other option, and no way to escape. In other words, if you can retreat from the situation, then you must retreat. Some places in the USA have "stand your ground" laws. These say you aren't required to retreat, that you can "stand your ground", that you can use (legally) leathal force without requiring that your back is against the wall.
- rocqua 9y agoAs I recall, stand your ground laws, based on castle doctrine, means that "but you could have fled your own home" does not invalidate self-defence. I think you are still required to retreat when on the street. As for people running away, the only way I see self defence working is when they still pose an 'imminent threat to life' which seems rather hard to argue.
- test1235 9y agoYour last line is the bit I've never been able to understand. If someone is running from you, do you have any legal argument for killing them?
- suneilp 9y agoWhat if they have stolen your property. Do you not have the right to get it back by force? Does the value of the property matter? If so, who gets to decide that in the moment?
- icefo 9y agoIf you live in Texas you can use deadly force if "the land or property cannot be protected or recovered by any other means". Source: http://codes.findlaw.com/tx/penal-code/penal-sect-9-42.html http://codes.findlaw.com/tx/penal-code/penal-sect-9-42.html I've read but couldn't find again the story of someone shooting a tief to get back his VHS player and walk free.
- chillydawg 9y agoYou have zero right to kill someone for stealing.
- technofiend 9y agoIn Texas you may make use of your weapon to stop the execution of a crime if you yourself are not also engaged in criminal activity. It's far larger than castle doctrine because it applies anywhere. I'm not arguing for actually using the law to shoot people: I don't ever want to be in that situation myself, but I'm saying depending on the situation you do in fact have the law on your side.
- rocqua 9y agoThe value of the property does not matter. They do not pose a lethal threat and therefor cannot be shot. At least, that's how it should be, I don't know legally.
- andrewla 9y agoUK common law as it pertains to "duty to retreat" and "self-defence", is largely a question for the jury. There is no fixed legal standard other than whether the actions were reasonable given the person's knowledge of the situation at the time. The US tends to be a little more prescriptive, leaving a situation where different jurisdictions have more specific requirements for defining what constitutes self-defense. Juries in the UK tend to have significantly more responsibility for making judgments like these, leading to a system where evolving views of what is right and wrong can result in standards naturally evolving over time, rather than being fixed by what people thought was okay thirty years ago.
- kodt 9y agoYes, in Texas you can use lethal force to prevent a burglary, robbery or theft (at night) and can also use lethal force on someone fleeing with stolen property in order to recover it.
- rmc 9y agoMost of those laws are self defence laws. The US & the UK have slight differences, but you're often allowed to use leathal force to prevent yourself being killed.
- vacri 9y agoYou're allowed to use equal force in the UK, as I understand it, which means if someone attacks you with fists, you can't shoot them in return. If you're in danger of being killed, then you'd be able to use lethal force.