7 ms·
Under the Hood of Luminar's Long-Reach Lidar
- mozumder 9y agoYou can have all the sensor-tech in the world, but self-driving cars aren't going to take off until you have standardized car-to-car communications and smart roadways designed for self-driving cars, such as pre-mapped lanes and surfaces as well as smart roads communicating road-condition and obstruction information.
- blane88 9y agoA "digital rail" with centralized traffic control is much safer and much more practical. Autonomous is a dead end. People make the mistake of looking at early progress (starting at 0 base line) and thinking it will not stop till it is perfect. It is like when we went from 100mhz to 1Ghz chips and people were saying "in 10 years we will have 10Ghz chips" but in reality we never will.
- 05 9y agoSure, but that means separated roads without pedestrians, cyclists and non-autonomous vehicles. Not really politically possible. And it's an incompatible system, so you don't have any benefits until you've sunk a huge ton of money - a total non-starter in most countries.
- Animats 9y agoCar-to-car communications are not necessary for automatic driving. They may even be undesirable, as a potential source of bad info. Google/Waymo doesn't need them. They make the point that there are lots of things in the environment, from bicyclists to moose, that aren't going to cooperate with the system. The need for super-detailed maps is probably temporary. A reasonable goal is to have the ability to drive anything with a basic map (Google StreetView level) at slow speed, then retain info to do it again at faster speed. Some of that mapping info may later be uploaded for use by others.
- diggernet 9y agoI really hope they get self driving cars working with nothing more than current GPS maps, plus lots of sensors. Considering the drive I took this weekend, past actively changing construction zones, landslides, along infrequently traveled roads (and even a logging road), I wouldn't want to trust my life to stale data.
- Animats 9y agoWe did all that in the DARPA Grand Challenge over a decade ago. Most of the problems today involve dealing with other road users. (Some of the self-driving car projects today are less capable on bad roads than the off-road systems of 2005. They don't have to be; it just comes from focusing on lane following on freeways as the primary goal.)
- amatic 9y agoI'd love to see self-riding multileg robots, like an advanced version of Boston Dynamics alpha dog. You don't even need roads for them. With some kind of super-stability they could become more comfortable than vehicles. Perhaps we'll have human carying drones a bit soner, though. Still, in a bit more distant future, roads might become obsolete.
- nacnud 9y agoRiding one of those, galloping along at 70mph, would be quite something. (I guess it's the legged-equivalent of a motorbike?) You'd have to have a lot of trust..
- Animats 9y agoIt's been tried a few times. Early versions were really clunky. Later versions were usually art projects. * General Electric Walking Truck (1969) [1] * Adaptive Suspension Vehicle (1984) [2] * Korean giant mecha (2016) [3] The BPG Motors Uno transforming motorcycle seemed a good idea, but they gave up on it.[4] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZMGCFLEYakM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZMGCFLEYakM [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DIiD1JimBXQ&feature=youtu.be&t=25 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DIiD1JimBXQ&feature=youtu.be... [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bqZWNn5qZ7U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bqZWNn5qZ7U [4] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=odI4WaYEcCU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=odI4WaYEcCU
- gozur88 9y agoI would settle for a car that drives exactly as well as I do, and non of that stuff is required to meet that goal.
- bcatanzaro 9y agoThe article says Luminar's advantage comes largely from wavelength: the longer wavelength they use is absorbed more strongly by water, meaning it won't penetrate to the retina, even at higher power, which allows them to have much better range and resolution. But what about the weather? The atmosphere often contains water. Does anyone know Luminar's performance in fog or rain? I'm always worried self-driving cars will be set back by having so much of their development take place in sunny California.
- Symmetry 9y agoLuminar's lidar beams will be absorbed by water rather than scattered so fog will effectively seem black to it rather than white and it will be just as unable to see through rain or fog as normal lidar or your eye. Thankfully if it's going to be developed in SF they'll be getting a lot of experience with fog.
- dweekly 9y agoTrue. For details on relative absorption and scattering and performance on rangefinding at 905nm vs 1550nm see https://www.degruyter.com/downloadpdf/j/oere.2014.22.issue-3/s11772-014-0190-2/s11772-014-0190-2.pdf https://www.degruyter.com/downloadpdf/j/oere.2014.22.issue-3...
- ianai 9y agoWhy use lasers at all? My brain doesn't need anything like a laser to figure out where objects are in relation to me. Is there something about a human eye that a camera can't reproduce for a machine?
- diggernet 9y agoYes. The human eye is attached to the human brain, which we haven't yet been able to reproduce for the machine.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> the human eye is attached to the human brain And those human brains are attached to human arms which navigate Americans into 32,000 motor vehicle deaths a year [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_motor_vehicle_deaths_in_U.S._by_year https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_motor_vehicle_deaths_i...
- diggernet 9y agoSure, but that's not what ianai asked. The question was what makes an eye better than a camera. You are comparing the human brain to a hypothetical future ideal machine brain. Replace every single driver on the road today with current state of the art machine brains operating under exactly the same conditions, and that 32k death toll will look good in comparison.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoOP asked why we need more sophisticated hardware for self-driving cars than human drivers possess. My response is that the status quo is not good enough for an emerging technology. Self-driving cars are not politically viable if they kill a hundred people a day. They may not be viable if they kill 1/10th that number. That's why we need better sensors for them than we possess.
- Symmetry 9y ago
- Animats 9y ago200m for a mechanically scanned LIDAR isn't a big deal. There are older flash LIDARs that can reach 400m with a 9 degree field of view.[1] Flash LIDARs have a field of view vs. range tradeoff, since they illuminate the entire field of view at one time. Range gated imagers, another form of flash LIDAR, have ranges out to kilometers.[2] (Those guys are using a lot of power, but it's spread over a wide area.) The eye safety problem can be overcome by making the outgoing beam bigger. What matters is how much energy comes through a hole about 1/4" in diameter, the size of the pupil of the human eye. If you enlarge the outgoing beam, by running it through a collimator backwards, the energy per unit area decreases. Expand a beam to a 2" circle and you have reduced the power per unit area by about 50. The risk is to someone coming up to the thing and staring into the beam, not out at range where energy per unit area is much lower. Cost remains a bigger issue than range. Give it 2-3 years. [1] http://www.advancedscientificconcepts.com/products/older-products/tigereye.html http://www.advancedscientificconcepts.com/products/older-pro... [2] https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCLrAizlR4ry9Nu6A7BXBBdg https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCLrAizlR4ry9Nu6A7BXBBdg
- jacquesm 9y agoAre there any cumulative effects regarding eye safety? As in: if 100's of cars in your field of view, say a traffic jam in the opposing lane are all firing LIDAR would it add up to trouble?
- diggernet 9y agoExcellent question. I foresee a booming market in lidar-blocking sunglasses.
- foobiekr 9y agoI wonder how this affects non-human eyes.
- deegles 9y agoHow do Lidar devices deal with potentially dozens of other Lidars operating in the same area?