4 ms·
I forget which of The Innovator's Dilemma and The Innovator's Solution had the section on electric cars. But back in the 1990s it was projected that on current
by btilly 9y ago
I forget which of The Innovator's Dilemma and The Innovator's Solution had the section on electric cars. But back in the 1990s it was projected that on current trends, electric cars would become viable around 2020. And explained why it was likely that traditional manufacturers would fumble the ball, all offer hybrids, and in the end most would go out of business because they couldn't make the transition.
It is worth reading those books and understanding the thesis. Because it is directly relevant to the current situation. We are looking at the gas -> electric conversion, in about the projected time frame, and all of the reasons for why traditional manufacturers were likely to fumble are all there. And the creation of hybrids that you point to is as relevant to the survival of traditional car manufacturers as the creation of sail/steam hybrids was to sailboat manufacturers roughly a century ago. (News flash, the big ones all made those hybrids, and none successfully made the transition to pure steam ships.)
This is not to say that Tesla will be a big player in the all electric age that is coming. But its odds are better than Ford, Toyota and GM.
- redm 9y agoMaybe. A few thoughts: 1) Automobile efficiency has moved dramatically since the 70's and that's due to government regulation. That regulation continues to push the industry as a whole. 2) The regulation goes beyond automobiles, were moving to alternative fuels as a people. Auto's will be drug along with that shift. 3) Automobiles and selling cars, in general, are a lot more than JUST the drivetrain. All that was really talking about with electric is a drivetrain. It's not clear to me yet that everything about a car has to be rethought to simply make it electric.
- trhway 9y ago>It's not clear to me yet that everything about a car has to be rethought to simply make it electric. it isn't "has", it is an opportunity to rethink what hasn't changed in the last 100 years. Google/Apple (and probably Uber) can attach drivetrain to their platform while Ford/GM just aren't capable of producing a platform to attach to their drivetrains. Tesla is an intermediate step in that direction and it looks like a good [though far from sure] candidate to make it successfully into the future of electric connected self-driving cars.
- btilly 9y agoThe problem that those books focus on is the difficulty in switching from an existing superior technology that meets the needs of an existing market to a new inferior technology that will some day meet the needs of an existing market, but does not yet. The problem is that the initial markets for the new technology are marginal ones that established companies do not easily get motivated to deliver to. And by the time that a mainstream audience is potentially interested, new companies have sprung up for these marginal markets that happily undercut the profit margins that established companies depend on. So everyone naturally migrates up market and this continues until established companies have such a small slice of market that they go bankrupt. In the case of cars the key performance characteristics that we need are ability to accelerate into freeway traffic, braking ability, range, and recharge time. Electric is naturally worse than gas on all of these characteristics at the same price point, however battery technology is improving at a predictable rate and it will eventually meet the characteristics that people need for daily life. At which point pure electric becomes viable for all of us. Therefore the prediction from 20 years ago was that the pure electric cars would likely to come from something that perhaps looks like a glorified golf cart, which will eat out the car market from the bottom up. Tesla doesn't look like this because Elon pursued an unexpected angle. He found that he could produce acceptable high performance electric cars long before the initial projection, because the profit margins on gasoline cars in that category were high enough to absorb the insane cost of the batteries. As battery technology improves, he is able to move down the quality curve. But to do so, he has to keep thin profit margins. Traditional manufacturers still face the traditional problem. They can't afford to offer an equivalent electric car at an equivalent price because their cost structures are too rich. But he's moving down the value chain and broadening, and not moving up. By the time he can offer a mass market car, he'll have an unbeatable edge. Of course even if Tesla's plan doesn't work, don't count out large electric golf cart companies moving up market into automobiles like Marshell Electric Vehicle Co Ltd, EZ-GO, Xiamen Dalle Electric Car Co. LTD and Polaris. Just as was predicted 20 years ago. Either way, I do not think it likely that most established automobile companies will survive the electric transition. If they do, it will be the first case that I know of where established brands are successful in switching to an inferior technology.
- agumonkey 9y agoYou got me wondering, how much efficient would it be to just burn fuel through a transformer to run a DC motor ?
- outworlder 9y agoYou could potentially make your engine, or whatever is burning fuel, more efficient by itself, if it is no longer required to drive a transmission and can run at any speed. Add a battery, and that enables you to do more stuff, such as regenerative breaking. Congrats, you got a hybrid now (not unlike a Chevy Volt).
- btilly 9y agoA large engine is generally more efficient than a small one. Most cars are in the 20% range. Steam turbines do better than 40%. So even with transmission and storage losses, having a centralized engine outside of the vehicle is much more efficient.
- oceanplexian 9y agoExcept, they didn't fumble on anything. GM released the Bolt several months ago, which has a longer range than the Model 3, and you can drive one off of a dealer lot right now. I test drove one and it's an awesome, fast, and affordable electric car. An average person, without any kind of pre-order, will not be able to drive off a lot with a 3 for at least another 2 years. Tesla has completely missed the ball. GM will be on their 3rd revision of the mass-market electric car by then. That's not even counting Toyota who are several revisions into the Leaf and many more into the Prius which eats Tesla's entire product line for lunch.
- felixhandte 9y agoI'm inclined to agree with you, except that people do buy Teslas and there is a huge waiting list for the Model 3. So your model seems to lack some explanatory power.
- jblow 9y agoChevy Bolt has sold 8,000 units total. Tesla expects to produce and sell 80,000 units of the Model 3 in 2017. We'll see if they hit that target, but come on ... in what reality can this be described as having "completely missed the ball"?
- sabujp 9y agolooks matter, I'd rather drive a 3 than a bolt/volt, leaf, or prius. + the safety / tech is much better in teslas (self driving prius anytime soon?).
- stcredzero 9y agoExcept, they didn't fumble on anything...GM released the Bolt several months ago With an already outdated charging system! In terms of styling and execution, I'd accept a position that GM is more competent than Tesla -- especially for the conventional vehicle-as-appliance crowd. But in terms of knowing where to go in the future, I think GM has a considerable disadvantage.
- btilly 9y agoThe Bolt costs $37,500 and according to rumor GM is losing $8-9000 per car for that. So let's say that the real cost of manufacture is $46,000. The Model 3 is a comparable car starting at $35,000 but is planned to sell at an average of $45,000 with an independently estimated profit percentage of around 25%. That means that the cost of production is somewhere around $34,000. If costs continue looking like that, as both companies scale electric car production up, which manufacturer would you prefer to be? Also I called them comparable, but they really aren't. After looking at safety in accidents, the driving assist and so on, my family doesn't consider them equivalent. We put a deposit on a Model 3 which we hope to buy next year. Traditional manufacturers are well behind Tesla on key amenities like that.