3 ms·
The author is trying to make an argument that it should have been done by the original researchers - since the implied conclusion is impossible and thus wrong,
by PeterisP 9y ago
The author is trying to make an argument that it should have been done by the original researchers - since the implied conclusion is impossible and thus wrong, they shouldn't have been allowed to publish the study with this conclusion without a proper interpretation; and even though he might have some interpretations, what matters is that it was their job to produce them and include them in the paper.
Quoting OP, "It is up to authors to interpret the effect size in their study, and to show the mechanism through which an effect that is impossibly large, becomes plausible. Without such an explanation, the finding should simply be dismissed."
- saidajigumi 9y agoAnd specifically, that the impossibly large effect has no plausible psychological basis, putting the onus on the researchers to perform additional due-dilligence in the face of data that is completely outside the bounds of the theoretical model(s) under discussion.