7 ms·
"This stuff happened before at a smaller scale by everyone," is a terrifying argument of normalization. It was wrong then. The norms were to crack down on that
by WorldMaker 9y ago
"This stuff happened before at a smaller scale by everyone," is a terrifying argument of normalization. It was wrong then. The norms were to crack down on that sort of thing when it happened. Now it's an excuse because the past wasn't perfect that we should normalize the worst excesses of wrongness as the new right. That's frightening.
- icebraining 9y agoAccepting reality as it is is not "normalization", it's just avoiding self-deception.
- WorldMaker 9y agoAccepting reality and feeling like there is nothing you can do about it is the very definition of "normalization". You can accept reality, feel that it's flaws are not "normal", and still strive to make it better and more normal.
- WorldMaker 9y agoMaybe useful analogy: "normal" here is used not as a synonym for reality but more in the way that it is used in computing, especially things like database architecture. I like to make my databases as normalized as I can. Doesn't mean that sometimes trade-offs don't result in realities/databases that aren't as normal as I would like.
- icebraining 9y agoAccepting reality and feeling like there is nothing you can do about it is the very definition of "normalization". Exactly. Except that second part is nowhere in the first post.
- lucideer 9y agoI think you've read something into the GP that wasn't there. I don't see them justifying or excusing bad practices anywhere in the post. Merely stating that they occurred (which is true). > The norms were to crack down on that sort of thing when it happened This what the GP is really getting at. This was never cracked down on in the past (I have no clue where you'd get the idea from that it was) because it wasn't done in the open as it is now. Now that it's blatant, we may finally have an opportunity to fight it.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> This what the GP is really getting at. This was never cracked down on in the past (I have no clue where you'd get the idea from that it was) because it wasn't done in the open as it is now. It wasn't done in the open because all kinds of structures, both formal and informal, were erected to crack down on it after the last time it was done so flagrantly in the open; OTOH, those have been systematically eroded over the last several decades so that with the political branches sand judiciary all in the hands of the same faction, they no longer function to restrain it.
- WorldMaker 9y agoEven if the GP wasn't explicitly justifying or excusing bad practices, I was pointing out that this very much is a justification and excuse we see a lot. It's a logical fallacy that has creepily become a dominant force in a lot of politics lately. > This what the GP is really getting at. This was never cracked down on in the past (I have no clue where you'd get the idea from that it was) because it wasn't done in the open as it is now. Now that it's blatant, we may finally have an opportunity to fight it. We have books now on the subject to even talk about it, and having that knowledge open helps to prevent the next one done in secret. That's not a very visceral "crack down", but it has been often considered sufficient, at least in the past, in the cases where the best we can do is post-hoc handling of the situation and further attempts at prevention. Yes, it's easier to fight things in the light, but don't mistake blatant violations for "light". The goal posts for the fight move when it is so blatant; the risks are that normalization happens and "oh well, this terrible thing is how things are done now" becomes true. Blatant acts mean the aggressors get to hold the light and control the narrative of what they point at. "We are doing nothing wrong, see, look at all this not wrong we are doing."