13 ms·
Mark Zuckerberg doubles down on universal basic income after a trip to Alaska
- mvid 9y agoI'm curious, isn't UBI basically untenable without single payer healthcare? Assuming he will be running for president, doesn't that mean he will be essentially a socialist candidate?
- kwellington 9y agobingo
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoSocialism is a spectrum. We have a socialized public transportation infrastructure, socialized power industries, socialized water and sewage industries, and a lot more, yet most people don't complain about that. UBI doesn't designate how peoples' income is used, it merely provides a baseline income to facilitate survival at least.
- ryanx435 9y agoAre you really making the argument that government provided services are socialism lite? So I guess the Romans were socialists then with their aquaducts.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- arethuza 9y agoServices like the UK NHS are certainly regarded as a form of socialism, as Aneurin Bevan NHS found said: "A free health service is pure Socialism and as such it is opposed to the hedonism of capitalist society." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneurin_Bevan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneurin_Bevan
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoYes, really, they are. And I'm not sure why this stuff is so surprising: one of the strong facets of scandinavian-style socialism is the government services and safety net. Single payer healthcare is often villified as "socialized health care". I'm pretty sure UBI and healthcare fit into the spectrum.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- digitalzombie 9y agoIt's not going to happen. Sanders could barely win cause they call him a socialist. Now with RNC threatening to take about ACA/Obamacare, single payer is easier to swallow for people who are afraid of new things or uninformed. UBI is such a new and radical idea compare to single payer. I doubt he'll win with UBI stance. Also I wouldn't vote for him. He got not political experiences. Donald Trump and Arnold are terrible politicians that are very ineffective compare to their predecessors, both have no political experiences at all. You can't run a government as a company.
- acalderaro 9y agoYou may have meant this, but I want to make sure people aren't mistaken - you can't run a government like a for-profit company, but you still need to run it like a company. And a company only exists as long as it has money. Our current government has a tremendous amount of debt. It's awesome to consider social programs like UBI, single payer, etc, but unless it's fiscally sustainable, we're stealing from our future generations. And that would be among the most horrific things a generation can do to another.
- digitalzombie 9y agoYou run it as if it's a country or a government. > Our current government has a tremendous amount of debt. That's a talking point the Republican always bring up even after the second election of Clinton and we had a surplus. Even Bush Sr had to raise the taxes because of his war debt. Bush Jr and Donald we're in debt with Trickle Down. The republican party, to me, is the ones that are pushing for running like a company. Recent Democrat runs it as if it's a government. An example is Clinton forgiving a foreign country debts, raising 50 million in vaccine, I doubt any company would do that while managing a surplus and bombing the middle east for Bin Laden. This is on top of knowing the key players that you've built relationship with while in politics. You can't just go in as President and just boss those people around. All of them have some sort of agenda they want and you have to know them well enough to compromise and get them on board with a bill. Clinton passed the bill of rights for healthcare. Bush close the donut loop hole and Obama got ACA. These aren't some running a company kind of move. Since ACA is in place Republican have failed to bring it down. But what people keep on making it as if it's simple as running a company. Making it easier for CEO person with no politic experiences run and become president. It's as easy as running a company.
- mc32 9y agoBut UBI does not necessarily mean everyone gets a "living wage". It covers a spectrum from very modest subsidies to outrageous* amounts which would bankrupt the system. *Outrageous meaning really unsustainable economically.
- xupybd 9y agoActually the UBI is popular in some other circles as well. It can be used to greatly simplify the tax and welfare systems. When you do that you shrink government, and that gets some of the right on board.
- axaxs 9y agoIf UBI is basic and agnostic, i'll support it. If it's geared only to low income earners, i'll fight it tooth and nail. -the right
- ramblerman 9y ago> If it's geared only to low income earners I'm not sure you understand UBI.
- axaxs 9y agoI do. And I really like the idea. But let's be realistic, when money comes up short, there will be rules and regulations put in place to screw people over. Just look at how they treat younger people with social security. I fully expect not to receive a penny from it in my lifetime.
- mychael 9y agoA thought experiment: You’re currently working in a call center making $9 an hour. You have no degree and marketable skills. Then you find out you’re now eligible for a paycheck that is equal to or more than you currently earn. What do you do?
- abstractbeliefs 9y agoAre you concerned that suddenly, no one would man the phones? These people will find that they suddenly live a much better quality of life. Some people will decide they want a quality of life even higher. With a lack of skills elsewhere, they may choose to continue their work, making $9/hr more than they would on UBI alone. If you think that no one would do this, if they could live on $9/hr before (even meager, miserly conditions), it would be the equivalent of erasing their previous cost of living with some cash on the side. Yes, they wouldn't work the same soul crushing job they had before. We'll see equally huge shifts in how we work, and how much is automated. For some people who didn't, perhaps they would now have the critical need to work remove and go to college, and develop those marketable or degree level skills and contribute far more.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoPoverty is incredibly stressful. I've been stuck working a minimum wage job living on my own while trying to go to college. That paycheck would be the difference between having panic attacks daily because I don't know if my scooter will last another month and being able to focus on school. While having some basic income to pay for necessities would be nice, it's not like the drive to improve myself and my income would go away. I'd bet college completion would go up significantly if UBI became the norm.
- RobLach 9y agoI'd probably quit my second night-shift job since now I can afford rent for my studio apartment with just one.
- lin_lin 9y agoI'd imagine that rents would rise in line with everyone getting an extra $x pm... Unless proper controls were put in place.
- ryanx435 9y agoIt's pretty obvious that Zuckerberg is trying to grow his public image in the national psyche to prepare for some kind of political run in the near future. He is not doing a good job, tbh, and if anything it's just further solidifying the perspective that he is an out of touch creepo
- boobsbr 9y agoAfter his message exchange published by Business Insider in 2010 (http://www.businessinsider.com/well-these-new-zuckerberg-ims-wont-help-facebooks-privacy-problems-2010-5 http://www.businessinsider.com/well-these-new-zuckerberg-ims...), I think people have a hard time taking anything he says seriously. Just print and distribute that article to ruin any campaign of his.
- fwn 9y agoThis must surely alienate potential supporters. I can not imagine someone getting to be US president with such shameful conversations being on the public record.
- Aron 9y agoUBI sounds a bit like minimum wage. Our normal tools of analysis will fail to find much of a problem so long as it's only a small difference from how things would have been without it, and a disaster otherwise.
- joejerryronnie 9y agoUBI is such a crock of BS. It was genius marketing naming it "Universal Basic Income" because it is anything but "universal". UBI is basically all of our current social spending thrown in a huge pot, multiplied by some factor, and doled out without any earmarks on how you can spend it (sure, maybe it is written as some type of negative tax bracket but the end result is basically the same). The more income you report, the less "universal basic income" you receive, while your taxes will skyrocket to pay for all of the new UBI spending. And the more people who decide to opt out of the workforce to pursue their passion projects, the higher those taxes on the working middle class will become. I guarantee Zuckerberg and his ilk will find loopholes to avoid paying a proportional UBI tax to their net worth. Once UBI is really exposed as the huge middle class tax it is, it will go down in political flames.
- esarbe 9y ago> The more income you report, the less "universal basic income" you receive, [. This is a misunderstanding. Under UBI, everybody receives the same monthly UBI. The size of the UBI does not depend on income. > ..] while your taxes will skyrocket to pay for all of the new UBI spending. Well, yes. Of course. Somehow this has to be paid for. But this will more probably be paid for by taxing corporations and shareholders instead of labour. For example by using the ~$2.0tn of US companies cash reserves.
- Jabanga 9y ago>But this will more probably be paid for by taxing corporations and shareholders instead of labour. This is not a good thing. It will discourage investment in the US. >For example by using the ~$2.0tn of US companies cash reserves. Corporations have trillions in debt. They need the cash reserves as a cushion to absorb potential losses from a future economic crisis. The economy is less fragile with companies having these cash reserves. Central economic planning like this, which just assumes "don't worry this will be fine as we take X from Y and spend it on Z" is so reckless. There are always grave negative unintended consequences from forcibly redistributing other people's income/wealth, and if you're not thinking hard about what they may be, you're going to overlook them.
- io-io2 9y agoSo, who is exactly going to pay for all of this? How is government going to collect funds in order to dole it out to everyone? Income tax? Mark Zuckerberg only makes $1 in income from Facebook. * http://www.businessinsider.com/mark-zuckerberg-only-makes-1-a-year-2015-6 http://www.businessinsider.com/mark-zuckerberg-only-makes-1-... But, before you go feeling sorry for Zuckerberg because he is working for free - for the good of the people, read the next set of articles... It appears that he has set himself up to NEVER pay any tax for the rest of his life. * http://www.cnn.com/2013/04/09/opinion/mccaffery-zuckerberg-taxes/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2013/04/09/opinion/mccaffery-zuckerberg-t... * http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/08/opinion/the-zuckerberg-tax.html?mcubz=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/08/opinion/the-zuckerberg-tax... It appears that the rest of us will be carrying the burden of UBI if it ever goes through.