6 ms·
“I want people who work for me to retire in their 50s and own their own boats,” she says. God that sounds terrible anyway. Do that many people want to retire -
by AndrewKemendo 9y ago
“I want people who work for me to retire in their 50s and own their own boats,” she says.
God that sounds terrible anyway. Do that many people want to retire - literally have nothing greater than themselves that requires their input on a daily basis - and go sit on a boat? What a waste.
- bitwize 9y agoEver own a boat? Believe me, it's not something you just sit on. Maintaining a boat can be hard, and fulfilling, work for a retiree.
- DrScump 9y agoHaving a large boat for recreation (rather than work, like fishing) is sort of a cultural symbol for wealth (in the USA, anyway). The California Lottery's current TV spot shows a youngish guy on a yacht, with a pony. It's perhaps inspired by the old Lyle Lovett song, "If I Had a Boat", which says: "If I had a boat I'd sail across the ocean and if I had a pony I'd ride him on my boat."
- gorkonsine 9y ago>God that sounds terrible anyway. Do that many people want to retire - literally have nothing greater than themselves that requires their input on a daily basis - and go sit on a boat? What a waste. I do! Not necessarily a boat, though; I'd rather have a nice house in the woods, and spend a lot of time traveling the world. But you seem to think it's a "waste" if someone doesn't want to spend their whole life working. For what? So I can spend most of my waking hours in the sheer hell which is the modern open-plan office? Why TF would I want to do that if I didn't have to? The sooner I don't have to put up with open-plan offices, the better. And what are you contributing to the world while you're working anyway? You really think that working on yet another Javascript framework, or building yet another re-spin of some website is improving the world in a substantive way? Out of all the HN readership, I'd guess that less than 5% actually does anything that's lasting and useful to society.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoWho said anything about working in an office? Out of all the HN readership, I'd guess that less than 5% actually does anything that's lasting and useful to society. I'd put it at closer to 1% - and that's the point. You have the causation backward though. If the purported goal is this mundane, hedonistic "retirement," then nobody will ever do anything lasting and useful because you can find an easy niche to fall into that lets you maximize your "leisure time."
- gorkonsine 9y ago>Who said anything about working in an office? You said before: "Do that many people want to retire - literally have nothing greater than themselves that requires their input on a daily basis" What else would people be doing if they don't retire, than working? And working means having to deal with all the crap that goes along with working: the open-plan office, meetings, the daily stand-up, office politics, etc. Why would anyone sane want to put up with this crap if they can afford not to? I sure wouldn't. >I'd put it at closer to 1% Yeah, I was being charitable. >If the purported goal is this mundane, hedonistic "retirement," then nobody will ever do anything lasting and useful because you can find an easy niche to fall into that lets you maximize your "leisure time." Yeah, but I don't see any alternative. Sure, I'd like to spend some of my time working on something really useful to humanity, and in fact that's one reason I got into engineering. The reality has been entirely different; nothing I've worked on has been important at all, and very little has even gotten any use. Most stuff just goes nowhere, gets canceled, etc. It's not like I can just go pick exactly what I want to work on. Notice how many applications NASA gets for the astronaut program, and how few of them are accepted. And even if I could pick some great project to work on, I don't want to do it if I have to work in an open-plan office, and I don't see office environments ever becoming a place where I'd be really excited to go every day. (i.e. cubicles were better than today's open-plan offices, but still pretty miserable.) So it's pretty simple: if I can afford to not work, I'd rather just do that than to put up with the annoyances that are unavoidable at work. If that means nobody ever does anything lasting or useful, then so be it.
- 9y ago
- RealityNow 9y agoRetirement = freedom. I don't know about you, but I want the freedom to not have to work for anybody else.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoNo, Power & Wealth = Freedom. The freedom to act as you want and to prevent others from acting on you. Retirement means you have taken yourself out of the power dynamic and limited your wealth potential.
- gorkonsine 9y agoWhat exactly is the point of having wealth if you have to put up with the same ol' rat race?
- zzalpha 9y agoNot being the OP, I can't speak for them, but it's worth noting that most people who are very wealthy but still work sure ain't participating in the same rat race you and I are... ... well, assuming you, like me, aren't fabulously wealthy, anyway. ;)
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoCause it ceases to be a "rat race" when you control the rules of the race.
- gorkonsine 9y agoHow exactly is someone with enough money to retire able to control the rules of the race? We're talking about real people here, people who have enough money to pay off a middle-class house and live off investments, not mega-wealthy people able to buy a mega-yacht like Paul Allen. Some middle-class guy who has enough money to retire is NOT going to be able to enjoy the workplace of his dreams working for someone else. The rational thing for him to do is retire and work on his own personal projects at home in peace.
- ImSkeptical 9y agoBoth of my parents are retired. My father spends his time with his amateur radio, writes magazine articles for niche publications (about amateur radio), works around the house, and sometimes consults with startups from his former field. My mother spends her time reading novels, taking care of grandchildren, visiting family members, and volunteering. Retirement seems like a good deal to me. It's not an inability to do things greater than yourself, it's the freedom to choose your pursuits without economic constraints (ideally). Owning a boat, and sailing for pleasure sounds like a lovely hobby. I don't see anything wrong with aspiring to spend time that way.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI don't see anything wrong with aspiring to spend time that way. At the end of the day it's just indulgence, not actually using your potential to the fullest. Going through life simply for pleasure is the sure fire way to have no lasting impact. If that's what you want to do, then great, but I get annoyed when mediocrity is touted as the greatest good.
- sangnoir 9y ago> Going through life simply for pleasure is the sure fire way to have no lasting impact. Not everyone wants that. Some people have had their run "making impact" and want nothing more than to spend time with their loved ones and enjoy their hobbies. I strongly doubt they'll be on their deathbeds thinking "I regret wasting all that time spent with family and doing things I love; I ought to have made a bigger impact at work instead"
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoNot everyone wants that. Sure, in which case they shouldn't be complaining about not having impactful work. I strongly doubt they'll be on their deathbeds thinking "I regret wasting all that time spent with family and doing things I love; I ought to have made a bigger impact at work instead" This is a false narrative and not mutually exclusive with doing important work. Most people die suddenly without a community surrounding them, family or otherwise. I'm dubious about the number of people who have great end of life with a loving family surrounding them.
- cm2012 9y agoI am a succesful, ambitious person by any measure and would do nothing but chill on a boat all day if I could.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoThat sounds like the antithesis of ambition. I think you need some self reflection.
- cm2012 9y agoI own a consulting firm and make probably top 5% of income for my age bracket. I'm just ambitious to do well to get freedom faster.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoSuccess =/= ambition. Congrats on the success but it's not the same as wanting to conquer some market or have outsized impact on some segment.