3 ms·
I didn't say "monopoly on violence". I said "overwhelming force". It is perfectly possible for governments to have a monopoly on violence but still not have ove
by pdonis 9y ago
I didn't say "monopoly on violence". I said "overwhelming force". It is perfectly possible for governments to have a monopoly on violence but still not have overwhelming force at their disposal: in fact that was the case when the US Constitution was written (for example, "keep and bear arms" in the 2nd Amendment was intended to include private ownership of warships). It is also perfectly possible for no entity to have a monopoly on violence and for no entity to have overwhelming force at its disposal compared to others (for example, in a number of American colonies, such as Pennsylvania in the early 1700s, while there was technically a "government", it did not have a monopoly on violence and private enforcement of laws was common, with all citizens being in roughly the same position as far as the force at their disposal).
I was merely recognizing the fact that, in today's world, governments, at least of developed countries like the US, do have overwhelming force at their disposal compared to private citizens. Whether that is because they have a monopoly on violence or for some other reason is irrelevant to the point I was making, which is simply that private citizens have to recognize and deal with the reality and limitations of what "ownership" means in today's world.