3 ms·
> And define widespread? Well, was this an isolated incident or not? Better yet, let's use your prior definition: > If someone refuses me, the white straight
by mistermann 9y ago
> And define widespread?
Well, was this an isolated incident or not?
Better yet, let's use your prior definition:
> If someone refuses me, the white straight male, the chance to buy something, I go somewhere else. That's not the case for some minorities however. If everyone won't provide wedding services for you, or everyone won't let you attend a class, or everyone won't sell you food, you can't live your life. Commonly discriminated minorities have to be protected because they have a right to do what they want as well. Just as you are free to do what you want, but that doesn't include murdering people. You are free to refuse service, but not based on things that mean that person can't get service anywhere.
- monocasa 9y ago> Well, was this an isolated incident or not? An event that had the implicit backing of the school administration sent a widespread message. Lynching in the wasn't 'widespread', but it's message was. According to this: http://time.com/3703386/jim-crow-lynchings http://time.com/3703386/jim-crow-lynchings Georgia had 586 total lynchings from 1877 until 1950. That's about 1 per county per generation. > your prior definition: Check usernames.
- mistermann 9y ago> An event that had the implicit backing of the school administration sent a widespread message. If you check the thread you'll clearly see my interest wasn't whether discrimination happens at all, it's whether it is to the point of being literally ostracized, as was stated. >> Could you name a two or three so we have some idea what you're talking about? > sure.. Perhaps don't impersonate other people if you don't want to be mistaken for someone else. Then again, I suppose by now I should know better than to expect reasonable discussion in threads such as these.
- monocasa 9y ago> If you check the thread you'll clearly see my interest wasn't whether discrimination happens at all, it's whether it is to the point of being literally ostracized, as was stated. You don't think putting the kid who was being 'uppity' in a coma doesn't cause imply ostracization for the others like him? Particularly when there was no repercussions from perceived authority figures? > Perhaps don't impersonate other people if you don't want to be mistaken for someone else. It's hard to 'impersonate' on a forum where every post has my username on it. Are you new to the internet or something?
- mistermann 9y agoIf you look up the word ostracize in the dictionary, you'll find no association with severity of injury. > It's hard to 'impersonate' on a forum where every post has my username on it. Are you new to the internet or something? I might ask you the same, answering a question that was asked specifically to another person isn't how you "internet".
- Latty 9y agoHe answered with a useful, relevant comment that provided the data point you were asking for. I'll back his experience up with another source: https://thegavoice.com/atlanta-police-release-details-12-recent-anti-gay-hate-crimes/ https://thegavoice.com/atlanta-police-release-details-12-rec... The point you were trying to make was that these were isolated incidents, that these people could live their lives around them. Reading that list, it's clear that isn't true - people threatening to kill you, beating you up, these aren't signs that you can live you life normally. Clearly, we aren't in the same place we were when we had state-supported segregation, but there is a reason these minorities are still protected, and there is still significant discrimination. This all means that there is a big difference between a community coming together in a space exclusively for them to try and push for inclusion, and discrimination.
- mistermann 9y ago> He answered with a useful, relevant comment that provided the data point you were asking for. Pardon me for nitpicking, but I can't help it. :) Here is the original post to which I replied: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14704091 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14704091 >> True, but socially, we've moved past that. There might be the rare individual baker who would not want to bake a cake for a gay wedding, because he's a devout Christian or Muslim or whatever and thinks homosexuality is a sin. But 98% of businesses won't care, as long as you can pay the bill. > Untrue. There are still many communities where you can be totally ostracized for those things. The point of contention is not whether some (and sometimes very severe) discrimination exists, it is whether as he claims that there are places where it is so common/frequent that you could be considered ostracized. I was looking for proof of the latter (his original assertion), not proof of the former (that which was provided, and now provided by you). > The point you were trying to make was that these were isolated incidents I'm not asserting anything, I am simply being skeptical and asking for proof of an extraordinary claim. If my "stance" pisses you off, I beg that you reconsider. To win over those who are still not "on your side" (and I'm not one of them, by the way), using exaggerations and half-truths is most definitely not the way to go about it, especially in this modern day "everyone's-a-victim" culture we live in. I am not your enemy, I'm just offering some well-intentioned advice on how to talk to your enemies in order to persuade them.