3 ms·
>The argument for that being, partially, that if the effect is caused by hunger that would predict widespread issues elsewhere in society that we do not see and
by SilasX 9y ago
>The argument for that being, partially, that if the effect is caused by hunger that would predict widespread issues elsewhere in society that we do not see and, partially, that there are no other psychological effects this strong.
I like that the author is invoking a consistency check from a separate domain (a very good practice!), but this particular one is over-reaching, for several reasons:
1) Judges don't personally bear a negative cost from overly harsh judgments (within the variation shown on these cases). So you can reasonably believe that judges are influenced by hunger (and likewise for anyone who knows their decision isn't life-or-death), but also believe that when there is more at stake, the general population is more careful and introspective (at these mild hunger levels).
2) We do in fact, anecdotally, see the "hangry" phenomenon.
3) We do see people rioting when resources are short, especially food. It would be surprising if you got the opposite result -- if judgments were hasty when you're very hungry, but not sorta-hasty when you're sorta-hungry.