3 ms·
No they haven' made it pretty clear that "jihadist groups had made progress." Please provide a citation for that. The official TSA website states: "Evaluated i
by bogomipz 9y ago
No they haven' made it pretty clear that "jihadist groups had made progress." Please provide a citation for that. The official TSA website states:
"Evaluated intelligence indicates that terrorist groups continue to target commercial aviation and are aggressively pursuing innovative methods to undertake their attacks"[1]
It says nothing about them making progress. Also that's a pretty nebulous statement. "Evaluated intelligence indicates"? Why not share the details with the public in the form of a redacted report?
Could you imagine the Surgeon General in the US issuing a statement that some food causes cancer and then not releasing any of the details? Of course not.
Withholding details that allow your citizens to make their own informed decisions regarding their safety and welfare is unacceptable.
Also did anyone ever assume that terrorists had stopped being interested in damaging aircraft? We are reminded of that every time we fly in the US and are berated and abused by TSA personal. So this isn't really a new development is it?
[1] https://www.dhs.gov/news/2017/03/21/fact-sheet-aviation-security-enhancements-select-last-point-departure-airports https://www.dhs.gov/news/2017/03/21/fact-sheet-aviation-secu...
- jeremymcanally 9y agoI don't get the aggressive tone here? I think the ban is stupid, but they actually have had significant intelligence that (a) they have stolen scanning equipment they are using in the development of explosives so they can avoid detection and (b) they have developed newer laptop bombs that are more dangerous and harder to detect. It took me literally 30 seconds on Google to find an article detailing it with links: http://heavy.com/news/2017/05/isis-laptop-bomb-threat-planes-carry-on-ban-europe-middle-east/ http://heavy.com/news/2017/05/isis-laptop-bomb-threat-planes...
- bogomipz 9y agoI didn't think my tonality was in any way aggressive. It certainly wasn't meant to be. Yes I read that story on heavy.com back in May. And heavy.com is not part of the DHS, the TSA or any other US government agency. Also the story on heavy.com is reporting about an unnamed source who reported it to another publication(the Washington Post.) So in effect you have - someone saying that someone told someone else this. That's hardly counts as a credible intelligence. That's what I would third-hand news. It's like the children's game of "Telephone."
- marcoperaza 9y ago>Also the story on heavy.com is reporting about an unnamed source who reported it to another publication(the Washington Post.) So in effect you have - someone saying that someone told someone else this. That's hardly counts as a credible intelligence. That's what I would third-hand news. It's like the children's game of "Telephone." This is a rather disingenuous argument. You're making a big fuss about heavy.com linking to WaPo, but why not just disregard the heavy.com article and look at the WaPo article? Further, it's pretty standard for news reports concerning intelligence matters to originate from anonymous sources.
- bogomipz 9y agoPlease read the entire context. I was originally responding to the statement: >"The government has made pretty clear over the last few months that the reason for the ban was intelligence that jihadist groups had made progress towards developing a laptop bomb." A Washington Post article citing an anonymous source is not the government making it "pretty clear." I'm not being disingenuous at all. The US Government making it pretty clear would be via a press briefing or some other such official statement.
- cft 9y agoThe analogy with food is flawed: the food does not deliberately cause cancer, and the would be announcement by the Surgeon General would not help the food to evade anti cancer treatments. Having said that, i am glad thst the ban is lifted.
- bogomipz 9y agoFood was not the point. The point is government agencies withholding information that helps their people: 1) think critically 2 allows them to make informed and rational choices 3) quantify risk
- marcoperaza 9y agoWhy do I as a private citizen need to know more detailed information about this? What can I possibly do as a private citizen with intelligence about terrorists planning to use laptop bombs on planes? My government has taken the action it deems appropriate to defend the country and its citizens, while still protecting the cover of the agent or asset that gave us the intelligence.
- bogomipz 9y ago>"Why do I as a private citizen need to know more detailed information about this? So you can make an informed opinion. In case you hadn't noticed there a lot of hysteria in the current administration. >"What can I possibly do as a private citizen with intelligence about terrorists planning to use laptop bombs on planes?" You can decide for yourself if you feel like it safe for you or your family to fly. >"My government has taken the action it deems appropriate to defend the country and its citizens, while still protecting the cover of the agent or asset that gave us the intelligence." Except that they didn't. Donald Trump exposed the source of the intelligence: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/16/world/middleeast/israel-trump-classified-intelligence-russia.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/16/world/middleeast/israel-t...
- marcoperaza 9y ago
- marcoperaza 9y agoThe whole controversy about Trump telling the Russians too much concerned the intelligence I am referring to. This, and the general existence of intelligence about progress by jihadis towards a laptop bomb attack, has been widely covered by just about every news outlet. It appears that an Israeli intelligence agent or asset was involved in uncovering the threat. The lack of public details is presumably to protect the cover of this agent or asset. I realize that government secrecy isn't popular around here, but the hostility to even this very obviously justified use of it is surprising.