5 ms·
>"The department of Homeland Security initiated the ban in March. It came into effect covering all flights to U.S. destinations from 10 airports in the Middle E
by bogomipz 9y ago
>"The department of Homeland Security initiated the ban in March. It came into effect covering all flights to U.S. destinations from 10 airports in the Middle East, including major travel hubs like Dubai, Abu Dabi and Dohar."
So how would a ban at flights originating at these airports prevent someone from exploiting this on a flight with a layover in this airport i.e while the plane was in route to one of these 10 airports?
>"While administration officials didn’t comment on any new and specific threats, ..."
This is used to justify every questionable action or inaction in the "Endless War on Terror." The claim is always "we can't comment because its an issue of national security." Do people of that "Nation" have no right to be informed about decisions being made on their behalf? Especially where safety is concerned?
Shouldn't this information be shared with the citizens of that nation so they can make up their own minds and make informed decisions? This level of infantilizing is just completely unacceptable. Those in the U.S security apparatus seems to take the view that they are parents and everyone else is a child.
- netcoder 9y agoFor international passengers during layover your personal baggage has to go through security check again before boarding next flight.
- throwawayjgo 9y agoIsn't the main reason for the ban the fact that they were worried security checks would be unable to detect bombs in devices like laptops in the first place?
- marcoperaza 9y agoThey are worried about security checks in those countries in particular.
- marcoperaza 9y agoThe government has made pretty clear over the last few months that the reason for the ban was intelligence that jihadist groups had made progress towards developing a laptop bomb. It is pretty reasonable for them to withhold details in order to protect sources and intelligence-gathering techniques.
- ceejayoz 9y agoIt seems unlikely they'd withhold that intelligence from the other Five Eyes nations and NATO partners, but to my knowledge they haven't implemented the same restrictions.
- marcoperaza 9y agoThe UK has: http://www.wired.co.uk/article/uk-laptop-ban-flights-explained http://www.wired.co.uk/article/uk-laptop-ban-flights-explain... The US and UK are obviously at higher risk of being targeted than most countries. We also don't know if the intelligence included information about the countries the jihadists intended to target. Also, other governments may have come to different decisions about how to handle this risk. Some countries let a million people pour across their borders without identity checks, others don't. It may be surprising to some, but who and what you vote for matters.
- valuearb 9y agoYes, lets put those laptop bombs in the hold.
- marcoperaza 9y agoI believe that US-bound luggage has to go through special screening.
- tyingq 9y agoThe amount of explosive you can fit into a laptop (and have it not be obvious) isn't a lot. So it works best if you can place the laptop directly against the hull of the aircraft. Putting it in the hold makes that less likely to happen. So while not optimal, putting them in the hold is an improvement.
- sleepybrett 9y agoHah, have you seen the "gaming" laptops out there, if you even replaces half of the battery with something like c4 it could easily blow a hole in a plane. That said I'm not advocating this ban at all, I think it's yet another in a long series of overreactions. But to imply that it couldn't be done is asinine.
- grenoire 9y agoThe reason why that information is not disclosed is not because they don't want their citizens to know. They don't want others to know; that's when it would actually compromise the security.
- bogomipz 9y agoYes that's the official "war on terror" party line you are parroting - "we can't tell you for your own good." Please provide one single example where communication and sharing of information with one's fellow citizens made them less safe.
- yellowapple 9y ago"Loose Lips Sink Ships" In other words: this sort of logic is by no means unprecedented in American history, for the simple reason that gathering information from the general public of a nation is a basic and common element of espionage against that nation. Whether or not such espionage is actually useful is a different story, but especially in this day and age of ubiquitous near-instantaneous and effectively-permanent public (or at least less-than-private) communication, there's every reason to believe that there are "enemy spies" among the general population, and therefore that the less information the general population receives, the less information the enemy can gather (at least through that particular avenue). I feel that this current instance of information-concealment is excessive, but it's not unreasonable to suspect that the likes of ISIS are collecting information from the American public, and thus not unreasonable to want to limit the information going out to the public in order to prevent hostile agents from obtaining that information.
- bogomipz 9y ago>"In other words: this sort of logic is by no means unprecedented in American history, for the simple reason that gathering information from the general public of a nation is a basic and common element of espionage against that nation" Please way what the precedent is then if this is not unprecedented in American history. >"... there's every reason to believe that there are "enemy spies" among the general population, and therefore that the less information the general population receives, the less information the enemy can gather (at least through that particular avenue" That statement is absurd - "keep all the citizens in the dark just in case one of them is a terrorist!"
- joelrunyon 9y ago> So how would a ban at flights originating at these airports prevent someone from exploiting this on a flight with a layover in this airport i.e while the plane was in route to one of these 10 airports? Have you been to a middle east hub? There's a specific security section you have to go through to get to the US bound flights - it's a completely different screening process and would be quite easy easy for them to check for laptops and get them checked as luggage.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]