4 ms·
Car privacy has been dead for a decade or more between cashless toll systems, cellular carriers and LPR. It's not coming back. Sticking your head in the sand a
by Spooky23 9y ago
Car privacy has been dead for a decade or more between cashless toll systems, cellular carriers and LPR. It's not coming back.
Sticking your head in the sand and pushing back against a system that is necessary to protect the safety of the driving public as automated vehicles become a thing is shortsighted.
Image recognition technology is such that you likely have a dozen or more government and private entities noticing you. You can buy data from cell carriers to know the average income of travelers on a road at a given time for 45 minute drive in urban and suburban areas.
Hell, I built a parking gate system for somebody with a raspberry pi and an outdoor security camera sourced from EBay -- and I'm a dope with no unique skill in these areas.
- biafra 9y agoThis is different. It is full surveillance everywhere, for every car and everytime. Not just some roads with cameras. Whose pictures (at least in Germany) are supposed not to be saved except for trucks.
- Spooky23 9y agoIt's there now. In the US, I'm sure the FBI and DEA have realtime feeds of phone movements for thousands or millions of phones. They had pervasive LPR surveillance a decade ago.
- ams6110 9y agoPerhaps. But you can put your phone on airplane mode or turn it off or just leave it at home if you don't want it to be tracked.
- mschuster91 9y agoYou really believe a phone is truly switched off? Unless the main processor kills the baseband power by GPIO, it is not - and baseband processors are a fairly easy exploit target, much more so for a state-level threat.
- edejong 9y agoI can leave it at home or buy a phone that has hardware validation processes to ascertain its correctness when turned off (or the transmitter system is disabled). I could put the phone in a Farraday cage or selectively raise the noise level of certain broadcast ranges within a limited range. I could kill the radio-IC and use a wifi mesh network. All of these measures are not prevented by federal law. Federally mandating trackers in a car is a completely different story. It will be illegal to remove these trackers, so a basic liberty will be taken away.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- danjoc 9y agoUber tracks you every 30 seconds. They struggle with it at that scale. http://highscalability.com/blog/2016/9/28/how-uber-manages-a-million-writes-per-second-using-mesos-and.html http://highscalability.com/blog/2016/9/28/how-uber-manages-a... 10 times a second made me laugh out loud.
- Spooky23 9y agoThe car transmits 10 times a second to assist other vehicles, signals or traffic management systems. The notion that big brother is going to track you in tenth if a second increments is not a thing.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoUnnecessary with radar, lidar, etc. What's the point? Oh, to invade privacy at some future date.
- Eridrus 9y agoI'm not a privacy zealot by any stretch, nor a car engineer, but it's not really clear that this system will actually do much to improve safety anyway. This won't be widespread for 20 years and the data quality coming out of cars will be very mixed. It seems pretty ridiculous to invest in this rather than allocating funds to things that are both useful immediately and in the long term, like actually painting lane markings everywhere.
- benchaney 9y ago> Car privacy has been dead for a decade or more between cashless toll systems, cellular carriers and LPR. It's not coming back. None of these things are remotely similar to legally mandated broadcasting of your location multiple times per second. They do not constitute a reason to sacrifice privacy for some nebulous safety gains. The rest of your comment is just FUD.
- DarkKomunalec 9y agoYour entire comment assumes all those things are permanent, when in fact, given the political will, they can easily be stopped. You provide no reason not to fight things getting even worse.