4 ms·
Nobody else wants to parse or host it because HTML works just fine. We don't need a new version from Google that so far only helps with search result visibility
by manigandham 9y ago
Nobody else wants to parse or host it because HTML works just fine. We don't need a new version from Google that so far only helps with search result visibility while losing flexibility and increasing the amount of effort publishers need to effectively maintain 2 copies of their site. This is a regression back to the days of WAP mobile sites.
It also does lock-in the users into Google's experience rather than actually visiting the site, which is a big issue, including problems like further centralizing traffic and data to a single company.
Google could easily penalize search results based on speed with a strict cutoff and the entire web would become faster within weeks. Also the largest ad server on the web is Google's own doubleclick which is one of the slowest. There are many better ways to improve performance and UX without AMP.
- endorphone 9y agoNobody else wants to parse it because HTML is a perfectly well functioning and accepted system Apple and Facebook, two of the largest content (re)publishers, have their own competing formats, and Bing currently spiders and parses AMP content as well. But thinking more holistically, many others simply pushed their content into apps, abandoning the web wholesale. Because while we can talk about how "well functioning" the web is, a virtually universal observation is that native apps that just wrap a web browser are sloggy garbage, and a big reason is that the HTML stack has grown so enormously flexible it becomes its own enemy. We don't need a new version from Google that so far only helps with google rankings I'm a charitable sort of person, so when someone like Google comes out with something I assess why they did it without presuming the worst. In this case we see silos appearing from Apple and Facebook, not to mention the appification of content, so Google looks for a way to keep the web compelling. And it is. When I see an AMP page there are a number of user-centric benefits that make it a draw as a link, not just speed but also best behaviors. I mean, many of the complaints on here about AMP seem just surreal. For instance if you open the carousel (an option for trending topics like Trump) and swipe, it brings you to the next story in the carousel. This outrages some that you aren't locked in the gutter of a given site, which is just bizarre and anti-user.
- coldtea 9y ago>Apple and Facebook, two of the largest content consumers, have their own competing formats Solving different problems on THEIR platforms. AMP is just imposing a non-solution to a non-problem on web users.
- ucaetano 9y agoIt isn't imposing, and as a user who frequently travels to emerging markets, it is a problem, and as a user, I see this as a solution, I usually prefer sites with the AMP logo because my general impression is that they load far faster. Maybe you're just not the target user for this, or even for the Internet. And to be honest, pretty much nobody reading HackerNews is the target user for this.
- monokh 9y agoSo slow page load speed is a non problem and speeding up delivering content is not a solution? Whether you like it or not, if you search on Google, you are using THEIR platform and you are THEIR user. What they have determined is that their users want to consume content faster than what is traditionally available on the web. So you'd rather wait 3 seconds to see your ebay listing than half a second? For the open web, javascript bloat and google is taking over the world reasons. That suits you fine but not the majority of users on Google. Why would Google be implementing a technology that is BAD for their users?
- jacquesm 9y ago> Why would Google be implementing a technology that is BAD for their users? Because it is GOOD for Google.
- manigandham 9y agoThis is about consolidating more time and data on their systems. You never leave a Google server with AMP. UX is secondary benefit used as marketing to force this on sites along with search rankings. Also Google owns Doubleclick which is the biggest and slowest ad server on the planet.