5 ms·
The problem with car sharing is that people tend to use their cars all at the same time: morning commute, afternoon commute, evening errands/leisure. If you go
by chongli 9y ago
The problem with car sharing is that people tend to use their cars all at the same time: morning commute, afternoon commute, evening errands/leisure. If you go out at 3am you'll see hardly any cars on the road. Rush hour? You'll hardly see any bare pavement.
- CalRobert 9y agoThis is a claim that would benefit from some data. There's certainly enough traffic during the day to suggest people aren't _all_ driving at the same time.
- awjr 9y agoIt's called the tidal wave effect and is the bane of public transport planning. You have to provide buses/trains to cope with rush hour when you make most of your profits, but then have no choice but to run the stock during the quieter day time. However it is used effectively in cycle track design. A 4m wide bidirectional cycle track can become effectively omnidirectional at rush hour significantly increasing capacity in one direction.
- miahi 9y ago* unidirectional
- mcv 9y agoBut the existence of rush hour means that a lot of people clearly are driving at the same time.
- Retric 9y agoSuppose only 50% of cars are part of rush hour. Now ride sharing can only cut parking by that same 50%. A less optimistic 75% means you can only cut parking by ~25%. Depending on the city these numbers may be high or low. However, one passenger ride sharing increases total miles driven. So in ultra congested city's it can actually make things worse.
- Twisell 9y agoThis issue is not limited to time sharing. It's equally inefficient to stack individual cars on highways during rush hours. Public transport is the best answers, but even so rush hours is still hard to manage. Rush hour is a global issue that could actually be mitigated by more flexible schedules and increase in remote work. So we shouldn't try to solve it by transportation alone. Interestingly jobs that can't be remote (factories, etc) usually already use alternative schedules that avoid office rush hours.
- CaptainZapp 9y agoI don't own a car (anymore). I live 1 minute from 2 tram - and 2 bus lines and 3 minutes from a train station with great connectivity to just about everywhere. I have a share in a car sharing cooperative with about a dozen cars, from a smart to a Mercedes transporter within five minute walking distance. Renting a car costs you $3-4 per hour plus 50 cents to 1$ per kilometer (half after 100 kilometers) The problem with car sharing is that people tend to use their cars all at the same time: morning commute, afternoon commute, evening errands/leisure Now here's the thing: With this setup you absolutely do not rent a car to get to work, or for leisure activities that you can perform equally well by using public transport. Plus: No parking hassle and no problem if you have a couple of drinks. Car sharing only makes sense for the occasional use of a car (which happens ca. 5 times a year, when I really need it) and not if you need a car on a regular basis, like getting to work. But then, it doesn't only make a ton of sense, it also offers very considerable savings at no downside. That, of course, only works when there's good public transport available as an alternative to car ownership.