5 ms·
Some related questions that I don't know where, or how, to ask: - Is there a “quantum” of space? Where/how is location stored? - If electromagnetic repulsion
by Razengan 9y ago
Some related questions that I don't know where, or how, to ask:
- Is there a “quantum” of space? Where/how is location stored?
- If electromagnetic repulsion is what makes matter “take space”, and if virtually all macroscopic phenomena are governed by electromagnetism and gravity, then could this reality be said to be “gravelectromagnetic”, and might there be other “dimensions” governed by other forces, like “cones” extending in differing “directions” from the subatomic scale? [0]
- Could gravity be the result of space trying to deflate/return to the pre-Big Bang singularity, kind of like pulling magnets apart? i.e. is gravity the “opposite” of, or a reaction to, “space?”
[0]: http://i.imgur.com/6meZmc2.png http://i.imgur.com/6meZmc2.png
- jacobolus 9y agoFrom what I understand nobody knows the answer to your first question, but there’s been speculation both ways. As for your second question, you might want to start with something like Feynman’s book QED.
- tombh 9y agoNothing to add, I just love where your questions send my mind, thank you.
- Razengan 9y agoYou may enjoy contemplating a sort of "epiphany" that I had during that usual pondering of imponderables: That the default or base state of existence may not be nothing, not "not even nothing", but rather Everything. ... Instead of viewing the origin of all reality/creation as things being added to a canvas of blackness/emptiness/voidness, rather consider that "Existence" may be a subtractive process: akin to holes being poked into a canvas of white, or bubbles in a boiling liquid. (I mean even before the Big Bang, or the classic "Who Created God"/Prime Mover/First Cause question – humans are given to assuming that the start of anything must be Zero or Nothingness, that the end of everything is Oblivion, and that may not be the case.) Our existence is a "filter", our perceptions being a very limited subset of everything that's around us, of select wavelengths and frequencies and etc. This entire universe could just be a transient bubble inside a flood of Everythingness. [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_vacuum#Existential_threat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_vacuum#Existential_threa...
- jsmthrowaway 9y agoThis is a common theme many human societies and cultures have developed, and it makes a lot of sense when you really (really) think about it. When you take it further, you realize that also implies everything being connected fundamentally, which is an another interesting thought space to explore with a litany of deep implications, particularly around consciousness.
- anentropic 9y agoit doesn't obviously imply anything to do with consciousness
- furyofantares 9y agoI've had the same thought about the starting from nothing rather than everything, but in an entirely different context. Axiomatic Set Theory is taught starting with the empty set as an axiom and along with a small number of additional axioms, and from that you can build the integers and rationals and real numbers as well as an impressive hierarchy of different infinities. And one thing that's proved is there is no largest infinity, no set that contains all sets. There isn't an Everything set that's consistent with the Peano axioms. However, you could build the entire system starting with the Everything set and similarly modify all the axioms to be analagously subtractive rather than additive, deriving in some sense every inverse theorem, including that there is no empty set, no Nothing. When you do this you immediately at working with insane objects and intuition fails miserably in a way that building the other way doesn't.
- enugu 9y agoI remember a mention somewhere of this kind of approach to inverse foundations for set theory, but lost track of the reference. IIRC, the approach didnt have problem with empty set, but would allow the existence as a default until some obstruction. So, 'large sets' (nowadays called proper classes) would exist.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- resu_nimda 9y ago- The Planck units [0] are generally associated with the attempt to quantize space and time. - Macroscopic phenomena are in turn governed by microscopic phenomena, where the strong and weak forces dominate, so I would say our dimension is equally governed by those. At high energies we know the electromagnetic and weak forces combine into the "electroweak" force, and it is commonly hypothesized that at even higher energies (such as those seen only during the very beginning of the Big Bang), all of the forces are unified. If you already knew that or were talking about something else, my apologies. - There is the concept of the Big Crunch, where gravity would pull the universe back to a single point, perhaps in an infinite cycle. To the best of our current knowledge though, the expansion of the universe is actually accelerating, and gravity will not overtake it. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck_units https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck_units
- chiefofgxbxl 9y agoFrom my understanding (just a Quantum Physics I class, I could be wrong here) the Planck units quantize space or time to the extent that they define the smallest thing we can practically measure due to Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle, but they do not preclude that things can actually be smaller than that. That is, something like length or time can be continuous, but our measurements can only ever be discrete multiples of the corresponding Planck constants. For example, a really small object can have a length smaller than the Planck length, but we wouldn't truly know how long it was because the Planck length acts as a fundamental limit on the precision/granularity of our measuring instruments.
- richrichardsson 9y ago> For example, a really small object can have a length smaller than the Planck length, but we wouldn't truly know how long it was because the Planck length acts as a fundamental limit on the precision/granularity of our measuring instruments. Would that be, to all intents and purposes, undetectable by us then? If so then that might be a possible explanation of "dark matter", assuming all these things were individually smaller than the Planck length.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThere are a number of interesting places to start, if you want to be traditional start with reading about the Standard Model, if you want to be avant-garde start reading about String Theory :-). I have come at the question a bit like you have, starting with Faraday and Maxwell for the electromagnetic theory, adding Lorentz and Einstein for the time and space dilation effects of general relativity. And when you start looking at light as an expanding wavefront alternating between a magnetic form and a electrostatic form and thinking about how the frequency of that oscillation relates to the other fundamental constants in the universe like the speed of light and the planck constant, you might start to wonder, as I have, whether a wavefront at the speed of light would mass appear as a side effect because it was distorting space time so hard it was dragging it around? Its a lot of fun to think about.
- ryukafalz 9y ago>Where/how is location stored? Is this even a meaningful question? My understanding of "where" is that it's referring to a location within space.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoCould gravity be the result of space trying to deflate/return to the pre-Big Bang singularity, kind of like pulling magnets apart? i.e. is gravity the “opposite” of, or a reaction to, “space?” I may be off the mark with what you believe, but just in case: It's a common misconception that the big bang originated at a specific point. The big bang seems to have happened everywhere simultaneously, so it wouldn't be true to say that gravity is pulling everything back toward a point of origin. Here's an excellent video on misconceptions about the universe: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XBr4GkRnY04 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XBr4GkRnY04 (Ironically, the video was created because the creator was a scientist, yet they fell into the trap of believing something incorrect to the point of being publicly mistaken about it. The universe is extremely counterintuitive!)
- jsmthrowaway 9y agoHoly shit, the Big Bang happened everywhere simultaneously because the Big Bang brought quantum fields into existence. Wow. I get it now. As a non-physicist, wording it like that made a lot that I didn't understand suddenly click.
- andyjohnson0 9y ago> the Big Bang happened everywhere simultaneously Until the big bang happened there wasn't any "where" for anything to happen in
- jdkuuuu 9y agoThis really makes it sound like a simulation
- RUTHLESS_RUFUS 9y agoThe Big Heap Allocation.
- monort 9y agoThis only applies if the universe is infinite. We don't know it for sure, though we have a lower bound of the universe size at 250 Hubble volumes: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1745-3933.2011.01040.x/abstract http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1745-3933.2011.... And infinite universe brings strange phenomenons, like our doppelgangers far away, that are exactly like us.
- piotroxp 9y agoFind Piotr Slupski on Quora and read his answers
- comboy 9y agor/askscience on reddit is my go to place for this kind of questions
- zecg 9y agoI can recommend this: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/30201328-reality-is-not-what-it-seems https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/30201328-reality-is-not-...
- peter303 9y agoPlancks quantum of action says there a minimum length of space 10^-35 meters below which no experiment can measure. Some asume this is a quantum of space, but not necessarily so. Some physicists suggest the universe is very strange at this length scale and may a sea of boiling virtual particles.