21 ms·
The capital sharp S in now part of the official German orthography
- lvh 9y agoWhile the glyph is still missing from many fonts, Unicode 5.1 designated a code point for it: U+1E9E ẞ LATIN CAPITAL LETTER SHARP S
- the8472 9y agoAnd it has been in unicode since 2008. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_%E1%BA%9E https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_%E1%BA%9E
- quink 9y agoArguments against: ß is a ligature, one of ss. ffl is a ligature, but that doesn't mean FFL should have one too. Just get rid of it. Switzerland did and they're managing just fine. Capitalisation in Unicode for German locales is just a headache, and this really doesn't help. How would one enter it on a keyboard? Argument for: ss is pretty much the same shape as SS, and Dutch has ij and IJ. It's just an optional ruling, anyone can do whatever they want and as with the new orthography, they did. Prescriptive linguistics is useless anyway, especially over the past two decades in German-speaking regions.
- tomjakubowski 9y agoSpelling reform got rid of quite a lot of the use of ß in (German) Standard German, didn't it? As a German learner, I actually quite like the eszett, as the ß is a very obvious hint that the preceding vowel (if "monophthongic") is long. > Capitalisation in Unicode for German locales is just a headache, and this really doesn't help. Huh, if anything doesn't this make it easier? Replacing one code point (ß) with two (SS) when capitalizing seems like a bigger headache.
- raverbashing 9y agoActually it's a ligature of SZ (as even it name says, eszet)
- kuschku 9y agoAnd it has a separate, and distinct sound from s or sz, and has a separate meaning for the pronunciation of the surrounding letters than ss. For example, Maße and Masse are only possible to differentiate due to ß.
- legulere 9y agoIt started out as a ligature of ſ and ʒ, forms of s and z that don't exist anymore today in German. And it became a letter like æ did. Also this happened at a time where z was pronounced differently from how it is pronounced today.
- quink 9y ago> It started out as a ligature of ſ and ʒ I know that, but again prescriptive linguistics vs. descriptive and descriptive definitely says ss.
- legulere 9y agoSs is horrible because double consonants signify short preceding vocals in German. Yet ß is preceded by long vocals. If you want to replace it, then just with s.
- vacri 9y agoI can't speak for other languages, but in English æ isn't really a letter in the modern tongue. It's just used when someone wants to be 'fancy'. You'll see athenaeum far more than you see athenæum, for example.
- kuschku 9y agoHe might be referring to danish, where æ is a standard letter used all over the language.
- faho 9y agoAs a german, I see this as a step in the wrong direction. The sharp S is a PITA to begin with, so I'd rather abolish it completely. Now there's a whole bunch of complications coming from this - how do I type this? To type lowercase "ß", I press the key above "p" (in the same position as with qwerty) and "ü" (to the right of it), which will do "?" when pressed together with shift. So do we move "?" somewhere else? QWERTZ is already bad for e.g. programming with all its punctuation (typing "]" means holding altgr and pressing 9), so that would make it even worse. Personally I'd rather use composing since that would mean I could continue ignoring "ß" like I already do (I use "ss" instead), only now I'll ignore both forms. Note also that a capital "ß" is barely useful to begin with - no word begins with it, so the only reason to use it is to write a word in ALL CAPS.
- bla2 9y agoAs a German, I disagree with you. German's not English, even though you might prefer if it was. Others don't. It's fine that it uses the letters it ended up with historically. This change fixes an internal inconsistency, your reply seems fairly irrelevant. It feels like replying to some bugfix in, say, Ruby with something like "I never liked Ruby anyhow".
- faho 9y ago>This change fixes an internal inconsistency I agree that it does! "ß" turning into "SS" when uppercasing is awful. >It feels like replying to some bugfix in, say, Ruby with something like "I never liked Ruby anyhow". In this analogy, "Ruby" would be the German language. And in that case... yes, I can disagree with a bugfix if it makes matters more complicated! I can argue that something is a misfeature, like ß is. Removing it would improve the situation, especially from a technological viewpoint. >German's not English, even though you might prefer if it was That's kind of a low blow. "ß" is not a defining feature of the German language.
- ainar-g 9y ago>"ß" is not a defining feature of the German language. It is though. As a language-lover and German-learner, AFAIK, no other language uses this letter. "ß", along with less exclusive "ä", "ö", and "ü" are what distinguishes German orthography from other languages.
- JepZ 9y agoAnd how do I type thiß capital sharp S? The Unicode input seems a little complicated :-/ CTRL + SHIFT + u1E9E = ẞ
- bla2 9y agoOn Windows, altgr-shift-ß.
- kuschku 9y agoon linux: [AltGr]-[Shift]-[S]: ẞ
- simias 9y ago[compose]-S S also works
- kuschkufan 9y agoactually Capslock + ß, on Fedora at least
- kuschku 9y agoboth work here (Ubuntu and Arch)
- yellowapple 9y agoOn a Unix-like system with X11 and a compose key, I believe Compose + S + S should work (away from my computer, so can't test).
- zzleeper 9y agoInterestingly, this is the opposite as what happened in Spanish [1] We had two extra letters, CH and LL that were just ligatures, so we dropped them and everyone is better off. [1] http://www.rae.es/consultas/exclusion-de-ch-y-ll-del-abecedario http://www.rae.es/consultas/exclusion-de-ch-y-ll-del-abeceda...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- yellowapple 9y agoWell damn. Now I have to learn myself a new alphabet song.
- kuschku 9y agoIn German, ßẞ is not just a ligature. Since the recent orthographic reforms, ßẞ means a very specific sound that’s separate from s, and from ss.
- 1maginary 9y ago> ßẞ means a very specific sound that’s separate from s, and from ss Kinda. ⟨ss⟩ and ⟨ß⟩ are both /s/, ⟨s⟩ being /z/ for contrast, but they do affect how you read the preceding vowel.
- filmor 9y agoAs other's have written already, ß is not simply a ligature. Since the orthography reform in the nineties it universally indicates that the preceding vowel is lengthened, dropping it would lead to a large amount of homophones. An example is Maße (measures) vs Masse (mass).
- 4ad 9y agoWhat a non-issue.
- 1maginary 9y ago>La eliminación de los dígrafos ch y ll del inventario de letras del abecedario no supone, en modo alguno, que desaparezcan del sistema gráfico del español. Important distinction to make. They are still part of written Spanish. To be completely honest I didn't even know they were part of the alphabet before and I wouldn't know how that affects everyday life. The capital Eszett is a new letter that (almost literally) no one used before
- joubert 9y agoFrom Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ß https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ß): In German orthography, the grapheme ß, called Eszett (IPA: [ɛsˈtsɛt]) or scharfes S (IPA: [ˈʃaɐ̯.fəs ˈʔɛs], [ˈʃaː.fəs ˈʔɛs]), in English "sharp S", represents the [s] phoneme in Standard German, specifically when following long vowels and diphthongs, while ss is used after short vowels. The name Eszett represents the German pronunciation of the two letters S and Z. It originates as the sz digraph as used in Old High German and Middle High German orthography, represented as a ligature of long s and tailed z in blackletter typography (ſʒ), which became conflated with the ligature for long s and round s (ſs) used in Roman type. The grapheme has an intermediate position between letter and ligature. It behaves as a ligature in that it has no separate position in the alphabet. In alphabetical order it is treated as the equivalent of ⟨ss⟩ (not ⟨sz⟩). It also has no traditional capital form (although some type designers have introduced forms of "capital ß" de facto). It behaves like a letter in that its use is prescribed by orthographical rules and conveys phonological information (use of ß indicates that the preceding vowel is long).
- simon_o 9y agoThis seems to be a poorly writen article for various reasons: > The grapheme has an intermediate position between letter and ligature. It might have been a ligature in the past, but it is definitely not a ligature today. A ligature is a purely typographical device that is completely interchangeable with the non-ligature variant. This is not the case with ß. > It behaves as a ligature in that it has no separate position in the alphabet. Not having a separate position is not sufficient evidence that it is a ligature. ä, ö, ü also don't have separate positions when ordering stuff. > It also has no traditional capital form (although some type designers have introduced forms of "capital ß" de facto). It had the same traditional from for almost 130 years. Yes, there are a few stylistic variations on the traditional forms, as well as some early experiments trying something completely different which have never been widely adopted. > It behaves like a letter [...] It is a letter, just like w is a letter, not a vv ligature.
- rini17 9y agoParselsprachebenutzerInnen feiern! ẞssssßs sss!
- microcolonel 9y agoLanguages with priesthoods make me chuckle.
- noarchy 9y ago>Languages with priesthoods make me chuckle. You'll likely be downvoted by the way you made your point, but there is a point to be made here. Native English-speakers, for instance, probably couldn't fathom there being an official body that makes decisions like this about the language. It just so happens that some of these official bodies make a point to stave off the influence of English on their respective languages (for better or worse - I won't argue either here).
- emodendroket 9y agoRight, we don't have an academy of English. Instead we have several competing organizations publishing dictionaries and style guides to the same purpose.
- BurningFrog 9y agoSo ß is finally out of β-test!
- champagnepapi 9y agoASK HN: Why is this at the top of HN?
- roywiggins 9y agoBecause it was up voted. HN likes linguistic things, and typographical things, and Unicode things, and this is all three. And the weird .toUpper behavior required by ß->SS is an old example of string-handling pitfalls that non-German programmers probably remember (and obviously German ones know about the issue!)
- weinzierl 9y agoMost commenters seem to be under the impression that German orthography gained a new letter, or that uppercase sharp S will be the norm. This is not the case. From the original article: > The change doesn’t mean that everyone now has to use a Capital Sharp S. The previous spelling of replacing ß with SS in uppercase texts remains the default for the time being. The Council for German Orthography sanctioned the use of the uppercase ß. They just accepted the fact that it exits and is used. No more, no less. That being said, I find it a bit ironic that at first Unicode had to bend over backwards to allow the strange surjective mapping that only German requires, only to later resolve to problem the easy way with the introduction of a new character. I mean it's probably the right thing to do, because both things are used in German, but on the other hand it introduces a lot of complications just for one very specific special case.
- detaro 9y agoIt's a bit more important than that, since ẞ didn't "exist" in official use before (if you have a name with ß, the spelling on your ID card can now use ẞ, instead of SS where its unclear if it is ss or ß, now it becomes valid in schools, ...), but yes, it's only an accepted variant now.
- aristidb 9y agoI for one find this GROẞARTIG. Maybe not using umlauts or writing nouns in lower case is more efficient, but sometimes it feels good to have something like this.
- Pxtl 9y agoSo when will we see it in string.toUpper()?
- cmurf 9y agoWere words using ß ever spelled with sz? The ß is pronounced as sz (in German) and I think it's a ligature of old German shrift s which is a line when found in the middle of a word, and z. So again, were words like strasse, spelled as strasze and hence the ß? And then later it became ss as the sharp s? Edit: OK nevermind. Other comments and wikipedia discuss this.
- virtualritz 9y agoWhat a typographic disaster. Making an uppercase version of a lowercase ligature was bad idea from the get go. I suggest to type designers who want to add this symbol to do an SZ or SS ligature. Caveat: I studied typography in another life.
- pluma 9y agoIt's not a ligature. It's not even a variant anymore. Yes, in orthography it's defined in contrast to "ss" but it is not acceptable to substitute "ss" for "ß" in names. Mesner, Messner, Meßner and Meszner are different names. Typography is not just about making pretty shapes that work nice alongside each other.
- beders 9y ago"straße".toUpperCase() is still "STRASSE", though. Wondering how any current i18n system will get out of this mess ;)
- Tomte 9y agoAgain, an unelected body decides on my mother tongue (the orthography reform of 1996 was the same, but more catastrophic). The Rechtschreibrat is tasked with codifying existing changes to the language, not inventing something new. Capital ß does not exist and never did. Before a few years ago when Unicode accepted it and a handful of designers played with it, there was exactly one documented occurence in hundreds of years of the language: the title page of one singular run of an orthography book in the GDR. The runs before and after that had SS. I think there should have been an uprising (violent, if necessary) in 1996, but the ship has sailed. Very few people care about their language. Heck, most people get the simplest parts of orthography wrong and imitate English patterns (even the famous contatenative property is dying, people are just writing constituent words serially, with space in between). Never forgive, never forget.
- dcposch 9y ago> I think there should have been an uprising (violent, if necessary) in 1996, but the ship has sailed. Lol you want a popular revolution over the Rechtschriebereform? Strong contender for First World Problem hall of fame here.
- Tomte 9y agoYou're a prime example of what I've talked about: people without any love for or sense of their language (whichever one in your case).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kupiakos 9y agoYou say that as if it's an inherently bad thing. Different people have different passions, and assuming one's own interests are "more important" seems kind of ridiculous to me. Most people simply use their language to communicate, and nothing more.
- 9y ago
- mkesper 9y agoFirst of all, it's not a 'sharp' s, as one can see compairing 'Maße' and 'Masse'. I doubt this will be used in practice. Many people nowadays are confused by last orthography rules and even write 'Straße' wrongly with double-s.
- dEnigma 9y agoWell, it is commonly called "scharfes S" (sharp S), at least in Austria -- and I'm pretty sure in Germany too. I certainly plan to use it in practice, and have already started telling my friends and relatives about it. The substitution with "SS" always rubbed me the wrong way, since it should be "SZ". The capital "ẞ" solves that problem for me, and I no longer have more letters in the uppercase version of certain words, which is nice.
- Raz2 9y agoSome street signs in the town where I live (Weingarten) are written with double-s. It is really confusing.
- pluma 9y agoThe article and comments are a bit misleading. The actual official document is a bit clearer: > E3: Bei Schreibung mit Großbuchstaben schreibt man SS. Daneben ist auch die Verwendung des Großbuchstabens ẞ möglich. Beispiel: Straße – STRASSE – STRAẞE. http://www.rechtschreibrat.com/DOX/rfdr_Regeln_2017.pdf http://www.rechtschreibrat.com/DOX/rfdr_Regeln_2017.pdf (page numbered 29, page 27 of the PDF) Roughly translated: > When writing in uppercase one writes SS. Additionally the use of the uppercase ẞ is also possible. Example: Straße – STRASSE – STRAẞE. In other words, it's an officially blessed variant spelling. The new standard actually defines several variant spellings for cases that have been debated since the last reform, e.g. Delfin ("new") vs Delphin ("old"). It's a lot more forgiving, standardizing a lot of existing usage rather than making up arbitrary rules. It's far more descriptive than the previous spelling reform some fellow Germans still like to bitch and moan about. The reason the capital sharp S is singled out as being newsworthy is mostly that it's one of the few additions; almost everything else is just establishing widespread non-standard variants as permissible.
- Grue3 9y agoI don't like it, it looks too much like B. At least lower-case version stands out among its lower-case peers, but the big one is the same size as B.
- Tepix 9y agoSo, I've read a few articles now but I'm left wondering: How do I enter the new character "ẞ" on a german keyboard? Pressing the key for "ß" + shift obviously doesn't work (it yields a questionmark). (I used cut + paste to get the ẞ into this post)